Skip to content
Free previewYou are reading 1 of 147 lessons, in the same interface members use. Everything else unlocks with full access.Get full access · $150

1.1.1 - Federal Question and Diversity Jurisdiction

What you'll learn

  • Determine whether a claim arises under federal law.
  • Assign citizenship to individuals, corporations, and unincorporated entities.
  • Apply complete diversity and the amount-in-controversy requirement.
  • Distinguish permitted aggregation from claims requiring a separate jurisdictional basis.
  • Recognize exceptions that defeat an otherwise plausible federal forum.

Estimated reading time: 23 minutes.

WHY

Why it matters

A federal district court needs authority over the category of dispute before it can adjudicate the merits. MBE questions often give a strong claim and an apparently convenient federal forum, then make jurisdiction turn on one party's domicile, the source of the plaintiff's right, or whether two demands may be added together.

KEY TERMS

Key terms

Subject-matter jurisdiction
A court's authority to hear a category of cases.
Original jurisdiction
Authority to hear an action initially, rather than review another court's judgment.
Well-pleaded complaint
The plaintiff's properly stated claim, including the elements needed for relief.
Domicile
A person's established home, retained until physical presence and the necessary intent establish another.
Complete diversity
No plaintiff shares citizenship with any defendant.
Amount in controversy
The monetary value genuinely at stake when the action begins.
Aggregation
Adding claims to determine whether the jurisdictional amount is satisfied.
Nerve center
The place where corporate officers actually direct, control, and coordinate corporate activities.
CORE

Core content

1.1.1.1 Federal authority requires a jurisdictional grant

Article III, Section 2 of the U.S. Constitution sets the outer boundaries of federal judicial power. Congress determines how much of that authority federal district courts receive. A dispute can fall within Article III's broad language yet fail the narrower statutory requirements for an ordinary district-court action.

The two principal original-jurisdiction grants here are 28 U.S.C. § 1331 for federal questions and 28 U.S.C. § 1332 for diversity. Either can independently support jurisdiction. A state-law contract claim can therefore belong in federal court through diversity, and a federal civil-rights claim can belong there even when all parties live in the same state.

The party invoking federal jurisdiction bears the burden of establishing the jurisdictional facts. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8(a)(1) generally requires the pleading to state the grounds for jurisdiction. If citizenship is contested, merely alleging that a person resides somewhere may be inadequate because residence and citizenship differ.

Authority cannot arise from agreement.

Parties cannot create subject-matter jurisdiction through consent, waiver, silence, or a forum-selection clause. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(h)(3), the court must dismiss an action originally filed in federal court whenever it determines that subject-matter jurisdiction is lacking. A removed action ordinarily is remanded instead.

Keep the forum questions separate. Table 1 shows why facts establishing one requirement do not automatically establish another.

Table 1. Separate questions about a federal forum
QuestionControlling concernIllustrative fact
Subject-matter jurisdictionAuthority over the dispute's categoryA qualifying federal claim or diverse parties with sufficient stakes
Personal jurisdictionAuthority over the defendantConsent, domicile, or constitutionally sufficient forum contacts
VenueProper geographic federal districtDefendant residence or substantial events
Governing lawRules determining the meritsState substantive law in an ordinary diversity contract action

Federal jurisdiction does not always mean exclusive federal jurisdiction. State courts generally may hear federal claims unless Congress makes federal jurisdiction exclusive or another recognized exception applies. Conversely, diversity supplies a federal forum without converting a state-created right into federal substantive law. See also: Personal Jurisdiction and Consent; Venue and Forum Transfers; Erie and Federal Common Law.

A Jurisdictional dismissal leaves the merits unresolved

A dismissal for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction ordinarily is without prejudice. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(b) expressly excludes jurisdictional dismissals from its ordinary rule that an involuntary dismissal operates as an adjudication on the merits. The plaintiff may pursue the claim in a court with jurisdiction, subject to applicable limitations periods and other procedural requirements. An answer stating that a jurisdictional dismissal establishes that the defendant did not breach the contract confuses authority to decide with the substantive result. The jurisdictional determination itself can have preclusive consequences even though the underlying claim remains undecided.

1.1.1.2 Federal questions must belong to the plaintiff's claim

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1331, federal district courts have original jurisdiction over civil actions arising under the Constitution, federal statutes, or treaties. Section 1331 has no general minimum monetary amount. The usual qualifying action asserts a cause of action created by federal law, such as an authorized federal employment-discrimination claim.

The well-pleaded complaint rule asks whether federal law appears as part of the plaintiff's own properly pleaded claim. An anticipated federal defense does not supply jurisdiction. Neither does a federal counterclaim, even a compulsory counterclaim, under the ordinary § 1331 analysis. A plaintiff cannot change that result by discussing the defense extensively in the complaint.

Suppose a passenger sues a railroad for breach of a state-law transportation contract. The railroad argues that federal legislation forbids performance. Contract formation, breach, and damages remain the plaintiff's grounds for relief; the federal statute appears through the defense. That arrangement does not create § 1331 jurisdiction, even if the statutory defense will decide the lawsuit.

Table 2 distinguishes the location of a federal issue from its practical importance.

Table 2. Sources of a federal issue
Federal issue appears inOrdinary § 1331 resultReason
Plaintiff's federal cause of actionQualifiesFederal law creates the asserted right to relief
Defendant's federal defenseDoes not qualifyThe plaintiff's claim does not arise under that defense
Defendant's federal counterclaimDoes not qualifyA counterclaim does not supply the complaint's federal foundation
Necessary federal element within a state claimSometimes qualifiesThe embedded-issue requirements must all be satisfied
Federal language incidental to state allegationsDoes not qualify by itselfA reference to federal law is not necessarily an element of relief

A Embedded federal issues

A narrow category of state-created claims arises under federal law because deciding the state claim requires deciding a federal issue. Under the framework associated with Grable and Gunn, the federal issue must be necessarily raised, actually disputed, substantial to the federal system as a whole, and capable of resolution in federal court without upsetting the congressionally approved division of federal and state judicial work.

Necessity concerns what the plaintiff must prove. If an independent state-law theory supports relief without deciding federal law, the federal issue may not be necessary. Substantiality concerns the federal system, rather than the dollar value or emotional importance of the lawsuit. A fact-bound malpractice dispute about an earlier patent case can require federal patent analysis yet lack the required broader federal significance.

The embedded-issue pathway has cumulative requirements, as Fig 1 shows.

Fig 1. Embedded federal issues
Key point: Failure at any branch prevents this narrow basis for federal-question jurisdiction.
flowchart TD
A[State law cause] --> B{Federal issue necessary?}
B -->|No| F[No embedded jurisdiction]
B -->|Yes| C{Actually disputed?}
C -->|No| F
C -->|Yes| D{Federally substantial?}
D -->|No| F
D -->|Yes| E{Judicial balance preserved?}
E -->|No| F
E -->|Yes| G[Embedded jurisdiction available]

B Preemption and declaratory relief

Ordinary preemption means federal law displaces a conflicting state rule. Raised defensively, it does not satisfy the well-pleaded complaint rule. Complete preemption is exceptional: Congress has so completely displaced a particular category of state-law claims that the claim is treated as federal from its inception. Do not infer complete preemption merely because federal regulation is extensive.

The Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. § 2201, creates a remedy rather than an independent jurisdictional grant. For federal-question analysis, reconstruct the underlying coercive action: who would sue whom for damages or an injunction without the declaratory procedure? A prospective defendant seeking a declaration that its federal defense is valid cannot manufacture jurisdiction when the underlying coercive claim arises only under state law.

Worked case

A Georgia author sues a Georgia publisher in federal court for $180,000 under a state-law royalty contract. The publisher says federal copyright law permits its conduct. The complaint describes that expected defense and asks the court to reject it. The author also mentions that the publisher previously threatened a federal counterclaim.

The asserted right is payment under a contract. The federal defense and threatened counterclaim do not transform that right into a federal cause of action, and no necessary federal element of the contract claim is identified. Shared Georgia citizenship also prevents diversity. The size of the royalty demand cannot cure either missing basis. On these facts, the district court lacks subject-matter jurisdiction.

C Checkpoint

Using Table 2, which placement of a federal issue ordinarily supports § 1331 jurisdiction without further embedded-issue analysis?

  1. An anticipated federal immunity defense to a state tort claim
  2. A federal cause of action asserted in the plaintiff's complaint
  3. A compulsory federal counterclaim to a state contract claim
  4. A complaint's prediction that federal preemption will be raised
Answer: B. The federal cause of action supplies the plaintiff's right to relief. C is tempting because a compulsory counterclaim is closely connected to the dispute, but it remains a counterclaim rather than the complaint's jurisdictional foundation.

D A weak federal claim can still belong in federal court

Separate an unsuccessful federal claim from an inadequate jurisdictional foundation. If the complaint asserts a colorable federal cause of action, the plaintiff's eventual failure to prove a required element ordinarily calls for a merits disposition. The court does not lose jurisdiction merely because the defendant has the better interpretation of the federal statute. A different result follows when the purported federal claim is wholly insubstantial and frivolous or is asserted solely to obtain federal jurisdiction.

Do not assume every statutory prerequisite is jurisdictional. A requirement governing entitlement to relief ordinarily remains a merits requirement unless Congress clearly makes it jurisdictional. Thus, a genuinely disputed coverage element of a federal claim does not automatically require dismissal under Rule 12(b)(1).

E Recognize established complete-preemption provisions

Two standard examples are § 301 of the Labor Management Relations Act, 29 U.S.C. § 185, and § 502(a) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a). A state-law label cannot prevent federal treatment when the claim falls within the relevant provision's complete-preemption scope. The statute's general presence in the dispute is insufficient. For example, an employer's reference to an employee benefit plan does not establish that every related state claim falls within ERISA's civil-enforcement provision. Distinguish displacement of a state rule as a defense from displacement of the asserted cause of action itself.

F Identify which federal claims state courts cannot hear

Table 3 supplies concrete applications of the distinction between concurrent and exclusive jurisdiction.

Table 3. Exclusive jurisdiction under § 1338(a)
Claim arising under federal lawState-court authorityDistinction to preserve
PatentExcludedA patent-related state claim does not necessarily arise under patent law.
Plant variety protectionExcludedThe federal cause of action controls.
CopyrightExcludedA royalty contract may remain a state-law claim.
TrademarkNot categorically excluded by § 1338(a)Federal subject matter does not itself establish exclusivity.

Exclusivity follows the character of the claim, rather than the mere appearance of a patent or copyrighted work in the facts. A suit seeking payment under a publishing contract does not become exclusively federal simply because the contract concerns copyrighted material. Likewise, the backward-looking patent-malpractice dispute already discussed does not become a federal patent action merely because patent doctrine must be examined.

1.1.1.3 Citizenship follows legal identity and domicile

For a natural person, state citizenship requires U.S. citizenship plus domicile in a state. Residence supplies evidence but is not the legal test. A person can maintain several residences while having only one domicile at a time.

Changing domicile requires both physical presence in the new place and intent to remain indefinitely. Indefinitely does not mean forever; it means the person has no definite present plan to leave for another home. A former domicile persists until a new one is established. Moving plans without arrival do not suffice, and temporary presence without the required intent does not suffice.

Consider a student who leaves Florida for a three-year program in New York while intending to return to Florida afterward. The student ordinarily retains Florida domicile. If the student instead arrives in New York, abandons the Florida home, and intends to stay without a fixed departure plan, New York can become the domicile immediately; no minimum period of residence is required.

Citizens abroad.

A U.S. citizen domiciled in France is not a citizen of any U.S. state for § 1332(a), and U.S. nationality prevents treating that person as an alien. This party cannot invoke ordinary diversity merely because the opposing party is a citizen of a U.S. state.

A Business entities and representative parties

A corporation has citizenship in every state or foreign state where it is incorporated and in the state or foreign state of its principal place of business. Under Hertz's nerve-center test, the principal place of business is the actual location of high-level direction, control, and coordination. It ordinarily is the genuine headquarters, rather than the state with the most factories, employees, customers, or sales. A nominal office used only for board meetings does not displace the actual nerve center.

Unincorporated entities use a different rule. An LLC takes every member's citizenship; a partnership takes every partner's citizenship, including limited partners. Trace ownership through each additional unincorporated entity until the relevant individuals and corporations are identified. The entity's formation state, headquarters, and label do not substitute for this analysis.

Table 4 assigns citizenship by party type. Notice that changing an enterprise's legal form can change its jurisdictional citizenship even when its operations stay the same.

Table 4. Citizenship by party type
PartyCitizenship assignedMisleading fact
Individual U.S. citizenState of domicileCurrent mailing address
CorporationEvery incorporation jurisdiction and principal-place-of-business jurisdictionLargest sales market
LLCEvery member's citizenshipState of organization
PartnershipEvery partner's citizenshipPrincipal office
Estate's legal representativeDecedent's citizenshipExecutor's personal domicile
Infant's or incompetent person's legal representativeRepresented person's citizenshipGuardian's personal domicile
State itselfNot a citizen under the diversity statuteIts location within the United States
Ordinary municipalityState in which it is locatedIts governmental character alone

The representative-party rules appear in 28 U.S.C. § 1332(c)(2). A state agency that functions as an arm of the state is different from an ordinary municipality; the arm-of-state question can therefore determine whether the entity counts as a diversity citizen. Do not confuse that classification with a separate sovereign-immunity analysis.

Special citizenship rules also exist for certain insurer direct actions. Under § 1332(c)(1), when a qualifying direct action is brought against a liability insurer without joining the insured as a defendant, the insurer additionally receives the insured's citizenship. This rule does not apply to every coverage dispute between an insured and its own insurer.

Match the legal identity to the jurisdictional attribute it requires.

Individual:
Established home plus the required national status.
Corporation:
Chartering jurisdictions and genuine executive command location.
Limited liability company:
Ownership traced through every constituent.
Estate representative:
Decedent's state affiliation.

B Checkpoint

An LLC was organized in Delaware and manages its business from Texas. Its two members are a Florida domiciliary and a corporation incorporated in Nevada with its nerve center in Oregon. What is the LLC's citizenship?

  1. Delaware only
  2. Delaware and Texas
  3. Florida and Texas
  4. Florida, Nevada, and Oregon
Answer: D. Trace through both members, including both citizenships of the corporate member. B applies corporate-style thinking to an LLC and overlooks the membership rule.

1.1.1.4 Every opposing party must fit a permitted alignment

Ordinary diversity under 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a) combines a citizenship requirement with a monetary requirement. For a suit between citizens of different states, complete diversity means every plaintiff must be diverse from every defendant. Plaintiffs may share citizenship with one another, and defendants may share citizenship with one another, provided no citizenship crosses the opposing sides.

Compare all citizenships, not just each party's most obvious affiliation. If a California plaintiff sues a corporation incorporated in Delaware with its nerve center in California, the corporation's Delaware citizenship does not erase its California citizenship. The overlap defeats complete diversity.

Citizenship ordinarily is measured when the complaint is filed. A genuine move after filing does not destroy jurisdiction that properly existed then. A move before filing counts if it actually establishes a new domicile; a strategic reason for a real move does not alone invalidate it. An assertion of intent unsupported by physical presence cannot create the change.

Table 5 separates permitted international alignments from arrangements that do not fit ordinary diversity. Assume the amount requirement is met.

Table 5. Ordinary diversity alignments
Plaintiff sideDefendant sideCitizenship result
Georgia citizenFlorida citizenQualifies under § 1332(a)(1)
Georgia citizenCanadian citizen domiciled in CanadaQualifies under § 1332(a)(2)
Georgia citizenCanadian permanent resident domiciled in GeorgiaExcluded by § 1332(a)(2)
Canadian citizenFrench citizenNo ordinary diversity
Georgia citizen and Canadian citizenFlorida citizen and French citizenMay qualify under § 1332(a)(3)
Georgia citizenU.S. citizen domiciled in FranceNo ordinary diversity
Georgia citizen and Florida citizenFlorida citizenComplete diversity absent

Section 1332(a)(3) permits citizens of different U.S. states on opposite sides with foreign citizens as additional parties. Thus, aliens appearing on both sides do not invariably defeat jurisdiction: the qualifying diverse U.S.-citizen controversy matters. By contrast, adding an alien to only one side of an otherwise alien-versus-alien dispute does not supply the missing opposing state citizens.

The permanent-resident exception is specific. Section 1332(a)(2) excludes a suit between a state citizen and an opposing foreign citizen who is lawfully admitted for permanent residence and domiciled in that same state. Permanent residence does not generally transform a foreign national into a U.S. state citizen. Also, § 1332(e) includes the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, and the territories within the statute's use of states.

Worked case

An Illinois citizen sues a delivery LLC for $240,000 after a collision. The LLC was organized in Delaware, keeps its headquarters in Indiana, and has two members: an Ohio citizen and a corporation incorporated in Michigan with its actual headquarters in Illinois. The collision occurred in Kentucky, where the driver was temporarily working.

The LLC's citizenship follows its members. It is an Ohio, Michigan, and Illinois citizen. The plaintiff is also an Illinois citizen, so complete diversity is absent. Delaware organization, Indiana offices, the Kentucky collision, and the large demand cannot remove the Illinois overlap. A state-law negligence claim supplies no separate federal-question basis merely because it involves interstate transportation.

A Finish the alienage analysis before counting dollars

Section 1332(a)(4) adds a specific alignment: a foreign state, as defined in 28 U.S.C. § 1603(a), may sue citizens of a U.S. state or different U.S. states when the ordinary amount requirement is met. This provision concerns a foreign state as plaintiff. A foreign state as defendant raises a different statutory framework and should not be treated as an ordinary foreign individual.

Also test an asymmetric arrangement carefully. A Canadian plaintiff suing a New York defendant and a French defendant does not qualify under § 1332(a)(2): aliens remain on opposing sides. Section 1332(a)(3) does not solve the problem because there are no opposing diverse U.S. state citizens. Contrast the existing example with state citizens on both opposing sides and aliens added to those sides.

B Use substantive interests rather than caption labels

A complaint's party labels do not settle diversity. Table 6 distinguishes three ways a misleading party arrangement can affect the analysis.

Table 6. Party identity and alignment
Party problemGoverning treatmentJurisdictional consequence
Nominal party without a real stakeDisregard its citizenshipA name in the caption does not necessarily defeat diversity.
Party placed opposite its actual litigation interestRealign according to the principal disputeRecalculate diversity using the proper sides.
Dispensable nondiverse partyRule 21 permits dismissal on appropriate termsThe court may preserve jurisdiction by dropping that party.
Indispensable nondiverse partyApply Rule 19's required-party analysisThe court cannot preserve the action simply by omitting that party.

Suppose an insurance stakeholder has no remaining interest in which claimant receives a fund. Do not automatically treat its caption position as establishing an adverse citizenship relationship. Ask who actually seeks relief against whom. Separately, dropping a nondiverse party is a procedural cure with limits, rather than a general exception to complete diversity. The court must determine whether the action can properly proceed without that party; convenience alone does not make an indispensable party dispensable.

1.1.1.5 The controversy must exceed $75,000 under permitted counting rules

Section 1332(a) requires an amount exceeding $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs. Exactly $75,000 is insufficient. A good-faith demand ordinarily controls unless it is legally certain that the plaintiff cannot recover enough. The inquiry concerns legally available relief at filing, not the judge's prediction of the most likely verdict.

A plaintiff demanding $90,000 on a claim subject to an applicable $50,000 substantive damages cap cannot satisfy the amount requirement with that claim alone. Conversely, a plausible $100,000 claim does not fail merely because liability is disputed or a jury might award $40,000. A later smaller award generally does not retroactively erase jurisdiction.

Distinguish the amount at stake from accounting additions. Table 7 identifies which requested amounts can contribute.

Table 7. Valuing requested relief
Requested componentTreatmentControlling qualification
Compensatory damagesCountMust be legally available and asserted in good faith
Punitive damagesMay countGoverning substantive law must permit them
Attorney feesMay countA statute or contract must authorize recovery
Ordinary litigation costsExcludeFiling and similar costs do not supply the threshold
Interest merely for delayed paymentExcludeDistinguish interest constituting the underlying substantive claim
Injunction or other equitable reliefValue the object of litigationUse monetary stakes and any valuation perspective specified in the question
Alternative theories for one injuryCount recovery onceMultiple labels do not multiply the same compensation

For equitable relief, courts differ about whether valuation is confined to the plaintiff's benefit or may consider the defendant's compliance cost. Use facts and any governing valuation rule supplied by the question. If a plaintiff seeks to prevent destruction of an easement worth $100,000 to that plaintiff, the plaintiff's own stake establishes sufficient value without resolving that variation.

A Which claims may be added?

One plaintiff may add all claims against one defendant, even when the claims involve unrelated transactions. A $48,000 loan claim plus a $31,000 property-damage claim against the same defendant totals $79,000. Procedural permission to join those claims does not require a common transaction.

Separate plaintiffs ordinarily cannot add their separate demands to reach the threshold. Two passengers each claiming $45,000 against a driver have separate injuries, even though the same collision caused them. A common factual source is different from a common and undivided legal interest.

Table 8 applies aggregation to particular party arrangements.

Table 8. Aggregation outcomes
ArrangementAmounts assertedAmount requirement
One plaintiff, one defendant, independent claims$48,000 plus $31,000Satisfied by $79,000 total
Two plaintiffs, separate personal injuries$45,000 eachNeither independently satisfies it
One plaintiff, separate liability of two defendants$40,000 against eachNot satisfied through addition
One plaintiff, defendants jointly liable for one obligation$90,000 total obligationSatisfied without dividing the obligation
Multiple plaintiffs, genuinely common and undivided right$100,000 collective interestCollective value may count
One injury, contract and tort alternativesSame $50,000 loss under each theoryOnly $50,000 at stake

A common and undivided interest exists when the plaintiffs enforce a genuinely collective right, such as joint ownership of a single indivisible fund. Separate wage claims, individual contracts, or personal injuries do not become collective rights because they are litigated together.

Against multiple defendants, distinguish separate obligations from joint liability. If two defendants are each separately liable for different $40,000 debts, the plaintiff cannot combine the debts merely by joining both defendants. If both are jointly liable for a single $90,000 obligation, the controversy concerns that whole obligation; it is not divided into $45,000 shares for the threshold.

B Distinguish later events from an insufficient original demand

A plaintiff who validly places $100,000 in controversy does not ordinarily destroy jurisdiction by later amending the demand to $60,000. That amendment is a subsequent event. By contrast, proof that a binding substantive rule limited recovery to $60,000 from the outset can show that the original demand never satisfied the legal-certainty standard. Read the chronology: a reduced demand after filing differs from a preexisting legal ceiling discovered later.

A defendant's counterclaim does not repair the plaintiff's insufficient demand. If the plaintiff seeks $50,000 and the defendant counterclaims for $40,000, do not total the opposing demands as $90,000 for the plaintiff's original diversity claim. This remains true even when the counterclaim arises from the same transaction.

C A small recovery can affect costs without undoing jurisdiction

Section 1332(b) permits a particular consequence when a plaintiff who originally filed in federal court ultimately recovers less than $75,000, computed without interest and costs and without counting a setoff or counterclaim to which the defendant is entitled. The court may deny the plaintiff costs and may impose costs on the plaintiff. This is discretionary and does not mean that a small verdict automatically proves the original demand was defective. Notice the numerical distinction: § 1332(a) requires a controversy exceeding $75,000, while this cost provision refers to recovery below $75,000.

A claim failing an independent jurisdictional test is not automatically excluded from every federal action. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1367, supplemental jurisdiction may reach related claims forming part of the same constitutional case or controversy, subject to statutory restrictions and discretion.

For example, when complete diversity exists and one plaintiff satisfies the amount requirement, another plaintiff's related claim below the threshold may qualify for supplemental jurisdiction in an appropriate party arrangement. Section 1367(b) imposes particular restrictions when original jurisdiction rests solely on diversity. Supplemental jurisdiction does not generally cure a nondiverse plaintiff-defendant alignment in an ordinary diversity action. See also: Supplemental Jurisdiction and Removal; Party and Claim Joinder.

Separate the questions.

First decide whether a claim independently satisfies § 1331 or § 1332. Then ask whether another claim can enter through § 1367. Permission to join parties or claims under a procedural rule is not itself a grant of subject-matter jurisdiction.

Section 1359 prevents manufacture of jurisdiction through improper or collusive assignment or joinder. Assigning a claim to a diverse collection agent who retains little economic stake can trigger this bar. A genuine change in the real holder of a right differs from a paper transfer arranged to obtain federal jurisdiction while the original holder retains the substance of the claim.

Even sufficient citizenship and monetary stakes do not authorize certain traditional matters. The domestic-relations exception excludes federal issuance of divorce, alimony, and child-custody decrees through diversity jurisdiction. It does not categorically exclude every tort or contract dispute between family members.

The probate exception reserves probate or annulment of a will, administration of an estate, and disposition of property in a state probate court's custody. An ordinary in-personam damages action involving an estate may proceed when it does not require those reserved functions or control of the probate property.

Special statutes change particular requirements. Table 9 identifies departures without replacing the ordinary § 1332(a) analysis.

Table 9. Special jurisdictional routes
RouteDistinct requirementsBoundary
Statutory interpleader, 28 U.S.C. § 1335$500 or more; minimal diversity between adverse claimants; required deposit or bondDo not import ordinary $75,000 and complete-diversity requirements
Rule interpleader, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 22Independent jurisdictional basis requiredThe procedural rule does not itself confer jurisdiction
Qualifying class action, 28 U.S.C. § 1332(d)Generally 100 or more proposed members, aggregate stakes over $5 million, and minimal diversityStatutory exclusions and local-controversy or home-state provisions may prevent a federal forum
Ordinary Rule 23 class action outside § 1332(d)Apply the applicable ordinary jurisdictional rulesThe class-action label alone creates no federal jurisdiction

Related procedural issues remain independent. A diverse defendant sued in its home state may raise a removal restriction even though original diversity jurisdiction exists. Federal law governing removal, rather than the ordinary original-jurisdiction citizenship test, supplies that additional limitation. See also: Supplemental Jurisdiction and Removal.

Retrieve these distinctions without consulting the tables.

For an ordinary Rule 23 class action relying on § 1332(a), complete diversity is determined using the named class representatives and the opposing parties. Unnamed class members' citizenship does not control that inquiry. Thus, a New York representative suing a New Jersey defendant does not lose ordinary complete diversity merely because an unnamed class member is from New Jersey. This rule does not authorize adding all separate class members' claims to manufacture the ordinary amount requirement. Keep it distinct from CAFA, whose special minimal-diversity and aggregate-value provisions require their own analysis.

Suppose a California plaintiff has a good-faith $100,000 negligence claim against a Nevada defendant. A second California plaintiff has a $30,000 claim from the same collision and properly joins under Rule 20. The first claim supplies original diversity jurisdiction; the second may enter under § 1367 because it belongs to the same constitutional case and does not destroy complete diversity. Section 1367(b) does not categorically exclude claims by plaintiffs merely because they joined under Rule 20. Its restriction on claims by plaintiffs against persons made parties under Rule 20 is different.

Change one fact: if the second plaintiff is a Nevada citizen, the ordinary complete-diversity requirement fails. Supplemental jurisdiction cannot be used simply to overlook that opposing citizenship overlap. Alternatively, if both plaintiffs seek only $30,000, neither supplies the necessary original diversity anchor.

What two elements establish a new domicile?
Physical presence in the new place and intent to remain indefinitely.
When are citizenship facts ordinarily measured?
When the action is filed.
What amount is insufficient even though it is close to the diversity threshold?
Exactly $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs.
What makes an embedded federal issue substantial?
Its importance to the federal system as a whole, rather than merely to the litigants.
What happens when an originally filed federal action lacks subject-matter jurisdiction?
The court must dismiss under Rule 12(h)(3), even if neither party objects.
COMMON MISTAKE

Common mistakes

The most plausible wrong answers use a true rule on the wrong jurisdictional question. Compare the disputed fact with the rule that actually governs it.

Table 10. Common jurisdiction confusions
Tempting choiceWhy it attractsFact that defeats it
Any federal issue permits federal-question jurisdictionThe defense may determine the outcomeThe federal issue appears only in a defense
Use the LLC's headquarters as its citizenshipThat location matters for corporationsThe defendant is unincorporated
Add every demand in the complaintThe overall litigation exceeds $75,000Separate parties own separate claims
Treat a temporary address as new citizenshipThe person currently lives thereA definite return plan preserves the former domicile
Dismiss because the eventual award was smallThe verdict falls below the thresholdA sufficient good-faith controversy existed at filing
ALGO

Approach

Use this sequence to organize a jurisdiction question before choosing an answer.

Locate the asserted right. Ask whether federal law creates the plaintiff's claim or a necessary federal issue satisfies the embedded-issue requirements.
Assign citizenship. Identify domicile for individuals, incorporation and nerve center for corporations, and every constituent's citizenship for unincorporated entities.
Compare opposing sides. Apply complete diversity or the specific alienage alignment, using citizenship at filing.
Value permissible relief. Apply the legal-certainty standard and count only recoverable amounts under the correct aggregation arrangement.
Check the governing route. Consider § 1367 for related claims, statutory exceptions, collusion, and reserved domestic-relations or probate functions.
Keep other forum issues distinct. Address personal jurisdiction, venue, removal restrictions, and governing law under their own rules.
QUIZ

Self-check quiz

Question 1

A Georgia citizen files an authorized federal civil-rights claim against another Georgia citizen and seeks $12,000. No statute other than § 1331 imposes a special jurisdictional limitation. Does the district court have subject-matter jurisdiction?

  1. Yes, because the complaint asserts a federal cause of action.
  2. No, because both parties are Georgia citizens.
  3. No, because the demand does not exceed $75,000.
  4. Yes, but only if the defendant consents.

Question 2

An Arizona citizen sues a corporation for $120,000 on a state contract claim. The corporation is incorporated in Delaware, has its actual executive headquarters in Arizona, and operates its largest factory in Nevada. Is complete diversity present?

  1. Yes, because incorporation alone determines corporate citizenship.
  2. Yes, because the largest factory makes the corporation a Nevada citizen.
  3. No, because the corporation and plaintiff share Arizona citizenship.
  4. No, because a corporation cannot have citizenship in multiple states.

Question 3

A citizen of Maine asserts two unrelated state-law claims against a citizen of Vermont: $46,000 for an unpaid loan and $32,000 for property damage. Both amounts are legally recoverable and claimed in good faith. Which conclusion is best?

  1. The claims cannot be combined because they are unrelated.
  2. Neither claim can proceed because each must independently exceed $75,000.
  3. The amount requirement is met only if the defendant files a counterclaim.
  4. The amount requirement is met because this plaintiff may aggregate both claims against this defendant.

Question 4

A U.S. citizen who has been domiciled in Spain for five years sues an Ohio citizen for $200,000 under state contract law. The plaintiff has no domicile in any U.S. state. Which conclusion is best?

  1. Diversity exists because the plaintiff lives outside Ohio.
  2. Ordinary diversity is absent because the plaintiff is neither a state citizen nor an alien.
  3. Alienage jurisdiction exists because Spain is a foreign state.
  4. Diversity exists because the demand exceeds $75,000.

Question 5

A Texas plaintiff sues a Texas defendant for legal malpractice in handling an earlier federal patent case. The state malpractice claim necessarily requires deciding a disputed patent issue, but its resolution has no significance beyond the parties' backward-looking dispute and cannot affect the patent's validity. What is the strongest reason against federal-question jurisdiction?

  1. The embedded federal issue lacks substantial importance to the federal system as a whole.
  2. A state-created claim can never arise under federal law.
  3. Federal-question jurisdiction always requires diverse citizenship.
  4. Any disputed patent issue automatically creates exclusive federal jurisdiction.
ANSWERS

Answer key

Question 1 - Answer: A. The plaintiff's authorized federal cause of action supports § 1331 jurisdiction without a general monetary threshold. B incorrectly imports diversity; C imports § 1332's amount requirement; D treats consent as jurisdictional authority.

Question 2 - Answer: C. The corporation is a citizen of Delaware and Arizona, and its Arizona citizenship overlaps the plaintiff's. A ignores the principal place of business; B substitutes production volume for the nerve center; D denies the statute's multiple-citizenship rule.

Question 3 - Answer: D. One plaintiff can aggregate unrelated claims against one defendant, producing a good-faith controversy of $78,000. A incorrectly requires related transactions; B overlooks permitted aggregation; C improperly relies on a counterclaim to supply the plaintiff's threshold.

Question 4 - Answer: B. A U.S. citizen domiciled abroad falls outside the relevant ordinary diversity categories. A mistakes different residences for qualifying state citizenship; C mistakes foreign domicile for foreign nationality; D treats monetary sufficiency as a substitute for citizenship.

Question 5 - Answer: A. Necessity and dispute are insufficient when the federal issue lacks broader federal-system significance, as illustrated by Gunn v. Minton. B overlooks embedded-issue jurisdiction; C confuses federal-question and diversity requirements; D treats every patent-related dispute as a patent cause of action.

RAPID

Rapid review

  • Federal defense only → ordinarily no § 1331 jurisdiction.
  • Federal cause of action → no general § 1331 monetary minimum.
  • New domicile → presence plus intent to remain indefinitely.
  • Corporate citizenship → incorporation plus actual nerve center.
  • LLC citizenship → every member, traced through ownership layers.
  • Complete diversity → no citizenship shared across opposing sides.
  • Ordinary diversity amount → more than $75,000, excluding interest and costs.
  • One plaintiff against one defendant → unrelated claims may be added.
  • Separate personal injuries → separate plaintiffs cannot aggregate their demands.
  • Missing subject-matter jurisdiction → agreement cannot cure the defect.
  • Colorable federal claim fails on an element → ordinarily a merits ruling, not loss of jurisdiction.
  • Nominal or misaligned party → assess the real interests before comparing citizenship.
  • Ordinary diversity class action → named representatives supply the relevant plaintiff citizenship.
  • Later demand reduction → ordinarily leaves properly established diversity jurisdiction intact.
  • Small final recovery → discretionary cost consequences may apply under § 1332(b).
  • Related Rule 20 plaintiff below the amount threshold → supplemental jurisdiction may work if complete diversity survives.

References

  • MBE Subject Matter Outline. National Conference of Bar Examiners, 2020.
  • United States Constitution, Article III, Section 2. United States.
  • United States Code, Title 28, §§ 1331, 1332, 1335, 1359, 1367, and 2201. United States.
  • Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rules 8, 12, 22, and 23. United States.
  • Hertz Corp. v. Friend. Supreme Court of the United States, 2010.
  • Grable & Sons Metal Products, Inc. v. Darue Engineering & Manufacturing. Supreme Court of the United States, 2005.
  • Gunn v. Minton. Supreme Court of the United States, 2013.
  • United States Code, Title 28, §§ 1338 and 1603. United States.
  • United States Code, Title 29, §§ 185 and 1132. United States.
End of your free lesson

Keep going with the full Multistate Bar Examination (MBE) Prep Course

You just studied the way members do, in the same lesson interface. Full access unlocks every lesson, the question bank and flashcards for a full year.

Up next with full access1.1.2 - Supplemental Jurisdiction and Removal

One payment per program