Determine whether assent, action on another's behalf, and control establish agency.
Distinguish agency status from employment status and authority to bind a principal.
Apply loyalty, care, disclosure, and accounting duties to concrete transactions.
Identify principal obligations and select remedies for an agent's breach.
Analyze termination, surviving duties, and California-specific protections.
Estimated reading time: 24 minutes.
WHY
Why it matters
Agency determines when one person's undertaking creates duties to another and supplies the foundation for contract and vicarious-liability analysis. California essays commonly place these issues inside a business dispute: a purchasing representative receives a supplier payment, a manager diverts a transaction, or a former agent continues dealing with customers.
KEY TERMS
Key terms
Principal
The person for whom an agent undertakes to act and whose control governs that undertaking.
Manifestation
Words or conduct expressing assent or another legally relevant intention.
Fiduciary
A person entrusted to act for another who owes loyalty within the entrusted relationship.
Actual authority
Authority arising from the agent's reasonable understanding of the principal's manifestations to the agent.
Ostensible authority
California terminology for authority the principal causes or permits a third person reasonably to believe the agent possesses.
Disgorgement
A remedy requiring surrender of gains obtained through wrongful conduct.
Renunciation
An agent's manifestation that the agent will no longer act for the principal.
Power given as security
A qualifying power protecting a holder's interest in property or an obligation, rather than merely an expected agency fee.
CORE
Core content
1.1.1.1 Agency begins with an entrusted undertaking
Under Restatement (Third) of Agency section 1.01, agency arises when a principal manifests assent that another act on the principal's behalf and subject to the principal's control, and the other person assents or otherwise consents. The three factual inquiries are therefore assent, representative purpose, and control. California Civil Code section 2295 describes an agent as a person representing a principal in dealings with third persons.
Assent can be explicit: an owner asks a representative to negotiate a purchase, and the representative accepts. It can also appear through conduct: the owner repeatedly assigns purchases, supplies funds and instructions, and accepts the representative's performance. The parties need not use the word agency or understand its legal consequences. Under Restatement section 1.02, a contractual label is relevant evidence but does not override the relationship actually created.
The following table separates formation requirements from facts that merely support an inference.
Table 1. Formation requirements and common substitutes
Inquiry
Supporting facts
Insufficient substitute
Mutual assent
An owner requests purchases; the representative accepts and begins purchasing.
The representative unilaterally announces an appointment the owner never authorized.
Acting on behalf
The representative seeks goods for the owner's business account.
A reseller buys inventory for its own account and later resells it.
Principal's control
The owner retains the right to redirect purchasing priorities during performance.
A customer specifies only the final product and delivery deadline.
Objective relationship
The parties' actual practices satisfy the elements.
A contract uses the title consultant without describing actual practices.
Neither consideration nor payment is required. A friend who accepts an unpaid undertaking to purchase equipment for an owner can become an agent. A gratuitous agent owes duties within the undertaking; the absence of compensation is relevant to the circumstances of performance, not an automatic exemption from loyalty or reasonable care. A promise to help in the future must still be distinguished from an accepted undertaking or conduct establishing agency.
Capacity is asymmetric. California Civil Code section 2296 permits a person with capacity to contract to appoint an agent and permits any person to be an agent. Thus, an agent's minority does not itself prevent the agent from affecting a competent principal's legal relations. Whether the minor separately incurs enforceable contractual obligations is a different question.
Writing requirement. Ordinary agency can arise orally or through conduct. California Civil Code section 2309 supplies the equal-dignities rule: authority to enter a contract that the law requires to be in writing must itself be given in writing. Separate the existence of a service relationship from legally sufficient authority to execute the particular transaction.
A Personal relationships do not substitute for assent
Marriage, kinship, and shared ownership do not, standing alone, establish that one person is another's agent. They may explain access, familiarity, or an opportunity to act, but they do not establish an accepted representative undertaking subject to control. A spouse's knowledge of household finances does not automatically authorize management of the other spouse's separate business. Conversely, repeated instructions to negotiate for that business, followed by accepted performance, can establish agency through conduct. In an essay, identify the manifestations and retained direction rather than treating the relationship label as proof. Any authority independently supplied by marital-property law presents a separate legal basis.
1.1.1.2 Control defines agency without requiring constant supervision
The relevant control is a right to direct the undertaking, including giving interim instructions, rather than constant supervision of every movement. A principal may allow broad discretion over methods while retaining the right to change the objectives or limits of the representative's work. Restatement section 1.01 does not require the detailed physical control associated with an employee relationship.
An independent contractor can therefore be an agent. A broker may operate a separate business, use independent judgment, and represent a client subject to the client's instructions. A contractor hired solely to deliver a completed product may instead act on its own behalf. Employment and independent-contractor tests serve additional purposes; an employment label alone does not resolve agency or automatically determine tort liability.
A lender's ordinary protective restrictions, such as requiring financial reports or limiting additional borrowing, do not by themselves turn a borrower into an agent. Extensive intervention in business operations may support a different conclusion when accompanied by action on the lender's behalf. Likewise, a purchaser buying goods for resale usually acts for its own account even though the original supplier benefits economically.
Fig 1 separates formation from the later authority inquiry. A failed formation element redirects the analysis rather than answering every possible third-party claim.
Fig 1. From relationship facts to agency status Key point: Mutual assent, representative action, and control must be evaluated before the scope of authority.
flowchart TD
A["Mutual assent manifested?"] -->|Yes| B["Acting for the principal?"]
A -->|No| E["Actual agency not established"]
B -->|Yes| C["Principal retains interim control?"]
B -->|No| E
C -->|Yes| D["Agency duties attach"]
C -->|No| E
D --> F["Analyze authority separately"]
E --> G["Consider ostensible agency separately"]
Agency status establishes the relationship; authority determines which acts can affect the principal. Actual authority depends on the principal's manifestations to the agent and the agent's reasonable understanding. Apparent authority under general agency law depends on a third party's reasonable belief traceable to the principal's manifestations. California Civil Code sections 2298-2300 distinguish actual and ostensible agency, while sections 2316-2317 address actual and ostensible authority.
An agent can exceed actual authority while remaining an agent who owes duties. Conversely, an asserted representative may lack actual appointment but create a third-party issue because the principal caused the appearance of authority. The asserted representative's unsupported claims alone ordinarily cannot supply the principal's manifestation. See also Agency Authority and Third-Party Liability for contract liability, reliance requirements, and ratification.
Checkpoint
An owner orally asks a consultant to negotiate equipment purchases for the owner's business. The consultant accepts. The owner may change the purchase list and budget while negotiations continue. Their contract calls the consultant an independent contractor. Which conclusion is strongest?
An agency relationship exists despite the independent-contractor label.
No agency exists unless the owner controls the consultant's daily schedule.
No agency exists without a written appointment.
The consultant necessarily has authority to execute every equipment contract.
Answer: A. Accepted representation plus retained interim control establishes agency. B confuses agency control with detailed employment control; C overlooks ordinary oral formation; D confuses status with the scope and formal requirements of authority.
1.1.1.3 Loyalty protects the entrusted purpose
Restatement sections 8.01-8.06 address loyalty in matters connected with agency. The duty prevents an agent from using the entrusted position to pursue a conflicting interest without legally sufficient consent. It applies even when the transaction appears economically attractive to the principal: an agent's conflict can distort decisions before a loss becomes visible.
A purchasing agent cannot secretly keep a supplier's referral payment tied to purchases for the principal. The problem is the material benefit obtained through the agency position, not simply whether the principal paid above market. A personal gift unrelated to the agency is different; the necessary connection must be established from the circumstances.
The following table compares distinct loyalty violations. Each involves an interest or resource entrusted to the agent.
Table 2. Loyalty violations and relevant permissions
Conduct
Agency-related problem
Relevant permission or boundary
Supplier pays agent a hidden purchase bonus.
Material third-party benefit connected with the position.
Informed principal consent to the disclosed benefit.
Agent sells personally owned goods to principal.
Agent acts as an adverse counterparty.
Disclose ownership and material terms; obtain informed consent.
Agent represents buyer and seller.
Divided representation of adverse interests.
Each affected principal must give sufficient informed consent.
Agent redirects an entrusted customer order.
Present competition or diversion of agency business.
Lawful preparation for future competition does not authorize diversion.
Agent takes pricing files for another venture.
Misuse of confidential information or principal property.
General experience differs from protected files and confidential information.
Self-dealing includes acting as the principal's counterparty, directly or through a controlled entity. Dual representation includes acting for both sides in a transaction. Disclosure to only one principal does not resolve the other principal's conflict. Agency rules permit some conflicted conduct with consent, but a specialized legal rule may impose additional restrictions or prohibit the arrangement.
Under Restatement section 8.06, valid consent requires good faith, disclosure of material facts, and fair dealing. The consent must concern a specific act or a sufficiently defined category reasonably expected in the ordinary agency relationship. An unexplained statement that the agent may have interests elsewhere does not necessarily disclose ownership of the seller or a transaction-specific payment. Information the principal already knows, or has properly indicated it does not wish to receive, is treated differently under that rule.
Consent must address the conflict. A principal's approval of a purchase price does not necessarily approve an agent's hidden commission. The missing fact is the agent's personal benefit, which may change the principal's evaluation of the recommendation.
During the agency, an agent may make otherwise lawful preparations for a later competing business, such as arranging financing or obtaining office space. Present solicitation of the principal's customers for diverted orders, use of confidential bid information, and taking an opportunity entrusted to the agent are different. Evaluate the conduct itself rather than accepting the description preparation.
Restatement section 8.05 separately protects property and confidential information. The agent must not use either for unauthorized personal or third-party purposes. Ordinary skills and general knowledge are distinguishable from confidential customer strategies, nonpublic pricing, and proprietary records. Termination does not convert those protected resources into the former agent's property.
Worked case
Mina, an unpaid procurement representative, agrees to obtain refrigeration equipment for a bakery. The owner sets a spending limit and may revise specifications. Mina selects a reliable supplier offering the lowest price, but secretly accepts a $2,000 payment from that supplier. A delayed building permit has made the owner anxious to finish quickly.
Mina accepted a purchasing undertaking for the bakery subject to the owner's direction, establishing agency despite the lack of pay. The supplier payment arose from that undertaking and gave Mina a personal interest in the selection. The permit delay explains urgency but supplies no consent to the payment.
The lowest price does not cure the undisclosed benefit. The owner may seek an accounting and surrender of the payment even if the equipment was worth its price. Additional compensatory damages require proof of a legally recoverable loss caused by the breach; the $2,000 gain does not itself prove an additional $2,000 overpayment. A complete answer states the relationship, identifies the connected benefit, considers informed consent, and separates gain-based relief from loss-based relief.
Match the conduct to the duty it most directly implicates.
Keeping a supplier's secret payment:
Surrendering an undisclosed third-party benefit.
Representing both transaction parties:
Obtaining informed permission from each affected principal.
Using nonpublic bid files for a new venture:
Protecting entrusted confidential information.
Redirecting a pending customer order:
Refraining from present competitive diversion.
A A counterparty who knows of the fraud cannot rely on authority
California Civil Code section 2306 supplies a boundary between internal disloyalty and external enforcement: neither actual nor ostensible authority authorizes an act that defrauds the principal when the person dealing with the agent knows or suspects the fraud. Suppose a supplier agrees to inflate invoices and secretly return the excess to the purchasing agent. The supplier cannot rely on the agent's purchasing title to enforce that scheme against the principal. This differs from an innocent seller dealing with an agent whose undisclosed personal motive is improper. Analyze the counterparty's knowledge or suspicion; an agent's breach alone does not establish that every associated third-party contract is unenforceable.
1.1.1.4 Performance duties run alongside reciprocal obligations
Loyalty concerns whose interests the agent serves. Care concerns how competently the agent performs. Under Restatement section 8.08, an agent must exercise the care, competence, and diligence normally exercised by agents in similar circumstances. Relevant circumstances include the undertaking's scope and the agent's special skills or knowledge. A professional engaged for expertise is evaluated with that expertise in view.
An unfavorable outcome alone does not establish deficient care. A purchasing representative who reasonably checks specifications and selects an appropriate supplier may still encounter an unforeseeable defect. Skipping a required compatibility check presents a different issue because the breach lies in the process of performance. Good intentions do not excuse careless execution, and expert execution does not excuse disloyalty.
Restatement section 8.09 requires action within actual authority and compliance with lawful instructions. An agent should seek clarification when instructions are materially ambiguous or circumstances change rather than silently substituting a personal preference. An illegal instruction does not create a duty of obedience. Acting beyond instructions also raises a separate authority question if a third party seeks to enforce the transaction.
The following table identifies performance duties and the principal obligations that arise under contract or general agency law.
Table 3. Performance and reciprocal obligations
Issue
Agent obligation
Principal obligation or consequence
Entrusted work
Use reasonable care, competence, and diligence.
Perform agreed contractual obligations.
Instructions
Follow lawful directions within actual authority.
Avoid obstructing agreed performance through bad-faith conduct.
Material developments
Communicate information relevant to entrusted affairs.
Deal fairly and in good faith with the agent.
Money and records
Keep accounts; preserve and identify entrusted property.
Pay agreed compensation when earned.
Proper agency expenditures
Distinguish authorized expenses from personal spending.
Provide reimbursement or indemnification when the governing rules require.
Delegated functions
Obtain authority and use reasonable selection and supervision.
Authorization to delegate does not excuse the agent's own negligence.
Restatement section 8.11 requires reasonable efforts to provide information the agent knows, has reason to know, or should know the principal would want concerning the entrusted affairs, subject to relevant superior duties. A purchasing agent who learns that a supplier cannot meet a critical delivery date must communicate that development. The duty is tied to the assignment, rather than a demand to report every unrelated personal observation.
Under Restatement section 8.12, the agent must account for money or property received for the principal and avoid handling it in a way that obscures ownership. Separate identification and reliable records permit the principal to determine what was received and spent. A later promise to reconstruct missing records does not replace proper accounting.
Delegation requires attention to actual or implied authority, custom, necessity, and the nature of the work. Restatement section 3.15 addresses subagency. Permission to hire clerical help does not necessarily permit transferring a discretionary assignment selected for the agent's personal judgment. Even authorized delegation leaves the appointing agent responsible for its own negligent selection or supervision; a properly appointed subagent also owes relevant duties within the relationship.
Principal obligations are not automatically reciprocal fiduciary duties. Restatement sections 8.13-8.15 address contractual performance, indemnification, and fair dealing. A principal must pay agreed compensation and provide applicable reimbursement, but agency alone does not promise a fee where the undertaking was gratuitous or make the principal a fiduciary for the agent.
General indemnification rules commonly protect an agent for payments or losses properly incurred in carrying out authorized work, subject to the agreement and the circumstances. They do not create a blanket right to reimbursement for the agent's own misconduct. Identify whether the claim concerns an authorized expense, a personal purchase, negligent performance, or a knowingly wrongful act.
California Labor Code section 2802 supplies a specific employee rule: the employer must indemnify necessary expenditures and qualifying losses directly resulting from employment duties or obedience to directions. The statute addresses directions that are unlawful but excludes the stated protection when the employee believed them unlawful at the time of obedience. This employee statute should not be applied automatically to every independent, nonemployee agent.
Checkpoint
A salaried purchasing employee reasonably pays an authorized courier charge from personal funds to complete an employer's delivery. The employer had supplied no company payment method. Which conclusion is most accurate?
The expense is unrecoverable because the employee already receives a salary.
The employee must prove that the employer acted as the employee's fiduciary.
The expense is recoverable only if the courier breached its delivery contract.
The necessary employment expenditure is subject to reimbursement under California Labor Code section 2802.
Answer: D. The charge was a necessary expense directly incurred in performing the employee's duties. A incorrectly treats salary as covering every business expense; B adds a fiduciary relationship the statute does not require; C confuses reimbursement with a claim against the courier.
A Protecting the enterprise and separating property
Two additional performance rules distinguish harmful conduct from ordinary mistakes. The following table identifies the conduct addressed by each Restatement provision.
Table 4. Enterprise protection and property segregation
Provision
Required conduct
Application
Restatement section 8.10
Act reasonably and avoid agency-connected conduct likely to damage the principal's enterprise.
A manager recklessly disrupts an entrusted supplier relationship without seeking any personal gain.
Restatement section 8.12
Keep the principal's property separate from the agent's property.
An agent deposits entrusted customer receipts into a personal account despite tracking them accurately.
Section 8.10 addresses reasonable conduct toward the enterprise even when the agent receives no secret payment and has no competing business. Its connection to the agency matters: it does not make every aspect of an agent's private life part of the undertaking. Analyze the entrusted function and how the conduct threatens the principal's business.
Section 8.12 makes segregation distinct from accounting. An accurate spreadsheet does not itself justify mixing entrusted funds with personal funds. Separation protects the principal's ownership and access, while accounting explains receipts and disbursements. If the agent mixes funds and later replaces them before any loss occurs, the absence of a shortfall may affect damages but does not erase the improper handling.
B The principal must disclose certain known risks
Under Restatement section 8.15, fair dealing includes providing information about risks of physical harm or pecuniary loss that the principal knows, has reason to know, or should know, when the principal has reason to know the agent is unaware of those risks. The information must relate to the agency relationship. A principal who sends an inventory agent into a warehouse while withholding knowledge of an unstable storage platform presents a different issue from a principal merely declining to guarantee a profitable assignment. The question is whether the principal withheld qualifying risk information, not whether the principal became the agent's fiduciary or insured every outcome.
C Urgency can justify a narrow departure from instructions
California Civil Code section 2320 permits an agent dealing with the subject of the agency to disobey instructions when departure is clearly in the principal's interest and there is no time to communicate with the principal. Both conditions matter. Mere convenience, a potentially higher profit, or the agent's preference is insufficient. Suppose an agent is instructed to store perishable inventory in a designated room, but a sudden refrigeration failure threatens immediate spoilage. Moving it to available safe storage may satisfy the exception if consultation cannot occur before the loss. If there is time to obtain instructions, urgency alone does not justify bypassing the principal.
D California's four statutory delegation grounds
California Civil Code section 2349 identifies four grounds for delegation. A principal's special prohibition defeats reliance on the statute's default permission; a later authorization must actually change that restriction. The following table states each ground separately.
Table 5. Delegation under Civil Code section 2349
Ground
What establishes it
What does not establish it
Purely mechanical act
The delegated task implements a settled decision without exercising entrusted discretion.
Allowing a substitute to make a personally entrusted investment choice.
Agent cannot perform; substitute can lawfully perform
The original agent cannot lawfully perform the act, but the proposed subagent can.
A substitute who also lacks the required legal qualification.
Usage of the place
A relevant local usage supports delegation of that power.
The agent's private habit of outsourcing assignments.
Special authorization
The principal specifically permits the delegation.
Permission to complete the overall project without permission to transfer the particular discretionary function.
For a California essay, connect delegation to the applicable statutory ground rather than relying on a general assertion that assistance was useful. In particular, personal inconvenience is not equivalent to inability to perform, and a custom cannot override an express prohibition. Separate delegating a mechanical step from handing over the judgment for which the principal selected the agent.
E Authorization determines whom a subagent represents
California Civil Code section 2350 provides that when an agent appoints a subagent without authority, the appointing agent becomes the subagent's principal; the original principal has no connection with the substitute through that unauthorized appointment. Section 2351 treats a lawfully appointed subagent differently: that subagent represents the original principal in the same manner as the original agent.
Section 2351 also states that the original agent is not responsible to third persons for the lawfully appointed subagent's acts. That provision does not excuse the original agent's own wrongful selection, supervision, or instructions. If a manager secretly hires an unauthorized substitute, do not infer a direct agency relationship with the owner merely because the substitute performs work benefiting the owner. Later authorization or ratification requires additional facts and a separate analysis.
1.1.1.5 Remedies and termination require separate analyses
A Match relief to the wrong
A compensatory claim requires a duty, breach, recoverable harm, and the required causal connection. A disloyal act does not automatically establish a particular amount of compensatory damages. Gain-based relief addresses a different interest: preventing the agent from retaining benefits obtained through breach. Restatement sections 8.01-8.05 supply the underlying duties, while the available remedy depends on the claim and applicable remedial law.
The following table distinguishes the object of each remedy; it also shows why a principal may need relief beyond ordinary damages.
Table 6. Selecting agency remedies
Remedy
What it addresses
Required factual focus
Compensatory damages
The principal's legally recoverable loss.
Breach, causation, and supported loss measurement.
Disgorgement
The agent's wrongful gain.
Benefit sufficiently connected to the breach.
Accounting
Unexplained receipts, expenses, or entrusted assets.
Transactions and records requiring reconciliation.
Rescission
Unwinding an affected transaction.
Grounds for avoidance and applicable restoration requirements.
Constructive trust
Identifiable property or proceeds wrongfully held.
A sufficient connection between the wrong and the property.
Compensation forfeiture
Pay associated with disloyal service.
Seriousness, affected service, and applicable apportionment rules.
These remedies are not automatically cumulative. A principal cannot obtain duplicate recovery for the same injury, and compensation forfeiture does not necessarily erase every payment for unrelated, properly performed work. Rescission and constructive trust require their own predicates; naming a fiduciary breach does not dispense with them. Injunctive relief may also protect confidential information or property when equitable requirements are met.
B Separate ending authority from breaching a contract
California Civil Code section 2355 addresses termination, as to persons having notice, through expiration of the term, extinction of the subject, the agent's death, the agent's renunciation, and the agent's incapacity to act. Section 2356 addresses revocation, death, and incapacity, together with exceptions and third-party protections. Restatement sections 3.06-3.10 also distinguish agreement-based termination, revocation, renunciation, and legal events.
A principal generally has the power to revoke ordinary authority, and an agent can renounce it. A fixed-term appointment can nevertheless create a contractual right to continued performance or compensation. Revocation can therefore end actual authority while exposing the principal to contract damages. Calling an appointment irrevocable does not, by itself, establish a power given as security.
Security exception. Under California Civil Code section 2356 and Restatement sections 3.12-3.13, a qualifying power coupled with an interest or given as security is treated differently from ordinary agency authority. A creditor's power to sell pledged property to satisfy a debt illustrates the protected interest. A sales agent's hoped-for commission alone does not.
Death and incapacity are especially sensitive to the governing framework. Traditional common-law formulations treat them as terminating events for ordinary agency; Restatement sections 3.07-3.08 incorporate notice or knowledge distinctions. California Civil Code section 2356(a) lists the principal's death and incapacity among terminating events, subject to exceptions. Durable powers of attorney are governed by the California Probate Code, including section 4124; qualifying durability addresses later incapacity and does not authorize action after death.
California Civil Code section 2356(b) protects a bona fide transaction entered into by a person acting without actual knowledge of the principal's revocation, death, or incapacity, binding the principal or successors as specified by the statute. Section 2356(c) addresses good-faith acts under a written power of attorney without actual knowledge of death or incapacity. These statutory protections require their own facts; they should not be collapsed into a universal statement that every act after termination is ineffective.
Apparent authority presents an additional, separate inquiry. Under Restatement section 3.11, termination of actual authority does not itself terminate apparent authority; the third party's continuing reasonable belief matters. Effective notice to prior counterparties can eliminate the basis for that belief. California Civil Code sections 2317 and 2334 govern ostensible-authority issues, and section 2355 expressly incorporates notice for its listed events. No universal number of notice days governs every ordinary agency termination.
Worked case
A gallery appoints Omar to purchase frames for one year at an agreed monthly fee. After four months, it unequivocally tells Omar that his purchasing authority ends immediately. Omar argues that authority must continue because eight months remain. He also keeps a confidential supplier-discount file and announces that he will open a competing framing business.
The gallery's revocation generally ends Omar's ordinary actual authority when communicated, even if the early termination violates the one-year compensation agreement. His potential contract claim does not authorize additional purchases. An expected fee supplies no security interest in gallery property.
Omar must return the entrusted file and account for gallery property. Whether a supplier can bind the gallery through later dealings requires a separate examination of ostensible authority, notice, and any applicable statutory protection. The revocation communication to Omar alone does not establish what the supplier knew.
Opening a competing business after termination is separately analyzed. California Business and Professions Code section 16600 generally invalidates restraints on lawful competition, subject to statutory exceptions such as qualifying business-sale arrangements. That policy does not authorize taking confidential files, misappropriating trade secrets, or retaining business diverted during the agency.
Termination also leaves accrued claims intact. Compensation already earned, reimbursement already due, damages for past misconduct, final accounting, return of property, and applicable confidentiality duties may survive. California Labor Code section 2860 additionally addresses employee acquisitions obtained by virtue of employment, including qualifying acquisitions after the employment term; timing alone does not make employment-derived benefits personal property.
C Distinguish events affecting the agent from events affecting the principal
Section 2355 identifies five events and expressly makes its rule applicable to persons having notice. Section 2356 separately addresses principal-side revocation, death, and incapacity, with its stated exceptions and transaction protections. The following table prevents transferring an event or notice rule from one provision to another.
Table 7. Events expressly listed in Civil Code section 2355
Event
Relevant fact
Distinction
Expiration of the term
The specified appointment period has ended.
Different from an early revocation by the principal.
Extinction of the subject
The subject of the agency no longer exists.
Different from the agent merely wanting to abandon the work.
Death of the agent
The appointed representative has died.
Death of the principal is addressed separately in section 2356.
Renunciation by the agent
The agent communicates withdrawal from the undertaking.
Different from the principal revoking the appointment.
Incapacity of the agent
The agent becomes incapable of acting as agent.
A principal's durable power does not cure the appointed agent's own inability to act.
Completion of an assigned purpose remains relevant under general agency principles and the terms of the appointment, but it is not a separately enumerated event in section 2355. If a representative dies, the representative's heir does not automatically inherit the appointment. A successor's ability to act must rest on a separate valid appointment or another applicable source of authority.
See also Agency Authority and Third-Party Liability for external liability, General Partnership Formation and Governance for relationships among co-owners, and Director and Officer Fiduciary Duties for duties attached to corporate office.
Answer these prompts from memory before moving to the practice questions.
D Recall check
Which capacity does California require of a person appointing an agent?
Capacity to contract; California Civil Code section 2296 separately permits any person to be an agent.
When does California require written authority for an agent's contract execution?
Under Civil Code section 2309, when the contract to be entered must legally be in writing.
What must an agent disclose before obtaining consent to conflicted conduct?
Material facts affecting the principal's judgment, including the agent's adverse interest or connected personal benefit.
Which remedy focuses on an agent's gain rather than the principal's measured loss?
Disgorgement targets benefits obtained through the breach.
What distinguishes a security power from an ordinary commission appointment?
The power protects a qualifying interest in the subject matter or obligation, rather than merely the agent's expected compensation.
COMMON MISTAKE
Common mistakes
Table 8. Similar facts that produce different results
Tempting conclusion
Why it seems plausible
Fact that resolves the issue
An independent contractor cannot be an agent.
Independence sounds inconsistent with control.
The principal retains interim direction over a representative undertaking.
A favorable price excuses a hidden supplier payment.
The principal appears financially unharmed.
The agent accepted an undisclosed material benefit through the position.
Fixed-term appointment means authority cannot end early.
The agreement promises continued work.
Power to revoke differs from contractual permission to revoke.
Revocation ends every possible third-party claim.
The agent has lost actual authority.
Third-party belief, notice, and statutory transaction protections remain separate questions.
Permission to compete includes permission to take records.
California strongly protects lawful competition.
Confidential information and entrusted property remain protected.
ALGO
Approach
Analyze an agency dispute in this order so that relationship, conduct, remedy, and timing receive distinct conclusions.
Establish the relationship. Connect mutual assent, representative purpose, and retained control to concrete facts; address capacity or required written authority.
Classify the conduct. Identify a personal conflict, deficient performance, disobedience, withheld information, improper delegation, or missing property.
Evaluate permission and obligations. Test informed consent, lawful instructions, contractual commitments, and any employee-specific reimbursement rule.
Select supported relief. Separate loss-based damages from gain-based relief and identify the facts supporting each requested remedy.
Resolve the timeline. Determine when actual authority ended, whether a security or durability exception applies, and which external protections and duties remain.
QUIZ
Self-check quiz
Question 1
A company authorizes its agent to buy a machine. Without disclosure, the agent sells the company a machine owned by the agent. The price is fair. Using Table 2, what additional fact most directly supports treating the transaction as permitted under ordinary agency loyalty rules?
The agent earned no separate commission on the sale.
The agent disclosed ownership and all material terms, dealt fairly, and obtained the company's informed consent.
The machine required less maintenance than competing machines.
The agent had authority to purchase machines from unrelated sellers.
Question 2
An agent accepts a secret $8,000 payment for directing the principal's purchases to a supplier. The principal proves the payment but cannot establish any overpayment or other financial loss. Which conclusion is most accurate?
No remedy is available without proof that the goods were overpriced.
The principal automatically receives both $8,000 in damages and another $8,000 in restitution.
The principal may seek disgorgement of the payment without proving an equivalent purchasing loss.
The agent may retain the payment because it came from a third party.
Question 3
A principal gives an agent an ordinary purchasing appointment for six months. After one month, the principal unequivocally communicates revocation. No security interest or special statutory power is involved. What is the best conclusion?
Actual authority generally ends, although early termination may support a contract claim.
Actual authority continues until six months expire because the appointment had a fixed duration.
The agent may continue purchasing until the principal pays all alleged damages.
The appointment is a power given as security because the agent expected commissions.
Question 4
Before resigning, a purchasing agent rents office space for a competing business and secretly redirects the principal's pending customer order to that business. Which conclusion is strongest?
Both acts are permitted preparations because the agent plans to resign.
Neither act can implicate loyalty unless the principal has a noncompetition agreement.
Both acts necessarily violate loyalty because no future business preparation is permitted.
Office arrangements may be lawful preparation, but redirecting the pending order is present diversion.
Question 5
A California principal revokes an ordinary agent's authority. A supplier then enters a bona fide transaction with the agent without actual knowledge of the revocation. The supplier seeks enforcement against the principal. Which rule most directly requires analysis?
The agent's expectation of compensation makes the authority irrevocable.
California Civil Code section 2356(b) protects qualifying third-party transactions despite the specified terminating event.
Every transaction after revocation is void regardless of notice or statutory protection.
The principal necessarily became the supplier's fiduciary by appointing the agent.
ANSWERS
Answer key
Question 1 - Answer: B. Informed consent requires disclosure of the agent's adverse interest and material facts, together with good faith and fair dealing. A removes a possible fee but leaves self-dealing; C supports economic attractiveness but supplies no consent; D authorizes purchasing without necessarily authorizing conflicted purchasing.
Question 2 - Answer: C. Disgorgement addresses the agent's wrongful gain and does not require a matching loss to the principal. A confuses gain-based relief with compensatory damages; B assumes unsupported damages and duplicate recovery; D overlooks the payment's connection to the agency position.
Question 3 - Answer: A. A principal ordinarily can terminate actual authority even when doing so breaches a fixed-term agreement. B confuses contractual duration with power to revoke; C invents a right to continue acting pending payment; D treats expected compensation as a qualifying security interest.
Question 4 - Answer: D. Otherwise lawful arrangements for a future enterprise differ from diverting the principal's current business during the agency. A incorrectly extends preparation to present diversion; B overlooks the existing loyalty duty; C wrongly prohibits every preparatory act.
Question 5 - Answer: B. Section 2356(b) specifically addresses a bona fide transaction by a person acting without actual knowledge of revocation, death, or incapacity. A mistakes compensation for a security interest; C ignores the statutory protection; D invents a fiduciary relationship with the supplier.
RAPID
Rapid review
Accepted representation plus interim control → examine agency despite the parties' labels.
Unpaid undertaking → compensation is not a formation requirement.