Skip to content
Free previewYou are reading 1 of 195 lessons, in the same interface members use. Everything else unlocks with full access.Get full access · $150

1.1.1 - Federal Subject Matter Jurisdiction

What you'll learn

  • Recognize a federal question from the plaintiff's claim.
  • Determine the citizenship of individuals and business entities.
  • Apply the diversity amount and aggregation rules.
  • Analyze supplemental claims and statutory limits.
  • Choose dismissal, remand, or continued adjudication when jurisdiction is challenged.

Estimated reading time: 30 minutes.

WHY

Why it matters

A federal court needs authority over the kind of dispute before it can decide the merits. Multiple-choice questions often hide the jurisdictional defect in one party's citizenship or one additional claim; essays require separate treatment of the original claim and each supplemental claim.

KEY TERMS

Key terms

Subject matter jurisdiction
A court's authority to adjudicate a category of cases.
Original jurisdiction
Authority to hear a claim independently of supplemental jurisdiction.
Domicile
A person's established home, combining physical presence and intent to remain indefinitely.
Complete diversity
No plaintiff shares citizenship with any defendant.
Well-pleaded complaint
The plaintiff's properly pleaded statement of the claim itself, without anticipated defenses.
Common nucleus of operative fact
A factual connection strong enough that claims ordinarily would be expected to be tried together.
Coercive action
An action seeking an enforceable remedy, such as damages or an injunction, rather than only a declaration.
CORE

Core content

1.1.1.1 Federal courts need constitutional and statutory authority

Article III, Section 2 of the United States Constitution establishes the outer boundary of federal judicial power. Congress determines how much of that power federal district courts may exercise through jurisdictional statutes. Constitutional permission alone therefore does not establish district court jurisdiction. Ordinary diversity illustrates the distinction: Article III can permit minimal diversity, but the general diversity statute ordinarily demands complete diversity.

The principal statutory routes are federal question jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1331 and diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332. Supplemental jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1367 extends a qualifying action to certain additional claims. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 82 confirms that procedural rules do not expand district court jurisdiction: permission to join a claim or party is a separate inquiry from authority to adjudicate it.

Jurisdiction is not consent. The party invoking federal jurisdiction bears the burden of establishing it. Agreement, a forum-selection clause, silence, and extensive litigation cannot supply missing subject matter jurisdiction. Personal jurisdiction, service, and venue remain separate questions; some objections to them can be waived.

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(1) authorizes a motion asserting lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Under Rule 12(h)(3), the court must act whenever it determines that jurisdiction is absent, including on its own initiative during the action or on direct review. A court may examine jurisdictional facts rather than accept a conclusory assertion that diversity exists.

The procedural consequence depends on how the case reached federal court. The following table separates an actual jurisdictional defect from a discretionary decision about related claims.

Table 1. What follows a jurisdictional problem
SituationGoverning instrumentUsual result
Originally filed action lacks subject matter jurisdictionFederal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(h)(3)Dismiss without prejudice to litigation in a competent forum.
Removed action lacks subject matter jurisdiction28 U.S.C. § 1447(c)Remand to the state court before final judgment.
Federal anchor claims dismissed; related state claims remain28 U.S.C. § 1367(c)(3)Decide whether to retain or decline supplemental claims.
Pleading inaccurately describes existing jurisdictional facts28 U.S.C. § 1653Amend defective allegations when appropriate.

A jurisdictional dismissal does not adjudicate whether the defendant breached a contract or committed a tort. It establishes that this federal court lacks authority to reach those merits. Removal procedures and the separate deadline for nonjurisdictional removal objections are addressed in Venue Removal and Remand.

A Separate removal defects from jurisdictional defects

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c), a motion to remand for a nonjurisdictional removal defect must be made within 30 days after the notice of removal is filed. An untimely removal notice is a procedural defect; absence of original federal jurisdiction is different. Participation does not cure missing jurisdiction, but waiting beyond the statutory window generally forfeits a procedural remand objection. See also Venue Removal and Remand.

1.1.1.2 Federal question jurisdiction follows the plaintiff's claim

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1331, federal district courts have original jurisdiction over civil actions arising under the United States Constitution, federal laws, or treaties. There is no general monetary minimum. A properly asserted federal statutory claim seeking $2,000 can qualify even when both parties are Illinois citizens.

Usually, federal law creates the plaintiff's cause of action. A federal civil-rights claim is a straightforward example. Under the well-pleaded complaint rule, a federal defense does not convert a state cause of action into a federal claim. The same is true when the complaint anticipates that defense or argues that the defense is invalid. An ordinary federal counterclaim likewise does not establish § 1331 jurisdiction over the plaintiff's state-law action.

The following comparison turns on the source and role of the federal issue, rather than the number of times federal law appears in the pleadings.

Table 2. Federal issues in different procedural positions
Federal issue appears asExampleOrdinary § 1331 result
Plaintiff's federal cause of actionClaim for violation of a federal civil-rights statuteQualifies, assuming a genuine federal controversy.
Defendant's defenseFederal law allegedly preempts a state negligence claimDoes not qualify merely because of the defense.
Anticipated defense in complaintContract plaintiff alleges a federal defense will failDoes not qualify merely because it is anticipated.
Defendant's counterclaimFederal claim asserted against a state contract plaintiffDoes not ordinarily establish § 1331 over the original action.
Necessary embedded issueState claim necessarily requiring a substantial federal-law determinationQualifies only if all embedded-issue requirements are met.

A A state claim can contain a qualifying federal issue

A narrow category of state-law causes of action falls within § 1331 because resolving the state claim necessarily requires deciding a federal issue. The issue must be necessarily raised, actually disputed, substantial to the federal system as a whole, and capable of resolution in federal court without disturbing the congressionally approved federal-state balance. All four requirements matter.

An issue is not necessarily raised if the plaintiff can prevail through an alternative theory that avoids federal law. Importance to the litigants does not by itself establish federal-system substantiality. For example, a backward-looking legal-malpractice claim involving a hypothetical patent outcome generally presents a different jurisdictional question from an actual patent infringement action. The former ordinarily leaves the federal patent system unaffected.

Worked case

An Illinois musician sues an Illinois promoter for $120,000 for breach of a performance agreement. The musician's complaint alleges that a federal regulation does not excuse the promoter's cancellation. The promoter admits the agreement but argues that the regulation required cancellation. The venue had also recently changed its parking policy.

The claim seeks a state contract remedy. The federal regulation enters as the promoter's justification, even though the musician discussed it first in the complaint. Under the well-pleaded complaint rule, anticipating that defense does not create a federal claim. The parking policy has no bearing on jurisdiction. Ordinary diversity also fails because both parties are Illinois citizens. Unless a separate jurisdictional grant applies, the federal court must dismiss an originally filed action without deciding who correctly interpreted the regulation.

B Declaratory relief, preemption, and exclusivity

The Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. § 2201, supplies a remedy rather than an independent jurisdictional grant. For a federal question analysis, reconstruct the coercive action that would exist without the requested declaration. If an insurer seeks a declaration that it has a federal defense to an insured's state contract action, the reversal of party positions ordinarily does not create § 1331 jurisdiction. Diversity might independently support the action.

Complete preemption is a narrow exception to ordinary complaint analysis: Congress has so completely displaced a category of state claims that a covered claim is treated as federal. A covered claim for benefits within the exclusive civil-enforcement framework of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, ERISA § 502(a), is a standard example. Ordinary preemption simply defeats or limits a state claim and remains a defense. The existence of extensive federal regulation alone does not establish complete preemption.

Federal question jurisdiction generally permits concurrent state-court jurisdiction. Exclusivity requires an additional rule. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1338(a), state courts lack jurisdiction over claims arising under federal patent, plant variety protection, and copyright laws; the same provision does not make trademark jurisdiction exclusive. The nature of the claim, rather than a loose connection to intellectual property, controls.

C Checkpoint

Two Illinois citizens dispute a $150,000 state-law contract. The defendant plans to assert ordinary federal preemption. The complaint anticipates and rejects that defense. Which conclusion is best?

  1. The anticipated defense does not establish federal question jurisdiction.
  2. The amount establishes diversity jurisdiction despite shared citizenship.
  3. The federal defense automatically converts the contract claim into a federal claim.
  4. The parties can establish subject matter jurisdiction by consenting.
Answer: A. The federal issue arises as a defense to a state claim. C confuses ordinary preemption with the narrow doctrine of complete preemption.

1.1.1.3 Diversity depends on citizenship across opposing sides

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a), ordinary diversity requires complete diversity: compare every plaintiff with every defendant. Two plaintiffs may share citizenship with each other, and two defendants may share citizenship with each other. A citizenship shared across the opposing sides is the problem. The location of the accident, contract performance, or courthouse does not itself establish citizenship.

Citizenship is generally measured when the action is filed. A genuine later relocation ordinarily does not destroy established diversity or repair a case that lacked it initially. For a natural person, state citizenship requires United States citizenship and domicile. Domicile requires physical presence and intent to remain indefinitely; it does not require a promise never to leave. A person retains an established domicile until acquiring another.

A student temporarily living in Massachusetts while intending to return to an established Illinois home ordinarily remains domiciled in Illinois. By contrast, moving to Massachusetts and making it an indefinite home can change domicile immediately. Residence, a driver's license, voting registration, employment, and family ties are evidence; none substitutes for the full inquiry.

Entity and representative citizenship follow different rules. Use the Citizenship rule column to identify which facts must be collected before comparing opposing parties.

Table 3. Citizenship rules and application records
Party or recordCitizenship rule or factsCitizenship to compare
Natural personUnited States citizenship plus domicileThe state of domicile
CorporationEvery incorporation jurisdiction plus principal place of businessAll applicable states and foreign states
LLC or partnershipCitizenship of every member or partner, through every ownership layerEvery citizenship found in that chain
Decedent's legal representative28 U.S.C. § 1332(c)(2)Decedent's citizenship
Minor's or incompetent person's legal representative28 U.S.C. § 1332(c)(2)Represented person's citizenship
Harbor CorporationIncorporated in Delaware; actual nerve center in Illinois; factory in IndianaDelaware and Illinois
River LLCMembers: Harbor Corporation and an individual domiciled in WisconsinDelaware, Illinois, and Wisconsin

A corporation's principal place of business is ordinarily its nerve center: the actual place where high-level officers direct, control, and coordinate corporate activity. A nominal headquarters does not control if those functions occur elsewhere. The state containing the largest factory or most sales is not automatically the nerve center. Unlike a corporation, an LLC does not acquire diversity citizenship merely from its formation state or headquarters.

A Foreign citizenship and party alignment

A United States citizen domiciled abroad is neither a state citizen for § 1332(a)(1) nor a foreign citizen for § 1332(a)(2). Thus, an American domiciled in France cannot establish ordinary diversity against an Illinois citizen simply by describing the parties as international.

Section 1332(a)(2) generally permits a state citizen to sue a foreign citizen, subject to its exception for a foreign citizen lawfully admitted for permanent residence and domiciled in the same state as the opposing state citizen. Permanent residence does not simply transform foreign citizenship into state citizenship. Ordinary alien-versus-alien litigation does not qualify. Section 1332(a)(3) permits foreign citizens as additional parties when citizens of different states are on opposing sides and the required diversity between those state citizens exists. Section 1332(a)(4) separately addresses a foreign state as plaintiff against state citizens.

Actual interests control. Courts may realign parties according to their real interests and disregard merely nominal parties. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1359, an improper or collusive assignment or joinder cannot manufacture jurisdiction. A genuine transfer is not automatically collusive, but a paper assignment designed to create diversity demands scrutiny.

The following matching exercise distinguishes the source of citizenship for commonly confused party types.

Individual:
Physical presence plus intent to remain indefinitely, with United States citizenship.
Corporation:
Incorporation jurisdictions plus the actual executive nerve center.
Limited liability company:
All owners' citizenships, recursively traced.
Estate representative:
The deceased person's citizenship, rather than the administrator's.

B Checkpoint

Using Table 3, an Illinois citizen brings a $100,000 state-law claim solely against River LLC. No other jurisdictional statute applies. Which conclusion is best?

  1. Diversity exists because River LLC's factory is in Indiana.
  2. Diversity exists because only the individual member's Wisconsin citizenship counts.
  3. Diversity fails because River LLC shares Illinois citizenship with the plaintiff.
  4. Diversity fails because every LLC is a citizen of every state.
Answer: C. River LLC takes Harbor Corporation's Illinois citizenship through its membership. B incorrectly excludes the corporate member and its citizenships.

C Additional statutory citizenship rules

These statutory qualifications refine the ordinary citizenship analysis.

Table 4. Citizenship qualifications
ProvisionAdditional ruleApplication
Section 1332(c)(1)A liability insurer in a qualifying direct action also takes the insured's citizenship when the insured is not a defendant.Check the insured's citizenship as well as the insurer's incorporation and principal place of business.
Section 1332(e)States includes the District of Columbia, the Territories, and the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.Do not classify their citizens as foreign citizens merely because they live outside the fifty states.

The direct-action rule concerns an injured claimant proceeding against the tortfeasor's liability insurer without joining the insured. It does not ordinarily cover an insured's own coverage or bad-faith suit. Thus, an Illinois claimant directly suing an Illinois tortfeasor's otherwise diverse insurer cannot overlook the insurer's added Illinois citizenship.

D Adding a nondiverse defendant after removal

Section 1447(e) supplies a specific choice when a plaintiff seeks post-removal joinder of a defendant whose addition would destroy subject matter jurisdiction: deny joinder, or permit joinder and remand. The court cannot permit that jurisdiction-destroying joinder and simply retain the action. For example, adding an Illinois defendant to a removed diversity action brought by an Illinois plaintiff requires this analysis, rather than reliance on the original filing date alone.

1.1.1.4 The amount requirement values the dispute at filing

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a), the matter in controversy must exceed $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs. A demand for exactly $75,000 fails. The relevant figure is the amount genuinely in dispute, rather than the amount the plaintiff will probably win.

A good-faith demand ordinarily controls unless it appears to a legal certainty that the plaintiff cannot recover above the threshold. A binding damages cap or an enforceable contractual ceiling can demonstrate legal impossibility. A weak evidentiary case ordinarily does not. If jurisdiction existed at filing, a later verdict for $20,000 or a later voluntary reduction generally does not eliminate it.

Legally available punitive damages count even when their recovery is uncertain. Attorney fees count when the substantive law or contract permits their recovery as part of the claim. Ordinary litigation costs and interest attributable merely to delayed payment are excluded. Interest that is itself part of the substantive claim, such as a suit to recover an interest obligation, is different from incidental prejudgment interest.

The following table shows when separate sums can be combined. Each row assumes the stated claims are asserted in good faith and the damages are legally available.

Table 5. Aggregation and valuation patterns
Claim patternAggregation treatmentIllustration
One plaintiff against one defendantMay combine unrelated claims$45,000 contract claim plus $35,000 tort claim meets the amount requirement.
Two plaintiffs with separate injuriesCannot combine individual claims merely because they share an eventTwo $40,000 injury claims do not become one $80,000 claim.
One plaintiff against separate defendantsDo not combine separate liabilitiesUnrelated $40,000 claims against two different defendants do not qualify together.
Joint liability for one obligationValue the full jointly enforceable obligationA single $90,000 joint obligation satisfies the amount requirement.
Common, undivided interestValue the shared right as a wholeA genuinely jointly owned right may permit combined valuation.
Alternative remedies for the same lossDo not double-count mutually exclusive recovery$60,000 damages or equivalent rescission does not automatically total $120,000.

For an injunction or declaratory judgment, value the object of the litigation. Courts differ on whether to consider only the plaintiff's value or also the defendant's compliance cost. Apply a valuation rule supplied in the question; do not assume every circuit uses the same perspective. A request to stop a recurring infringement may put more at stake than the value of one past transaction.

Worked case

A Wisconsin citizen sues an Illinois citizen in federal court for a $42,000 unpaid consulting invoice and $36,000 for damage to unrelated equipment. The complaint also requests $4,000 in ordinary court costs. The consultant spends weekends in Illinois but keeps an established Wisconsin home and intends to remain there. At trial, the consultant ultimately recovers only $25,000.

The plaintiff and defendant are completely diverse on the stated domicile facts. One plaintiff may aggregate unrelated claims against one defendant, so the jurisdictional amount is $78,000 before considering costs. Ordinary court costs add nothing, but they are unnecessary. Assuming the claims were asserted in good faith and no legal limit made the requested recovery impossible, the smaller eventual award does not undo jurisdiction. If the equipment claim instead belonged to a second plaintiff with a separate injury, the aggregation analysis would change.

A A small recovery can affect costs

Section 1332(b) permits denying costs to an original federal plaintiff who recovers less than $75,000 and imposing costs on that plaintiff. This is discretionary, not jurisdictional dismissal. Compute the recovery without interest, costs, or deductions for the defendant's setoff or counterclaim. The provision says less than $75,000, rather than $75,000 or less.

1.1.1.5 Additional claims need both a factual connection and statutory permission

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1367(a), a district court with original jurisdiction generally may hear additional claims forming part of the same Article III case or controversy. The usual formulation is a common nucleus of operative fact: the claims share the events, conduct, or injuries that make a joint trial natural. Identical parties, a shared legal label, or convenience alone is insufficient.

Start with a genuine original-jurisdiction claim. Supplemental jurisdiction cannot create an anchor by combining claims that independently fail to establish one. A federal employment discrimination claim and a state assault claim arising from the same alleged workplace attack may belong to the same case. An unrelated landlord dispute does not become supplemental merely because the same employee is the plaintiff.

Procedural joinder remains a separate requirement. Rule 18 may permit a party to plead unrelated claims, but § 1367(a) does not provide jurisdiction over an unrelated state claim lacking its own jurisdictional basis.

A The diversity-only restriction

Section 1367(b) applies when original jurisdiction is founded solely on § 1332. It prevents plaintiffs from using specified joinder devices to evade diversity requirements. The following table identifies the restricted alignments; the restriction applies when supplemental jurisdiction would be inconsistent with § 1332.

Table 6. Plaintiff-side restrictions under § 1367(b)
Claim assertedParty-joinder ruleDiversity-only consequence
Claim by a plaintiff against an added partyRule 14: third-party practiceNo supplemental workaround for defective citizenship or amount.
Claim by a plaintiff against an added partyRule 19: required partiesNo supplemental workaround for defective citizenship or amount.
Claim by a plaintiff against an added partyRule 20: permissive joinderNo supplemental workaround for defective citizenship or amount.
Claim by a plaintiff against an added partyRule 24: interventionNo supplemental workaround for defective citizenship or amount.
Claim by a person proposed as a plaintiffRule 19Independent satisfaction is required when § 1332 would otherwise be violated.
Claim by a person seeking to intervene as a plaintiffRule 24Independent satisfaction is required when § 1332 would otherwise be violated.

Suppose an Illinois plaintiff sues a Wisconsin defendant for $120,000. The defendant properly impleads an Illinois subcontractor for indemnity arising from the same occurrence. The defendant's indemnity claim may qualify under § 1367(a), despite the third-party defendant's Illinois citizenship. But an additional negligence claim by the original plaintiff against that Illinois third-party defendant is barred by § 1367(b). The statute distinguishes who asserts the claim and how the opposing party entered.

A Rule 20 coplaintiff presents a different pattern. When complete diversity exists and at least one plaintiff has a qualifying amount, another properly joined plaintiff's related claim may use supplemental jurisdiction despite falling below the amount threshold. Rule 20 coplaintiffs are not included in the plaintiff-entry prohibition that names Rules 19 and 24. This does not permit a nondiverse plaintiff: an absence of complete diversity defeats the necessary diversity foundation.

Read the statutory trigger. The restrictions in § 1367(b) govern actions founded solely on diversity. An action with a genuine federal question anchor follows § 1367(a) without that diversity-only restriction, although relatedness and other jurisdictional limits still matter.

B Defensive claims and discretion

A compulsory counterclaim under Rule 13(a) commonly shares the required factual nucleus. A proper crossclaim under Rule 13(g) and a proper derivative-liability impleader claim under Rule 14 also commonly qualify. A counterclaim classified as permissive under Rule 13(b) is not automatically supplemental or automatically excluded: examine its factual relationship. If it falls outside § 1367(a), it needs an independent jurisdictional basis.

Statutory power does not always require retention. Under § 1367(c), the court may decline supplemental jurisdiction if the claim raises a novel or complex state-law issue, substantially predominates over the original claims, remains after all original-jurisdiction claims have been dismissed, or presents exceptional circumstances with other compelling reasons for declining. Economy, convenience, fairness, and comity guide the decision. Early dismissal of the federal claims commonly favors leaving state issues to state court; a case already tried may support a different result.

Dismissal of a federal claim on its merits therefore differs from discovering that a purported federal claim never supplied a genuine jurisdictional anchor. Under § 1367(d), the limitations period for a covered supplemental claim is generally suspended while the claim is pending and for 30 days after dismissal, unless state law affords longer protection. The rule stops the clock rather than merely providing a flat 30-day total filing window.

Fig 1 separates the mandatory statutory restrictions from the court's later discretionary choice.

Fig 1. Supplemental jurisdiction decision
Key point: Relatedness establishes the starting grant, but diversity-only restrictions can still prohibit the additional claim.
flowchart TD
A["Original jurisdiction anchor?"] -->|No| B["Independent jurisdiction needed"]
A -->|Yes| C["Common factual nucleus?"]
C -->|No| B
C -->|Yes| D["Solely diversity anchor?"]
D -->|No| G["Consider discretionary refusal"]
D -->|Yes| E["Section 1367(b) bars claim?"]
E -->|Yes| B
E -->|No| G

C Tolling can reach a companion claim

Section 1367(d) also covers another claim in the same action voluntarily dismissed at the same time as, or after, dismissal of the supplemental claim. The sequence matters: the statute does not extend this companion-claim protection to a claim voluntarily dismissed earlier. When the provision applies, the companion claim receives the statutory suspension during its pendency and for 30 days after dismissal, unless state law supplies longer protection.

1.1.1.6 Special grants and separate limits require their own analysis

Ordinary § 1332(a) rules do not govern every federal jurisdiction statute. A question describing a class action or a stakeholder facing competing demands may invoke a different grant. The following table identifies the threshold differences without replacing the separate analysis of class certification or interpleader procedure.

Table 7. Special diversity grants
Jurisdictional routeCitizenship requirementAmount and additional conditions
Ordinary diversity: 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a)Complete diversityMore than $75,000, excluding interest and costs.
Qualifying CAFA class action: 28 U.S.C. § 1332(d)Minimal diversity: a class member differs from a defendantGenerally at least 100 proposed members and aggregate amount above $5 million; exceptions apply.
Statutory interpleader: 28 U.S.C. § 1335Minimal diversity among adverse claimantsAt least $500 and required deposit or appropriate bond.
Rule interpleader: Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 22Apply the independently invoked jurisdictional statuteThe procedural rule supplies no separate jurisdictional grant.

The Class Action Fairness Act, CAFA, includes important exclusions and local-dispute exceptions. Minimal diversity alone is therefore insufficient. Statutory interpleader instead asks whether adverse claimants are minimally diverse from each other; the stakeholder's citizenship need not establish ordinary complete diversity. These special statutes explain why a fact pattern may legitimately use a different amount or citizenship threshold.

A Domestic relations, probate, standing, and immunity

The traditional domestic-relations exception to diversity jurisdiction excludes issuance of divorce, alimony, and child-custody decrees. It does not categorically exclude an otherwise qualifying damages action merely because former spouses are involved. The probate exception reserves probate or annulment of a will, administration of an estate, and disposition of property in a state probate court's custody. A qualifying personal claim against an executor may proceed if it does not require those reserved functions or control over that property.

Article III standing requires a concrete and particularized actual or imminent injury, fairly traceable to the challenged conduct, and likely redressable by the requested relief. A federal legal issue does not dispense with those requirements. Sovereign immunity is also distinct: § 1331 alone does not waive federal sovereign immunity, and suits against states may encounter constitutional immunity. Analyze the relevant waiver, abrogation, or permitted officer-suit doctrine separately when the facts raise it.

Repairing allegations and party defects

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8(a)(1) requires a short and plain statement of jurisdictional grounds unless the court already has jurisdiction and no new support is needed. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1653, an allegation stating only residence may be amended to allege actual diverse citizenship if that citizenship existed. The statute does not turn an Illinois domiciliary into a Wisconsin domiciliary.

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 21 can permit dismissal of a dispensable nondiverse party, including in appropriate circumstances to preserve diversity jurisdiction. This is not an entitlement to erase every inconvenient party. If a nondiverse party is required and cannot feasibly be joined, Rule 19 governs whether the action can proceed without that party or must be dismissed.

Answer the following questions from memory before moving to the integrated practice.

B Recall check

What are the two components of an individual's domicile?
Physical presence and intent to remain indefinitely.
Which corporate locations determine diversity citizenship?
Every jurisdiction of incorporation and the principal place of business, ordinarily the actual nerve center.
When can one plaintiff combine unrelated claims for the diversity amount?
When the claims are against one defendant.
What triggers the restrictions in § 1367(b)?
An action with original jurisdiction founded solely on diversity, plus one of the specified plaintiff-side claim alignments inconsistent with § 1332.
How does § 1367(d) generally protect a covered claim after dismissal?
It suspends the limitations clock during federal pendency and for 30 days afterward, unless state law gives longer protection.
COMMON MISTAKE

Common mistakes

These errors arise from substituting a nearby concept for the rule that actually governs the claim.

Table 8. Confusions that change the outcome
Tempting conclusionWhy it attracts attentionFact that settles the issue
Federal defense means federal jurisdictionThe litigation may turn on federal law.The federal issue appears only as a defense to the plaintiff's state claim.
Headquarters determine every business entity's citizenshipCorporate and LLC terminology look similar.The defendant is an LLC, requiring membership tracing.
Related claims always qualify as supplementalShared events satisfy § 1367(a).A diversity-only plaintiff claim falls within § 1367(b).
The eventual award proves the amount was insufficientThe plaintiff recovered less than the statutory threshold.The good-faith demand was legally possible when filed.
Joinder permission supplies jurisdictionA procedural rule authorizes pleading the claim.Rule 82 preserves the separate statutory jurisdiction requirement.
ALGO

Approach

For a multi-party fact pattern, work through the action claim by claim in this order.

Find the original grant. Identify a qualifying plaintiff's federal claim, a diversity claim, or a specifically applicable alternative statute.
Resolve citizenship and value. For ordinary diversity, trace every party's citizenship at filing and apply the amount and aggregation rules.
Separate additional claims. Identify who asserts each claim, against whom, and through which joinder device the relevant party entered.
Apply supplemental restrictions. Test the common factual nucleus, then § 1367(b) if the original basis is solely diversity.
Check remaining barriers. Address discretionary refusal, special statutory exceptions, standing, immunity, or reserved domestic and probate functions when raised.
State the procedural result. Distinguish adjudication, discretionary dismissal of supplemental claims, jurisdictional dismissal, and remand of a removed case.
QUIZ

Self-check quiz

Question 1

An Illinois citizen sues a corporation for $200,000 on a state contract. The corporation is incorporated in Delaware, has its actual executive nerve center in Illinois, and conducts most manufacturing in Texas. No other jurisdictional grant applies. What is the best result?

  1. Jurisdiction exists because the corporation is incorporated outside Illinois.
  2. Jurisdiction exists because the corporation conducts most manufacturing in Texas.
  3. Jurisdiction exists because the amount exceeds $75,000.
  4. Jurisdiction is absent because the corporation and plaintiff share Illinois citizenship.

Question 2

An Illinois plaintiff asserts a qualifying federal civil-rights claim against an Illinois defendant and a $20,000 state battery claim against the same defendant arising from the same arrest. The federal claim remains pending. Which statement is best?

  1. The battery claim needs complete diversity because it is based on state law.
  2. The battery claim can fall within supplemental jurisdiction despite shared citizenship and its amount.
  3. The battery claim qualifies only if it independently exceeds $75,000.
  4. The federal claim loses jurisdiction because the complaint includes a state claim.

Question 3

A California plaintiff sues a Nevada defendant for $150,000 arising from a construction accident. The defendant properly impleads a California subcontractor for related indemnity. The plaintiff then asserts an $80,000 state negligence claim against the subcontractor. What is the best analysis of the plaintiff's added claim?

  1. Section 1367(b) bars supplemental jurisdiction over that claim in this diversity-only action.
  2. The common factual nucleus conclusively establishes supplemental jurisdiction.
  3. The subcontractor's proper impleader makes the plaintiff's citizenship irrelevant.
  4. The added claim qualifies because its amount independently exceeds $75,000.

Question 4

Two completely diverse plaintiffs properly join related claims against one defendant. The first has a good-faith $110,000 claim and the second has a separate $35,000 claim. Neither shares citizenship with the defendant. Which statement is best?

  1. The claims must be aggregated to create an original-jurisdiction anchor.
  2. The smaller claim necessarily fails because separate plaintiffs can never use supplemental jurisdiction.
  3. The smaller claim may qualify under § 1367 because a Rule 20 coplaintiff's amount defect is not categorically barred.
  4. The larger claim supplies jurisdiction even if the second plaintiff later proves nondiverse at filing.

Question 5

A state contract action is removed to federal court. Before final judgment, the district court determines that there was no federal question, diversity, or other jurisdictional basis. The plaintiff participated in federal discovery without objecting. What should the court do?

  1. Retain the case because the plaintiff forfeited the objection.
  2. Enter judgment for the defendant on the contract merits.
  3. Dismiss the removed action under the ordinary rule for originally filed actions.
  4. Remand the action to state court under § 1447(c).
ANSWERS

Answer key

Question 1 - Answer: D. The corporation is a citizen of Delaware and Illinois, defeating complete diversity with the Illinois plaintiff. A ignores its additional citizenship; B substitutes manufacturing activity for the nerve center; C satisfies only the amount requirement.

Question 2 - Answer: B. The same arrest supplies a common factual nucleus under § 1367(a), and the action has a federal question anchor rather than a solely diversity anchor. A incorrectly requires an independent diversity basis; C imports the diversity amount into a supplemental claim; D treats a permissible additional claim as destroying federal jurisdiction.

Question 3 - Answer: A. In a solely diversity action, § 1367(b) prevents the original plaintiff from asserting this nondiverse claim against a party added under Rule 14. B overlooks the statutory restriction after relatedness; C confuses the defendant's impleader claim with the plaintiff's direct claim; D satisfies the amount but leaves citizenship defective.

Question 4 - Answer: C. A qualifying original claim and complete diversity can support supplemental jurisdiction over a properly joined Rule 20 coplaintiff's related claim below the amount threshold. A improperly aggregates separate interests and overlooks the existing anchor; B overstates the plaintiff restrictions; D wrongly treats supplemental jurisdiction as curing incomplete diversity.

Question 5 - Answer: D. Section 1447(c) requires remand when subject matter jurisdiction is found absent in a removed action before final judgment. A incorrectly treats participation as consent to subject matter jurisdiction; B reaches merits without authority; C overlooks the removed action's required return to state court.

RAPID

Rapid review

  • Federal defense only → ordinarily no § 1331 jurisdiction.
  • Federal question claim → no general minimum dollar amount.
  • Ordinary diversity → compare every plaintiff against every defendant.
  • Individual citizenship → United States citizenship plus domicile.
  • Corporation → incorporation jurisdictions plus actual nerve center.
  • LLC → trace every member through every ownership layer.
  • Exactly $75,000 → insufficient for ordinary diversity.
  • Related additional claim → test § 1367(a), then any § 1367(b) restriction.
  • Federal claims dismissed on merits → retention of state claims may remain discretionary.
  • Removed action lacks jurisdiction → remand rather than decide the merits.
  • Qualifying direct action against liability insurer → add the absent insured's citizenship.
  • District of Columbia, Territories, and Puerto Rico → included within States under § 1332(e).
  • Recovery below $75,000 → possible cost consequences despite valid original jurisdiction.
  • Nonjurisdictional removal defect → move to remand within 30 days after the removal notice is filed.
  • Post-removal joinder destroys jurisdiction → deny joinder or permit it and remand.
  • Companion claim voluntarily dismissed before the supplemental claim → no companion-claim tolling under § 1367(d).

References

  • United States Constitution. Article III, Section 2. United States.
  • United States Code. Title 28, §§ 1331, 1332, 1335, 1338, 1359, 1367, 1447, 1653, and 2201. United States House of Representatives, Office of the Law Revision Counsel, 2026.
  • Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Rules 8, 12, 13, 14, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 24, and 82. United States Courts.
  • Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974. Section 502(a), codified at 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a). United States Congress, 1974.
  • MBE Subject Matter Outline. National Conference of Bar Examiners.
End of your free lesson

Keep going with the full Illinois Bar Exam Prep Course

You just studied the way members do, in the same lesson interface. Full access unlocks every lesson, the question bank and flashcards for a full year.

Up next with full access1.1.2 - Personal Jurisdiction and Service

One payment per program