Skip to content
Free previewYou are reading 1 of 194 lessons, in the same interface members use. Everything else unlocks with full access.Get full access · $150

1.1.1 - Federal Subject Matter Jurisdiction

What you'll learn

  • Determine whether a plaintiff's claim arises under federal law.
  • Identify each party's citizenship and test complete diversity.
  • Calculate the amount in controversy using the correct aggregation rules.
  • Separate jurisdictional defects from defenses, procedural objections, and failures on the merits.
  • Recognize special jurisdictional grants and limits.

Estimated reading time: 24 minutes.

WHY

Why it matters

A federal court needs authority over the category of dispute before it can decide the parties' rights. Bar questions often supply a strong federal defense, a misleading business address, or several small claims to make a jurisdictionally defective action appear eligible for federal court.

KEY TERMS

Key terms

Subject matter jurisdiction
A court's authority to adjudicate a category of cases.
Well-pleaded complaint
The plaintiff's properly pleaded affirmative claim, separated from anticipated defenses and responsive claims.
Domicile
A person's established home, maintained until physical presence and intent establish a new one.
Complete diversity
A configuration in which no plaintiff shares relevant citizenship with any defendant.
Nerve center
The actual place where a corporation's officers direct, control, and coordinate its activities.
Amount in controversy
The value genuinely placed at issue when the action begins, measured under the governing jurisdictional rules.
Aggregation
Combining amounts from multiple claims when the applicable rules permit collective valuation.
CORE

Core content

1.1.1.1 Jurisdiction concerns the court's power over the dispute

Federal courts exercise limited jurisdiction. Article III of the U.S. Constitution identifies the constitutional categories of federal judicial power; Congress supplies statutory authority for the lower federal courts within those limits. The existence of a federal courthouse, a national business, or an interstate transaction establishes no jurisdiction by itself.

The party invoking federal jurisdiction bears the burden of establishing it. A plaintiff filing in federal court ordinarily must state the jurisdictional grounds in the complaint under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8(a)(1). When citizenship allegations are disputed, the court may examine evidence rather than treating an unsupported allegation as conclusive.

The following comparison separates four questions that can produce different procedural outcomes.

Table 1. Four distinct objections
QuestionWhat it testsIllustrative problemEffect of consent
Subject matter jurisdictionPower over this category of disputeNo federal claim and no qualifying diversityConsent cannot supply missing power
Personal jurisdictionPower over this defendantInsufficient forum contactsConsent or waiver can matter
VenueProper geographic districtSuit filed in an unauthorized districtObjection can be waived
Failure to state a claimLegal sufficiency of the asserted entitlementA necessary substantive element is missingAgreement does not establish substantive liability

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(1) permits a motion challenging subject matter jurisdiction. Rule 12(h)(3) requires dismissal whenever the court determines jurisdiction is absent, even if neither party raised the issue. A defendant's participation, an expired pleading deadline, or the parties' written agreement cannot cure the missing authority. In a removed case, the ordinary response to a lack of subject matter jurisdiction is remand to state court rather than dismissal of the underlying state action.

A jurisdictional dismissal ordinarily does not decide whether the plaintiff owns a valid substantive claim. By contrast, Rule 12(b)(6) addresses failure to state a claim. A statutory requirement is not automatically jurisdictional merely because it is mandatory or determines whether the plaintiff wins; Congress must make the jurisdictional character sufficiently clear.

Separate powers. A court may possess subject matter jurisdiction yet lack personal jurisdiction over a particular defendant. Conversely, a defendant's consent to personal jurisdiction supplies no missing federal subject matter jurisdiction.

A Checkpoint

After a year of federal litigation, the judge discovers that the complaint asserts only a state claim between citizens of the same state. No supplemental or specialized statutory basis exists. Both parties ask the judge to decide the case. What should the judge do?

  1. Dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.
  2. Proceed because both parties consented.
  3. Proceed because the defendant did not object in the first response.
  4. Enter judgment for the defendant on the merits.
Answer: A. Rule 12(h)(3) requires dismissal once the absence of jurisdiction is determined. C imports the waiver rules for certain personal-jurisdiction and venue objections into a category where those rules do not apply.

1.1.1.2 A federal question must belong to the affirmative claim

Under 28 U.S.C. section 1331, federal district courts have original jurisdiction over civil actions arising under the Constitution, laws, or treaties of the United States. There is no general amount-in-controversy minimum for this grant. A properly asserted federal statutory cause of action seeking $2,000 can therefore qualify.

The usual route is a claim created by federal law. Apply the well-pleaded complaint rule by identifying the legal elements the plaintiff must establish to obtain relief. A state contract claim does not become federal merely because the defendant intends to rely on a federal statute, the plaintiff predicts that defense, or the defendant asserts a federal counterclaim. Whether a defense is likely to determine the outcome does not change whose claim supplies the jurisdictional basis.

The following flowchart isolates the less common embedded-issue route. See Fig 1.

Fig 1. Federal-question routes
Key point: A state-law claim needs every embedded-issue requirement, not merely a reference to federal law.
flowchart TD
A["Plaintiff's affirmative claim"] --> B{"Federal law creates claim?"}
B -->|Yes| C["Federal-question route"]
B -->|No| D{"Federal issue necessarily raised?"}
D -->|No| E["No embedded-issue jurisdiction"]
D -->|Yes| F{"Actually disputed and substantial?"}
F -->|No| E
F -->|Yes| G{"Federal-state balance preserved?"}
G -->|No| E
G -->|Yes| C

A state-created claim can arise under federal law when a federal issue is necessarily raised, actually disputed, substantial to the federal system as a whole, and capable of resolution in federal court without disrupting the congressionally approved federal-state balance. Each requirement does distinct work. A claim that can succeed on an independent state-law theory may not necessarily raise the federal issue. A federal question already conceded by the parties is not actually disputed.

Substantiality concerns the federal system, not simply the dollars or importance of the dispute to these litigants. A retrospective malpractice suit asking whether a lawyer would have won a past patent case ordinarily lacks the necessary system-wide significance. Its hypothetical patent analysis resolves the malpractice dispute without controlling the underlying patent's validity against others.

The following table distinguishes three ways federal law can enter a pleading.

Table 2. How federal law enters the case
ConfigurationFunction of federal lawJurisdictional consequence
Federal statutory cause of actionCreates plaintiff's right to reliefOrdinarily supports section 1331 jurisdiction
Federal defense to a state claimDefeats otherwise available reliefOrdinarily does not support section 1331 jurisdiction
Necessary embedded issueForms an essential part of a state claimRequires all four embedded-issue conditions
Complete preemptionReplaces a covered state claim with an exclusive federal claimExceptionally supports federal recharacterization
Federal counterclaimAsserts defendant's responsive entitlementOrdinarily does not establish the complaint's federal-question basis

Ordinary preemption means federal law displaces an otherwise applicable state rule; it ordinarily operates as a defense. Complete preemption is narrower: Congress has so displaced a particular category of state claims that a covered claim is treated as federal from its inception. Section 301 of the Labor Management Relations Act is a standard example. A question must support that exceptional recharacterization; ordinary conflict with a federal regulation is insufficient.

The Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. sections 2201-2202, provides a remedy rather than an independent jurisdictional grant. For federal-question analysis, reconstruct the coercive action that the declaration would anticipate. If a manufacturer seeks a declaration that a federal statute defeats a customer's threatened state contract action, the anticipated coercive action remains state-created. If the declaration instead anticipates an actual federal infringement action, federal-question jurisdiction may exist.

Worked case

A retired engineer sues a former employer in federal court for $42,000 in promised retirement benefits under an ordinary state contract. Both are citizens of Ohio. The complaint devotes several paragraphs to a federal defense the employer has threatened to raise. Assume no complete preemption or other specialized jurisdictional statute applies.

The engineer's affirmative entitlement comes from the contract, so the federal defense does not establish section 1331 jurisdiction. Diversity also fails because the opposing parties share citizenship, and the demand independently falls below the diversity threshold. The engineer's retirement status and the length of the federal-law discussion change neither conclusion. The federal court should dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction, leaving any available state-court action to the appropriate forum.

A weak federal claim presents a different problem. A colorable federal cause of action ordinarily permits the court to decide whether its elements are satisfied. If the plaintiff fails to plead an element, dismissal may be on the merits under Rule 12(b)(6). An assertion that is wholly insubstantial, frivolous, or merely fabricated to obtain federal jurisdiction does not receive the same treatment. Distinguish a genuine dispute over entitlement from the absence of any plausible federal controversy.

1.1.1.3 Diversity requires a citizenship map of every opposing party

Ordinary diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. section 1332(a) requires both a qualifying citizenship arrangement and an amount in controversy exceeding $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs. Complete diversity means every plaintiff must be diverse from every defendant. Two Texas plaintiffs may sue two Oklahoma defendants; the plaintiffs' shared citizenship is harmless. Add a Texas defendant, however, and ordinary complete diversity fails.

A Individuals and changes of home

A natural person is a citizen of a state for diversity purposes when the person is a U.S. citizen domiciled there. Domicile requires physical presence plus intent to remain indefinitely. The person need not promise to stay forever. Residence, property ownership, a driver's license, voting registration, employment, and family location supply evidence, but an address alone does not settle the question.

An established domicile continues until a new one is acquired. A student attending a two-year program in another state with a fixed plan to return home ordinarily retains the original domicile. A person who moves to another state for an open-ended job and makes it a home may acquire a new domicile immediately, even while keeping a house elsewhere.

The following comparison identifies which facts matter for each party type.

Table 3. Citizenship by party type
PartyCitizenship ruleMisleading fact
Individual U.S. citizenState of domicileTemporary mailing address
Ordinary corporationEvery incorporation jurisdiction plus principal place of businessLargest sales market alone
LLCEvery member's citizenshipFormation state or headquarters alone
PartnershipEvery partner's citizenshipBusiness registration address
Estate representativeDecedent's citizenshipExecutor's personal domicile
Infant's or incompetent's legal representativeRepresented person's citizenshipGuardian's personal domicile

B Corporations and unincorporated entities

An ordinary corporation has citizenship in every state or foreign state of incorporation and in the state or foreign state containing its principal place of business under section 1332(c)(1). For a domestic corporation, this often produces two state citizenships. A Delaware corporation directed from Illinois is a citizen of both states even if its largest factory and most employees are in Michigan.

The principal place of business is ordinarily the nerve center: the actual location where officers direct, control, and coordinate corporate activity. A nominal headquarters or occasional board-meeting site does not control when real direction occurs elsewhere. The geographic volume of business can be relevant evidence, but it does not replace the nerve-center inquiry.

An LLC, limited partnership, or general partnership ordinarily takes the citizenship of all members or partners, including limited partners. Trace ownership through every constituent entity until the relevant citizenships can be identified. An LLC member that is another LLC requires another layer of member analysis; an LLC member that is a corporation requires the corporate citizenship rules.

The following party map supplies facts for the next checkpoint. See Fig 2.

Fig 2. Tracing an LLC's citizenship
Key point: Each ownership branch contributes citizenship to the LLC.
flowchart TD
A["Harbor LLC"] --> B["Member Lena: Nevada domicile"]
A --> C["Member Beacon Corporation"]
C --> D["Incorporated in Delaware"]
C --> E["Nerve center in Arizona"]

C Checkpoint

Using Fig 2, which plaintiff could sue Harbor LLC alone under ordinary diversity jurisdiction on a $120,000 state-law claim, assuming each plaintiff is a U.S. citizen and no exception applies?

  1. A person domiciled in Nevada
  2. A person domiciled in Arizona
  3. A person domiciled in Colorado
  4. A person domiciled in Delaware
Answer: C. Harbor LLC has Nevada, Delaware, and Arizona citizenship through the two ownership branches. B is tempting if only Beacon's incorporation state is counted, but its Arizona nerve center also contributes citizenship.

D Foreign citizenship and filing time

A U.S. citizen domiciled abroad is neither a citizen of a state nor a citizen of a foreign country for section 1332(a). That person cannot ordinarily rely on either state-citizen diversity or alienage jurisdiction. Foreign residence does not convert U.S. nationality into foreign nationality.

Alienage rules require attention to the entire alignment, not simply the presence of someone from another country. The following table assumes the amount requirement is satisfied and no other jurisdictional grant applies.

Table 4. Citizenship configurations under ordinary diversity
Plaintiff sideDefendant sideSection 1332(a) result
Georgia citizenFrench citizen domiciled in FranceOrdinary alienage configuration permitted
French citizenGerman citizenAlien-versus-alien dispute does not qualify
Georgia citizen and French citizenTexas citizen and German citizenDiverse state citizens with additional foreign parties may qualify
Georgia citizenFrench permanent resident domiciled in GeorgiaSame-state permanent-resident exclusion applies
U.S. citizen domiciled in FranceTexas citizenU.S. expatriate lacks qualifying state or alien citizenship
Georgia citizen and French citizenGerman citizen onlyAlien parties on both sides without opposing diverse state citizens do not qualify

Section 1332(a)(2) specifically excludes suits between a state citizen and a foreign citizen lawfully admitted for permanent residence who is domiciled in that same state. Permanent-resident status does not generally transform the foreign citizen into a state citizen for all diversity purposes. Section 1332(a)(3), by contrast, allows citizens of different states to litigate with foreign citizens as additional parties.

Citizenship ordinarily is measured when the action is filed. A validly diverse plaintiff's later move to the defendant's state ordinarily does not destroy jurisdiction. A nondiverse plaintiff's later move ordinarily does not repair the original defect. Party dismissal, amendment, substitution, and removal can introduce additional rules; do not treat a mere postfiling address change as a universal cure.

Match each party type to the controlling source of citizenship.

Individual:
Physical presence plus intent establishing a home.
Corporation:
Incorporation jurisdictions and actual executive control location.
LLC:
Citizenship traced through every owner.
Estate representative:
The decedent's citizenship rather than the executor's.

1.1.1.4 The amount requirement measures what is genuinely at stake

Section 1332(a) requires an amount exceeding $75,000. A claim for exactly $75,000 is insufficient. The amount claimed in good faith ordinarily controls unless it appears to a legal certainty that the plaintiff cannot recover enough to cross the threshold. A prediction that a jury probably will award less is weaker than a controlling damages cap that makes a sufficient award legally impossible.

Evaluate the stakes when the action begins. If a plaintiff genuinely seeks $100,000 on a legally available theory and later recovers $40,000, that result ordinarily does not retrospectively eliminate jurisdiction. Similarly, a postfiling reduction in the demand ordinarily does not defeat jurisdiction that already attached.

The following comparison shows which components can increase the jurisdictional value.

Table 5. Components of the amount in controversy
ComponentOrdinary treatmentCondition or distinction
Compensatory damagesCountMust be legally recoverable and claimed in good faith
Punitive damagesMay countGoverning substantive law must permit them
Attorney's feesMay countA statute or contract must authorize recovery
Ordinary court costsExcludeFiling and similar litigation expenses do not bridge the gap
Interest for delayed paymentExcludeDistinct from interest that itself forms part of the substantive claim
Injunction or declarationValue the object of litigationApplicable valuation perspective may vary by court

For equitable relief, ask what the requested order is worth in the dispute. An injunction protecting a valuable property right can satisfy the threshold without a large damages demand. Courts differ on whether to measure only the plaintiff's benefit or also the defendant's compliance burden. When that difference changes the answer, use the governing approach supplied in the question rather than inventing a nationwide valuation rule.

A Combining claims

One plaintiff may aggregate multiple claims against one defendant, even if those claims concern unrelated events. Claims against different defendants ordinarily remain separate when each defendant has a distinct liability. Joint liability for one obligation is different: the value of that single obligation is not divided merely because multiple defendants are jointly responsible.

Different plaintiffs ordinarily cannot combine separate interests to cross the threshold. A genuinely common and undivided interest, such as a single jointly owned right that must be enforced collectively, can be valued as a whole. Similar injuries arising from one accident do not alone create such an interest.

The following examples assume complete diversity and ordinary section 1332(a) rules.

Table 6. Aggregation outcomes
ClaimsAggregation ruleAmount result
One plaintiff, one defendant: $46,000 contract and $35,000 tort claimsUnrelated claims may be combined$81,000 satisfies threshold
One plaintiff: $46,000 against D1 and $35,000 against D2 separatelyIndependent liabilities remain separateNeither claim independently qualifies
Two plaintiffs: separate $40,000 injuries against one defendantSeparate injuries cannot be combinedNeither claim independently qualifies
One plaintiff: $90,000 obligation jointly owed by two defendantsSingle joint obligation retains full value$90,000 satisfies threshold
Two plaintiffs enforcing one common, undivided $100,000 rightCollective interest valued as a whole$100,000 satisfies threshold

Worked case

A Nevada citizen sues an Arizona citizen for $48,000 under an unpaid consulting contract and $31,000 for damage to a vintage vehicle in an unrelated accident. The defendant argues that the claims concern different events. The plaintiff also requests $2,000 in ordinary court costs and mentions a relative's separate $20,000 accident injury.

The same plaintiff asserts both substantive claims against the same defendant, so the $48,000 and $31,000 may be combined to produce $79,000. The unrelated events do not prevent aggregation. Ordinary costs are excluded, and the relative's separate injury contributes nothing to this plaintiff's amount. Assuming good-faith demands and legally available damages, the action satisfies the amount requirement without those additions.

1.1.1.5 Special grants and exceptions change the ordinary analysis

Section 1331 and section 1332 are major routes, but they are not the entire jurisdictional system. A question naming a specialized statute may require that statute's rules instead of the ordinary diversity framework. Federal jurisdiction also does not automatically mean exclusive federal jurisdiction: state courts generally can hear federal claims unless Congress has made the relevant jurisdiction exclusive.

The following comparison places important boundaries around the ordinary routes.

Table 7. Specialized grants and limits
Instrument or doctrineWhat it changesNecessary distinction
28 U.S.C. section 1338(a)Patent infringement and copyright actions fall within exclusive federal jurisdictionA contract about patented goods is not automatically an infringement action
28 U.S.C. section 1334Supplies bankruptcy jurisdictionBankruptcy cases are exclusive; related civil proceedings have different statutory treatment
28 U.S.C. section 1332(d)Supplies special class-action diversity rulesMinimal diversity and aggregate valuation differ from ordinary section 1332(a)
28 U.S.C. section 1359Bars improper or collusive manufacture of jurisdictionA sham assignment does not create a valid federal forum
Domestic-relations exceptionLimits diversity jurisdiction over divorce, alimony, and child-custody decreesA family-related damages action is not automatically excluded
Probate exceptionReserves probate functions and property in probate-court custodyAn independent personal-liability claim may remain within federal jurisdiction

The Class Action Fairness Act, reflected in section 1332(d), generally requires minimal diversity, at least 100 proposed class members, and an aggregate amount exceeding $5 million for covered class actions. Minimal diversity requires at least one qualifying plaintiff-defendant citizenship difference, rather than complete separation of every opposing citizenship. Local-controversy, home-state, and other statutory exceptions can require or permit a federal court to decline jurisdiction. These special rules do not allow two ordinary plaintiffs to aggregate separate $40,000 injuries in a nonclass action.

The domestic-relations exception concerns federal issuance of divorce, alimony, and child-custody decrees under diversity jurisdiction. A tort suit between former spouses is not excluded solely because the parties once were married. The probate exception prevents a federal court from probating or annulling a will, administering an estate, or disposing of property in a state probate court's custody. It does not categorically bar every damages claim involving an estate.

A Related claims and movement from state court

Under 28 U.S.C. section 1367, supplemental jurisdiction can reach additional claims sharing a common nucleus of operative fact with a claim within original jurisdiction. It can sometimes reach a related claim that does not independently satisfy the amount threshold, including an additional diverse plaintiff's claim when another plaintiff satisfies that threshold. It does not erase a complete-diversity defect. In cases founded solely on diversity, section 1367(b) restricts specified plaintiff-side claims involving joined parties; section 1367(c) also permits discretionary refusal in specified circumstances.

Under 28 U.S.C. section 1441, removal ordinarily allows a defendant to transfer a qualifying state action to federal court if original federal jurisdiction exists. A federal defense ordinarily cannot support removal based on federal-question jurisdiction. Separate removal restrictions may prevent removal even though the plaintiff could originally have filed in federal court. See also Supplemental Jurisdiction and Removal for the forum-defendant rule, timing, consent, and the detailed supplemental-jurisdiction limitations.

The following sequence organizes the difference between an independently qualifying claim and a related claim that needs supplemental authority. See Fig 3.

Fig 3. Additional-claim jurisdiction
Key point: Relatedness begins supplemental analysis, but statutory restrictions and discretion remain separate inquiries.
flowchart TD
A["Additional claim"] --> B{"Independent original jurisdiction?"}
B -->|Yes| C["Independent jurisdictional basis"]
B -->|No| D{"Same constitutional case?"}
D -->|No| E["Supplemental route unavailable"]
D -->|Yes| F{"Statutory restrictions apply?"}
F -->|Yes| E
F -->|No| G["Consider discretionary refusal"]

Use the following questions to retrieve the governing distinctions without rereading the tables.

B Recall check

Which two elements establish a new individual domicile?
Physical presence in the new state and intent to remain there indefinitely.
Which citizenships belong to an ordinary corporation?
Every jurisdiction of incorporation and the jurisdiction containing its principal place of business.
How does a U.S. citizen domiciled abroad fit ordinary diversity categories?
The person is neither a state citizen nor an alien for section 1332(a).
What amount must ordinary diversity place in controversy?
More than $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs.
What four conditions govern a state claim's embedded federal issue?
The issue must be necessarily raised, actually disputed, substantial to the federal system, and resolvable without disrupting the federal-state balance.
What distinguishes an amount allegation from an eventual award?
A good-faith demand governs unless legally insufficient to a certainty; a later smaller award ordinarily does not undo jurisdiction.
COMMON MISTAKE

Common mistakes

These confusions usually arise from applying a real rule to the wrong jurisdictional question.

Table 8. Similar facts with different legal effects
Tempting conclusionWhy it attracts attentionFact that settles the issue
A decisive federal defense creates federal-question jurisdictionThe litigation may turn entirely on federal lawThe affirmative claim remains state-created
An LLC has its corporation-style headquarters citizenshipBoth entities offer limited liabilityThe defendant is an LLC, so member citizenship controls
A move automatically changes citizenshipThe person now lives elsewhereA fixed plan to return may preserve the established domicile
Two $40,000 injuries satisfy diversity togetherThe injuries arose in the same accidentSeparate plaintiffs own separate claims
A failed federal theory proves jurisdiction was absentThe plaintiff ultimately cannot recoverA colorable federal claim can fail on the merits
ALGO

Approach

Analyze the original claim first, then determine whether each additional claim has its own jurisdictional support.

Locate the affirmative entitlement. Identify whether federal law creates the plaintiff's claim, or whether the embedded-issue requirements are satisfied.
Map every party's citizenship. Apply domicile, corporate citizenship, or member tracing as appropriate, using the relevant filing-time facts.
Test the citizenship alignment. Compare every plaintiff with every defendant and apply the correct alienage or special statutory rule.
Value the controversy. Apply the amount threshold, legal-certainty standard, recoverable components, and permitted aggregation.
Check grants and limits. Consider exclusive jurisdiction, the domestic-relations and probate exceptions, collusion, and any applicable specialized statute.
Resolve remaining claims and procedure. Examine supplemental jurisdiction or removal separately, then distinguish dismissal, remand, and a merits ruling.
QUIZ

Self-check quiz

Question 1

A Florida citizen sues a Florida corporation in federal court for $160,000 under state negligence law. The corporation argues that a federal safety statute preempts the claim. Assume ordinary defensive preemption and no embedded federal issue. Does the court have subject matter jurisdiction?

  1. Yes, because the amount exceeds $75,000.
  2. Yes, because preemption requires interpreting federal law.
  3. Yes, because federal safety statutes make all related claims exclusively federal.
  4. No, because neither federal-question nor diversity jurisdiction is established.

Question 2

A U.S. citizen domiciled in New York moves to Oregon for an open-ended job, takes possession of an apartment, and intends to remain indefinitely. The next day, she files a $100,000 state-law action against a New York citizen. She retains a New York bank account. Which conclusion is best?

  1. Diversity fails until she has lived in Oregon for one year.
  2. She has acquired Oregon domicile, so the citizenship requirement is satisfied.
  3. She remains a New York citizen until she closes the bank account.
  4. She is a citizen of both states because she has financial ties to each.

Question 3

A Colorado citizen sues a Utah citizen in federal court. She demands $66,000 in compensatory damages and $15,000 in punitive damages, both in good faith. Governing state law permits punitive damages on the alleged facts and imposes no relevant cap. She ultimately recovers only $20,000. What follows?

  1. Jurisdiction is absent because compensatory damages alone do not exceed $75,000.
  2. Jurisdiction disappears when the jury returns the smaller award.
  3. The amount requirement was satisfied at filing, and the later award ordinarily does not defeat jurisdiction.
  4. The punitive demand counts only after the jury awards it.

Question 4

Using Table 6, assume complete diversity and no supplemental jurisdiction. One plaintiff asserts an unrelated $46,000 contract claim and $35,000 tort claim against the same defendant. Which fact would change the amount analysis so that aggregation no longer supplies jurisdiction?

  1. The $35,000 claim instead belongs to a second plaintiff with a separate injury.
  2. The claims arose in different years.
  3. The claims require different witnesses.
  4. The plaintiff also requests ordinary court costs.

Question 5

A plaintiff asserts a nonfrivolous federal statutory cause of action seeking $8,000. The defendant argues that the complaint omits a required substantive element. The statute does not make that element jurisdictional. What is the best characterization?

  1. The demand is too small for federal-question jurisdiction.
  2. The objection necessarily concerns personal jurisdiction.
  3. The missing element makes subject matter jurisdiction depend on the defendant's consent.
  4. The court may possess federal-question jurisdiction while considering dismissal for failure to state a claim.
ANSWERS

Answer key

Question 1 - Answer: D. The affirmative claim is state-created, the federal issue enters only as a defense, and opposing parties share Florida citizenship. A mistakes the amount requirement for a complete jurisdictional basis; B overlooks the well-pleaded complaint rule; C assumes exclusivity and a federal cause of action without statutory support.

Question 2 - Answer: B. Physical presence and an indefinite intention to remain establish Oregon domicile before filing. A invents a durational requirement; C treats one evidentiary tie as controlling; D confuses financial connections with simultaneous state domiciles.

Question 3 - Answer: C. Legally available punitive damages bring the good-faith demand to $81,000, and the smaller verdict ordinarily does not undo filing-time jurisdiction. A improperly excludes punitive damages; B substitutes the verdict for the original controversy; D postpones valuation until after adjudication.

Question 4 - Answer: A. Table 6 permits aggregation by one plaintiff against one defendant but distinguishes separate injuries owned by separate plaintiffs. B and C concern factual differences that do not prevent permitted aggregation; D adds an excluded cost request without removing the existing $81,000 controversy.

Question 5 - Answer: D. A colorable federal claim supplies a jurisdictional basis even when its substantive pleading may be deficient. A imports the diversity threshold into section 1331; B confuses claim sufficiency with power over a defendant; C incorrectly makes federal subject matter jurisdiction depend on agreement.

RAPID

Rapid review

  • Subject matter defect → parties cannot waive or consent around it.
  • Federal defense → ordinarily outside the affirmative-claim jurisdictional inquiry.
  • Embedded federal issue → necessity, dispute, systemic significance, and proper federal-state balance.
  • Individual citizenship → U.S. citizenship plus state domicile.
  • Corporate citizenship → incorporation jurisdictions plus the nerve center.
  • LLC citizenship → trace every member through every ownership layer.
  • Ordinary diversity → qualifying opposing citizenships and more than $75,000.
  • Aggregation → one plaintiff may combine unrelated claims against one defendant.
  • Later smaller award → ordinarily leaves valid filing-time jurisdiction intact.
  • Colorable federal claim with missing element → consider merits dismissal rather than automatically denying jurisdiction.

See also: Supplemental Jurisdiction and Removal; Personal Jurisdiction and Service; Venue and Forum Transfer; Erie and Federal Common Law; Claim and Party Joinder; Class Action Certification.

References

  • MBE Subject Matter Outline. National Conference of Bar Examiners, revision dated November 16, 2020.
  • Constitution of the United States, Article III. United States.
  • United States Code, Title 28, sections 1331-1332, 1334, 1338, 1359, 1367, 1441, and 2201-2202. United States.
  • Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rules 8 and 12. United States.
  • Labor Management Relations Act, section 301, codified at 29 U.S.C. section 185. United States, 1947.
End of your free lesson

Keep going with the full Uniform Bar Exam (UBE) Prep Course

You just studied the way members do, in the same lesson interface. Full access unlocks every lesson, the question bank and flashcards for a full year.

Up next with full access1.1.2 - Supplemental Jurisdiction and Removal

One payment per program