Skip to content
Free previewYou are reading 1 of 93 lessons, in the same interface members use. Everything else unlocks with full access.Get full access · $150

What you'll learn

  • Identify who can grant a license, discipline a lawyer, or control an appearance in a particular forum.
  • Determine the legal effect of an adopted rule, a model provision, a comment, and an ethics opinion.
  • Select the governing MPRE authority and calculate when an approved amendment first becomes eligible for testing.
  • Distinguish permission and disciplinary exposure from damages, disqualification, and procedural sanctions.

Estimated reading time: 15 minutes.

WHY

Why it matters

A judge can remove a lawyer from a case, a disciplinary authority can seek suspension, and a client can sue for damages over the same representation. Each decision answers a different legal question. On the MPRE, the words asking what the court, client, or disciplinary authority can do often determine which rule governs.

KEY TERMS

Key terms

Inherent authority
Power a court possesses by virtue of its judicial function, including authority to govern practice before it.
Promulgation
Formal issuance of a rule by a body with authority to make it effective.
Integrated bar
A bar organization in which membership is required for practice in the jurisdiction. Its regulatory responsibilities depend on the powers assigned to it.
Advisory opinion
An ethics body's interpretation of how a professional rule applies to stated facts.
Disqualification
A ruling excluding counsel from a particular representation in a proceeding.
Reciprocal discipline
Disciplinary action in one jurisdiction or court based on discipline imposed elsewhere.
CORE

Core content

1.1.1.1 Who controls the license and the forum?

A state license authorizes its holder to practice under the authority of the issuing jurisdiction. The state's highest court generally has ultimate responsibility for admission and discipline. Its name varies. A reference to the state's court of last resort identifies its position in the judicial system even if its title omits the words supreme court. Courts have inherent power to regulate lawyers because the administration of justice depends on who may appear as counsel and how counsel conducts proceedings.

Much of the work happens elsewhere. A board of bar examiners can administer examinations and investigate character and fitness. Disciplinary counsel can investigate a grievance, decide whether to bring charges under applicable procedures, and present evidence. A hearing panel can make findings and recommend a sanction. Some jurisdictions delegate authority to impose specified measures. An order authorizing a board to recommend suspension establishes who makes the recommendation and leaves the final decision to the authority designated to enter the order.

Table 1 compares the powers of bodies whose names often appear together on a lawyer's professional record.

Table 1. Sources and reach of regulatory power
BodySource of powerIllustrative actionReach of action
State's highest courtJudicial authority under state lawOrders disbarmentLicense in the issuing state
State disciplinary boardState rule or order assigning powersReviews charges and recommends suspensionEffect specified by the delegation
Voluntary county barMembership rulesExpels a memberMembership in that association
LegislatureConstitutional lawmaking authorityPenalizes fraudulent handling of entrusted fundsPersons and conduct covered by the statute
Administrative agencyStatute and valid implementing rulesBars a representative from agency proceedingsPractice covered by the agency's authority
Federal district courtAuthority over its proceedings and barSuspends admission to its barPractice before that federal court

A state legislature can enact laws that affect lawyers directly, including statutes addressing unauthorized practice, and laws that apply to lawyers along with everyone else. A lawyer who steals client property can face prosecution under a theft statute. Judicial control over the license supplies no exemption from criminal law. A different constitutional issue arises if a statute purports to direct the judiciary's decision about whom it must admit. The result depends on the jurisdiction's allocation of authority and the particular intrusion.

A federal court has its own bar. State licensure may be a prerequisite under its admission rules, but state admission alone need not authorize an appearance there. Likewise, discipline in one forum can trigger reporting duties or reciprocal proceedings in another. The effect depends on the second forum's rules. Federal administrative practice raises a related distinction. When valid federal law authorizes a qualified representative to perform specified work before a federal agency, a state generally cannot use its licensing rules to prohibit the federally authorized work. That authorization extends only to its defined scope.

Worked case

On May 3, a county's voluntary lawyers' association expels Perez after she withholds association dues. Perez also belongs to the state bar and represents a tenant in federal district court. A landlord moves to strike her appearance, attaching the county association's letter and noting that she owes $600. The motion rests entirely on the assertion that expulsion terminated her license.

The issue is Perez's authority to appear. The letter proves a membership decision. Nothing gives the county association licensing power, and the facts identify no state suspension or federal order affecting Perez's admission. The size of the debt adds nothing to the association's authority. The district court controls its own bar and could act on a proper ground under its rules. On the stated ground, however, it should deny the motion. A state suspension coupled with an applicable federal reciprocal-discipline rule would require a different inquiry.

A Checkpoint

A court rule permits a committee to investigate grievances and recommend discipline. After a hearing, the committee recommends a six-month suspension. What follows from the recommendation alone?

  1. The suspension begins when the committee serves the lawyer.
  2. The authority empowered to impose suspension must decide whether to enter it.
  3. The complainant may enforce the recommendation as a civil judgment.
  4. The hearing converts the committee's recommendation into a final disciplinary order.
Answer: B. The delegation authorizes a recommendation. A hearing can give the recommendation a sound factual basis, but D assigns the committee a power the rule reserves to another decision maker.

B Constitutional limits on the regulator

A court can have authority to adopt a rule and still face a constitutional limit on enforcing it. Suppose a state supreme court prohibits every newspaper advertisement stating a price for routine legal services. A lawyer publishes an accurate, nonmisleading price for lawful work. Controlling First Amendment decisions protect that commercial speech against a blanket ban. The lawyer can challenge enforcement even though the correct state body adopted the rule. A deceptive price claim would present a different constitutional question.

1.1.1.2 How a professional standard becomes binding

The American Bar Association (ABA) develops model standards. A jurisdiction gives a model provision legal force by adopting it through an authorized body, usually its highest court. The adoption order determines which text takes effect and when. If a state adopts an earlier version or changes an exception, its disciplinary authority applies the operative state text to conduct governed by that state's rules. Later ABA action does not silently amend the state rule.

The distinction also matters within a single publication. In the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct, the rule text creates professional obligations. Comments explain purpose and application. A comment can resolve ambiguity, illustrate an exception, or describe a prudent precaution. It cannot supply an independent basis for discipline beyond the rule it explains. For example, a comment suggesting a desirable practice does not turn every omission of that practice into misconduct. The omission may still be evidence that the lawyer failed to satisfy an actual rule.

Table 2 shows how to use four texts found in the same lawyer's research file.

Table 2. Legal effect of professional guidance
Text in the fileQuestion it answersWhat establishes its weight?
State court's effective ruleWhat conduct does this jurisdiction require?Valid adoption, effective date, and applicability
Unadopted ABA amendmentWhat change has the ABA approved?Model status pending local adoption
Comment accompanying a ruleHow does the rule operate in context?Its connection to the governing text
Bar committee advisory opinionHow does the committee interpret comparable facts?Jurisdiction's treatment of opinions and fit with the facts

An advisory opinion can help a lawyer identify a risk before acting. Its persuasive force depends partly on whether it addresses the same rule and the same material facts. An ABA opinion about the model text may be less helpful where a state has changed that text. Reliance on an opinion ordinarily supplies neither an automatic defense nor a guarantee against a grievance. A jurisdiction can expressly give designated advice special effect, so the terms of any stated protection matter.

Match each professional document to the use a lawyer can make of it.

Adoption order:
Determine when a state's new wording takes effect.
Model proposal:
Identify a change under consideration.
Interpretive comment:
Read an example alongside the operative provision.
Committee advisory opinion:
Assess a professional body's reasoning on a submitted scenario.

A Judicial interpretations and judicial canons

Suppose a state's highest court construes an exception in its professional conduct rule. A bar committee later reads the same words more broadly. In a disciplinary case governed by the same text and materially identical facts, the deciding body must follow the controlling judicial interpretation. The committee's later publication date gives it no power to enlarge the exception. Look for a change in the operative text or a material difference in the facts before distinguishing the precedent.

In the Model Code of Judicial Conduct, a canon introduces a broad principle, such as preserving judicial independence, integrity, and impartiality. The numbered rules under each canon translate that principle into enforceable duties. If a complaint alleges only that a judge acted inconsistently with a canon's ideal, identify the specific rule the conduct would violate. The canon guides interpretation of that rule. A disciplinary finding requires a violation of an enforceable provision.

1.1.1.3 Which authority governs an MPRE question?

The National Conference of Bar Examiners (NCBE) supplies common assumptions so that an applicant educated in one state can answer the same question as an applicant educated in another. Lawyer discipline ordinarily draws on the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct. A question about a judge's ethical conduct ordinarily draws on the ABA Model Code of Judicial Conduct. The official subject matter outline identifies topics that may be examined. It does not itself authorize a lawyer to act or a tribunal to impose discipline.

The actor's professional title alone cannot settle the source question. Suppose a lawyer receives a confidential admission from a client and is later subpoenaed. The scope of the lawyer's duty to protect information is a professional-conduct issue. Whether a court can compel particular testimony may turn on attorney-client privilege and applicable evidence law. A client can communicate a fact in confidence even when that fact remains discoverable from another witness. Calling the information confidential leaves the evidentiary question open.

For matters outside the disciplinary context, the ordinary MPRE convention is the generally accepted view reflected in leading decisions and other authorities. This matters for civil liability, agency principles, and disqualification. For questions of procedure or evidence, federal rules ordinarily supply the framework unless the question provides otherwise. A procedural rule that itself directs the court to use state law must be applied as written. For example, Federal Rule of Evidence 501 points to state privilege law in a civil case for a claim or defense governed by state substantive law. An express assumption in the question takes priority over a default.

Figure 1 sorts questions by the ruling or consequence requested.

Fig 1. Governing authority by question type
Key point: The requested ruling determines which body of law supplies the answer.
flowchart TD
A[Requested legal determination] --> B{Express governing rule?}
B -->|Yes| C[Apply stated rule]
B -->|No| D{Which issue?}
D --> E[Lawyer disciplinary duty]
E --> F[Model professional conduct rules]
D --> G[Judicial ethical duty]
G --> H[Model judicial conduct code]
D --> I[Procedure or evidence]
I --> J[Federal rules framework]
D --> K[Other nondisciplinary issue]
K --> L[Generally accepted principles]

A The amendment clock

NCBE treats an ABA amendment as eligible for testing no earlier than one year after ABA approval. The event that starts the interval is approval of the amendment. Publication of a draft, discussion by a committee, and a state's effective date answer different questions. Reaching the anniversary establishes the earliest possible eligibility. It supplies no information about which questions NCBE selected for an actual examination.

Table 3 gives the complete record for a hypothetical amendment. Each date has a different legal or examination function.

Table 3. Hypothetical amendment record
EventDateSignificance
Draft circulatedMarch 4, 2024Proposal available for discussion
ABA approves final amendmentAugust 12, 2024Starts NCBE's minimum waiting interval
State court adopts revised textOctober 15, 2024Establishes the state's chosen wording
State adoption order takes effectJanuary 1, 2025Revised state standard governs subsequent covered conduct

B Checkpoint

Using Table 3, what is the earliest date the approved amendment could be eligible for MPRE testing?

  1. January 1, 2025
  2. March 4, 2025
  3. October 15, 2025
  4. August 12, 2025
Answer: D. One year from ABA approval on August 12, 2024, reaches August 12, 2025. C also adds a year, but it uses the state court's adoption date.

C Choosing among competing versions of the law

Table 4 shows what to do when two plausible answers rely on different authorities.

Table 4. Selecting the governing rule on the MPRE
Facts suppliedSource to applyEffect on the answer
Courts divide on a nondisciplinary issue.Majority approach reflected in cases, statutes, or regulations.Apply the prevailing rule unless the question specifies another.
The stem quotes a local court rule.The supplied text, including its exceptions.Use the local provision for the issue it addresses.
The ABA approved a change six months ago.The pre-amendment provision remains testable.Use the earlier wording if the two versions yield different answers.

For example, if a nondisciplinary question describes a split over when a nonclient may recover damages, a decision from the applicant's home state carries no special weight. The prevailing U.S. approach supplies the default. A question that gives the jurisdiction's governing statute supplies the information needed to depart from that default. Read the quoted text closely, including whom it covers. An unfamiliar place name alone gives no reason to supply a local exception from memory.

The waiting period for amendments applies to both the lawyer rules and the judicial code. Suppose a new judicial rule adds a gift exception that would permit the judge's conduct. Six months after ABA approval, a question can still require the earlier gift rule. In that interval, an answer relying solely on the new exception uses a provision that is too recent for the examination.

1.1.1.4 What the operative verb requires

A mandatory rule can require an act or prohibit one. In the Model Rules, shall imposes a duty and shall not states a prohibition. The conditions attached to the verb are part of the standard. A requirement triggered by knowledge calls for actual knowledge, which may be inferred from circumstances. A requirement triggered by what a lawyer reasonably should know can reach a failure to recognize facts a reasonably prudent and competent lawyer would recognize. Substituting one trigger for the other changes the scope of disciplinary exposure.

A permissive provision gives a choice once its conditions are satisfied. Under the Model Rules' confidentiality provision, for example, a lawyer may reveal information to prevent reasonably certain death or substantial bodily harm, to the extent the lawyer reasonably believes necessary. The degree of danger, the lawyer's reasonable belief, and the amount disclosed each matter. Permission to give a warning to someone able to avert the danger does not by itself authorize publishing the client's entire file. A separate law or court order can raise another duty even where the professional rule grants discretion.

Subject to discipline. This wording asks whether the proved conduct exposes the lawyer to professional discipline. A violation can support discipline without client injury, a lawsuit, or a client's request for punishment. Whether a sanction is imposed, and whether it is a reprimand, suspension, or disbarment, are further decisions under the applicable disciplinary system.

The wording may the lawyer asks whether the contemplated action is permitted. The wording must the lawyer asks whether declining to act would breach a duty. A third question, was the lawyer's conduct proper, calls for assessment under applicable governing standards, including relevant law beyond the disciplinary rules where the facts implicate it. An action that escapes a particular disciplinary prohibition can still violate a protective order. Conversely, the availability of a lawful procedural maneuver does not excuse a lawyer's independently dishonest statement to obtain it.

A Apply the same test to 'may' and 'proper'

NCBE uses both words to ask whether the proposed conduct is professionally appropriate. Check three things: whether the conduct exposes the actor to discipline, whether it fits the applicable ABA text and its preamble and comments, and whether it accords with generally accepted law governing lawyers. For example, a lawyer's reasonable choice between two permitted tactics can still require the client's authorization under agency law. An answer relying only on the absence of a disciplinary prohibition leaves the authority question unresolved.

Professional discipline protects the public and the integrity of the profession. Civil malpractice law compensates for legally cognizable injury caused by a lawyer's breach of duty. The Scope of the ABA Model Rules explains how the two relate. Violation of a rule does not itself create a cause of action or a presumption that a legal duty was breached. A rule can nevertheless supply evidence of the applicable standard of conduct and its breach. Its relevance depends on the duty and conduct actually disputed.

For a client's negligence-based malpractice claim, the questions are whether the lawyer owed a duty, breached the applicable standard of care, and thereby caused compensable injury. When the alleged loss is a lost lawsuit, causation commonly requires showing what the client would have obtained with competent representation. If the underlying claim was already time-barred when the client retained the lawyer, a later missed filing may be careless without causing the loss of that claim. Other proven losses would require their own causal analysis.

Table 5 compares the determinations that can arise from one disputed representation.

Table 5. Proceedings and available consequences
Question presentedDecision makerRequired inquiryPossible result
Is the lawyer subject to discipline?Authorized disciplinary body or courtDid the lawyer violate a governing professional obligation?Professional reprimand, suspension, or disbarment
Can the client recover negligence damages?Court hearing the civil claim, with a factfinder where appropriateDid a breach of duty cause compensable injury?Damages for the proven loss
May counsel continue in the case?Tribunal hearing the matterDo governing disqualification standards require removal?Exclusion of counsel from the matter
May the judge sanction litigation conduct?Court overseeing the litigationAre the grounds and procedural protections for this sanction satisfied?Expenses, a procedural order, or another authorized sanction

Disqualification protects interests implicated by continued representation, such as a former client's confidences or the fairness of the proceeding. The court applies governing disqualification law. A conduct rule may inform the decision, but its violation does not automatically entitle an opponent to remove counsel. An opponent's litigation advantage supplies no independent ground. Likewise, a ruling on disqualification resolves counsel's status in the matter and does not itself revoke a license.

Procedural sanctions have their own authority and safeguards. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11 addresses representations made when presenting papers to a federal court. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37 supplies remedies for specified discovery failures. Their triggers and procedures differ. A lawyer's failure to comply with a discovery order calls for examining the discovery-sanctions authority, including who may be sanctioned and what findings or exceptions apply. The trial judge can decide that question without waiting for disciplinary counsel to file charges.

Worked case

On April 8, Elena's lawyer knowingly tells her that he filed a response the previous day. In fact, he files it that afternoon, two days before it is due. The response succeeds. Elena paid the agreed $2,000 fee and incurred no additional expense or other compensable loss. She has the lawyer's email and demands both discipline and negligence damages.

The email is evidence of a knowingly false factual statement. The Model Rules prohibit professional misconduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation. Timely filing answers a deadline question but leaves the earlier lie intact. The lawyer can face discipline for the lie even though Elena won.

Her negligence claim requires a separate causal account. The agreed fee was payable for the work she received, and the facts attribute no loss to her reliance on the lie. A proved rule violation could be evidence of breach, but it cannot supply missing damages. If Elena had reasonably hired and paid emergency counsel because of the misrepresentation, that expense would warrant analysis as a possible loss. On the facts given, disciplinary exposure and the failure of the negligence damages claim are consistent outcomes.

See also Admission and Application Candor addresses statements to admissions authorities. Disciplinary Grounds and Jurisdiction develops which jurisdictions can act on misconduct. Reporting Professional Misconduct addresses when a lawyer who learns of another professional's conduct must report it.

Table 6 identifies whose interests or obligations a tribunal may adjudicate.

Table 6. Parties and grounds for relief
Relief requestedPotential targetQuestion to resolve
A fine, contempt punishment, or fee forfeitureCounsel or, where authorized, the firmDoes the tribunal's sanctions authority cover this conduct and this target?
Removal of a firm from a civil or criminal matterAll counsel in the affected firmDoes the governing law extend the conflict to the firm?
Relief for deception or disloyaltyThe lawyer or a firm legally responsible for the conductHas the claimant established the elements of the particular civil claim?

Suppose an associate signs an improper federal civil filing. Under Rule 11, a law firm ordinarily shares responsibility for a violation by its partner, associate, or employee unless exceptional circumstances exist. The identity of the signer therefore does not dispose of a motion seeking a sanction against the firm. By contrast, a motion to remove the firm requires analysis of disqualification, including any applicable imputation or screening rule.

Read a civil complaint for the duty it invokes. A lawyer who secretly profits from a transaction involving a client may face a fiduciary claim even if the lawyer competently completed the legal work. An intentional falsehood that induces detrimental reliance may support a misrepresentation claim. Whether the client would have won an underlying lawsuit matters when loss of that lawsuit is the alleged injury. It is not an element of every civil claim involving a lawyer.

Also ask who can request the remedy. Suppose an opponent discovers that counsel failed to explain a fee to counsel's own client. The ethics rule alone gives the opponent no standing to enforce that duty. If the opponent instead identifies a threat to the fairness of the pending proceeding, the court can assess that concern under its own authority. The person who brings conduct to the court's attention and the person entitled to relief can be different.

Supply the governing distinction for each situation.

What gives model language binding force in a state?
Adoption by a competent state authority, effective under the terms of the adoption.
Which source supplies the ordinary MPRE standard for a judge's ethical obligations?
The ABA Model Code of Judicial Conduct.
What role can a professional rule play in proving civil negligence?
It may provide evidence of breach of the applicable standard. The plaintiff still must establish the civil claim's elements.
Which decision determines whether a lawyer can remain counsel in a pending case?
The tribunal's ruling under the applicable disqualification standard.
What does the first anniversary of ABA approval establish about the examination?
The amendment has reached the earliest possible testing date. Its appearance on an examination remains unconfirmed.
COMMON MISTAKE

Common mistakes

Table 7 identifies facts that make a plausible answer fail.

Table 7. Plausible answers and the facts that defeat them
Tempting choiceWhy it appealsDecisive fact
The state bar necessarily entered a final sanction.Bar agencies often conduct the entire investigation.The court rule gives this agency only investigatory and recommendatory powers.
The lawyer must take the precaution described in a comment.The comment appears beside binding text.The comment describes an optional precaution and no operative provision requires it.
The lawyer owes damages because the disciplinary finding is final.The finding establishes serious professional wrongdoing.The civil plaintiff sustained no compensable loss.
The client can prevent professional discipline by declining to complain.The client personally experienced the conduct.The disciplinary authority has independent power to pursue the violation.
The new wording appeared on the examination after the anniversary.The minimum waiting interval has elapsed.The only evidence concerns eligibility, with no evidence of actual item selection.
ALGO

Approach

Work from the requested decision to the facts needed to justify it.

Name the disposition. Translate the request into a concrete result, such as a license suspension, removal from one case, or payment for a lost claim.
Locate the decision maker. For a motion in a pending case, identify the tribunal. For a licensing order, check who holds final authority under the jurisdiction's delegation.
Select the operative source. Apply any stated governing rule. Otherwise use the MPRE source appropriate to the disposition, including federal procedure or evidence where applicable.
Test the missing element. Check the provision's verb, factual trigger, exception, and remedy. A proven lie can complete a misconduct analysis while leaving civil causation and damages unresolved.

Track the actor through the last sentence

In MPRE Key Words and Phrases (2019), NCBE explains that 'attorney' usually identifies the person being tested when 'lawyer' also appears in the question. Suppose a lawyer gives an attorney confidential information and the final sentence asks whether the attorney acted properly. Analyze the recipient's conduct first. The sender's breach might explain how the information arrived while leaving the recipient's obligations to be decided separately. An express role designation in the question controls.

QUIZ

Self-check quiz

Question 1. An ABA committee has issued an opinion interpreting an exception in the Model Rules. State R expressly omitted the exception when adopting its own rule. A lawyer invokes the ABA opinion in a State R disciplinary case governed by that state's rule. Which authority controls?

  1. State R's effective rule as adopted
  2. The ABA opinion because it addresses the precise conduct
  3. The model exception because the state adopted the rest of the rule
  4. Whichever text was published more recently

Question 2. A judge asks whether accepting a gift would violate her judicial ethical obligations. No jurisdiction-specific rule is supplied. Which source most directly addresses the question?

  1. The ABA Model Rules governing a lawyer's acceptance of gifts from clients
  2. The Federal Rules of Evidence governing proof of bias
  3. The ABA Model Code of Judicial Conduct
  4. The prevailing civil standard for setting aside a judgment

Question 3. A trial judge finds that counsel violated a discovery order. An authorized disciplinary investigation is pending. May the court decide a motion for discovery sanctions now?

  1. Only if disciplinary counsel consents to concurrent proceedings
  2. Yes, if the applicable procedural grounds and safeguards are satisfied
  3. Only after the client establishes a compensable injury
  4. Yes, because opening the disciplinary investigation establishes misconduct

Question 4. A former client moves to remove opposing counsel from a pending action. The applicable disqualification standard is supplied in the question. What decision should the tribunal make on that motion?

  1. Whether to suspend the lawyer's state license for the duration of the case
  2. Whether the former client can prove each element of negligence
  3. Whether disciplinary counsel would probably impose a sanction
  4. Whether the stated standard permits the lawyer to continue in this matter

Question 5. A lawyer inadvertently misses a filing deadline. The client proves that competent counsel would have filed on time, but the factfinder determines the underlying claim would have failed even with timely filing. The only damages sought are the value of that claim. Which conclusion follows?

  1. The client must also prove the missed deadline caused the claimed loss and cannot do so on these findings.
  2. The missed deadline creates a presumption of entitlement to the full claimed recovery.
  3. The lawyer's good faith conclusively defeats civil negligence.
  4. The client must obtain a disciplinary finding before bringing a damages claim.
ANSWERS

Answer key

Question 1 - Answer: A. The state adopted its own operative text and omitted the exception. B gives an advisory interpretation binding force, C disregards the deliberate omission, and D treats publication order as a source of legal authority.

Question 2 - Answer: C. The judge asks about ethical obligations attached to judicial office. A addresses a different professional role, B governs proof in proceedings, and D concerns relief from a judgment.

Question 3 - Answer: B. The court can exercise its discovery-sanctions authority under the governing procedure. A gives disciplinary counsel a veto, C imports a malpractice element, and D treats the opening of an inquiry as a finding.

Question 4 - Answer: D. The motion puts continued representation in this proceeding before the tribunal. A changes the scope to licensure, B asks about a damages claim, and C substitutes a prediction about discipline for the supplied standard.

Question 5 - Answer: A. Timely filing would not have produced a recovery, so the breach did not cause the only loss claimed. B presumes a recovery the facts defeat, C confuses an inadvertent error with due care, and D invents a disciplinary prerequisite.

RAPID

Rapid review

  • Final authority over a state license → generally the state's highest court.
  • Board or committee action → read the delegation to determine its legal effect.
  • Conflict between model and local text → the effective adopted text governs local discipline.
  • Federal courtroom or agency appearance → check that forum's admission and practice authority.
  • MPRE procedure or evidence question → begin with federal rules unless otherwise stated.
  • ABA amendment → earliest testing eligibility is one year after approval.
  • Permission with conditions → discretion exists only within the exception's scope.
  • Negligence damages → the client must connect breach of duty to compensable injury.
  • Removal from one proceeding → apply the tribunal's disqualification standard.
  • Rule validly adopted → check any controlling constitutional limit on enforcement.
  • Split outside professional discipline → use the majority approach unless the stem supplies a different rule.
  • ABA change inside its first year → the earlier provision remains testable for lawyers and judges.
  • 'May' or 'proper' → consider the preamble, comments, and law governing lawyers along with the disciplinary text.
  • Opponent invokes an ethics violation → identify an independent basis for standing and relief.

References

  • MPRE Subject Matter Outline. National Conference of Bar Examiners. 2013.
  • Preparing for the MPRE. National Conference of Bar Examiners.
  • Model Rules of Professional Conduct. American Bar Association.
  • Model Code of Judicial Conduct. American Bar Association. 2007.
  • Federal Rules of Evidence. United States Courts.
  • Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. United States Courts.
  • MPRE Key Words and Phrases. National Conference of Bar Examiners, 2019.
End of your free lesson

Keep going with the full Multistate Professional Responsibility Examination (MPRE) Prep Course

You just studied the way members do, in the same lesson interface. Full access unlocks every lesson, the question bank and flashcards for a full year.

Up next with full access1.1.2 - Admission and Application Candor

One payment per program