Skip to content
Free previewYou are reading 1 of 193 lessons, in the same interface members use. Everything else unlocks with full access.Get full access · $150

1.1.1 - Federal Subject Matter Jurisdiction

What you'll learn

  • Distinguish federal-question jurisdiction from diversity jurisdiction.
  • Determine citizenship, calculate the amount in controversy, and recognize special jurisdictional grants.
  • Decide whether additional claims qualify for supplemental jurisdiction.
  • Apply removal deadlines, defendant restrictions, and remand rules.
  • Explain the correct disposition when federal jurisdiction is missing.

Estimated reading time: 30 minutes.

WHY

Why it matters

A federal court must have authority over the kind of dispute before it can decide the merits. Bar questions often combine a valid claim with a citizenship defect, a federal defense, or a removal deadline; each can change whether the action belongs in federal court.

KEY TERMS

Key terms

Original jurisdiction
Authority to hear a claim under an independent jurisdictional grant when it first enters federal court.
Domicile
A person's fixed home, established through physical presence and intent to remain indefinitely.
Complete diversity
No plaintiff shares state citizenship with any defendant.
Amount in controversy
The legally cognizable value of the relief placed in dispute when jurisdiction is assessed.
Supplemental jurisdiction
Authority to hear additional claims sufficiently connected to a claim within original jurisdiction.
Removal
A qualifying defendant's transfer of a pending state action into federal court under a removal statute.
Remand
A federal court's return of a removed action or claim to state court.
CORE

Core content

1.1.1.1 Federal authority must exist independently of the merits

Article III of the United States Constitution sets the outer boundaries of federal judicial power. Congress must also authorize the district court to exercise that power. The ordinary civil-action gateways are federal-question jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1331 and diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332. A dispute may qualify under either, both, or a specialized statute.

Subject matter jurisdiction concerns the court's authority over the category of dispute. Personal jurisdiction concerns authority over a defendant, and venue concerns the proper geographic location. Establishing one does not establish the others. See also Personal Jurisdiction and Service and Venue and Forum Transfers.

Jurisdiction cannot be created by agreement. A contract selecting federal court, both parties' consent, or a defendant's failure to object cannot supply missing subject matter jurisdiction. A federal court has an independent obligation to examine its authority.

The party invoking federal jurisdiction bears the burden of establishing it. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8(a)(1) requires a short and plain statement of the grounds for jurisdiction unless the court already has jurisdiction and the claim needs no new support. A diversity allegation must identify citizenship, rather than merely residence or a company's business address.

Rule 12(b)(1) permits a motion challenging subject matter jurisdiction. Under Rule 12(h)(3), a court discovering the defect in an action originally filed in federal court must dismiss the action, ordinarily without prejudice to refiling in a competent court. A jurisdictional dismissal does not decide the substantive claim. In a removed action, the governing disposition is generally remand under 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c).

The following comparison separates jurisdictional questions from other threshold issues.

Table 1. Distinct threshold inquiries
InquiryQuestion answeredEffect of party conduct
Subject matter jurisdictionDoes federal law authorize this court to hear this category of dispute?Consent and ordinary forfeiture cannot establish it.
Personal jurisdictionDoes the court have authority over this defendant?The defense can be waived.
VenueIs this a statutorily proper geographic forum?The objection can be waived.
MeritsDoes the governing substantive law entitle the claimant to relief?A losing claim may still lie within federal jurisdiction.

State courts generally may hear federal claims unless Congress has made federal jurisdiction exclusive. For example, 28 U.S.C. § 1338(a) makes federal jurisdiction exclusive over patent-infringement claims, and 28 U.S.C. § 1334(a) gives district courts exclusive original jurisdiction over bankruptcy cases. Exclusivity does not extend automatically to every dispute involving a patent or a debtor.

A Exclusive and concurrent intellectual-property jurisdiction

Section 1338(a) makes federal jurisdiction exclusive over civil actions arising under federal patent and copyright law. Federal trademark claims generally may be heard in either state or federal court. Distinguish an infringement claim created by federal law from a state contract dispute concerning royalties or ownership: the latter does not become exclusively federal merely because the contract concerns a patent or copyright. If the claim is state-created, apply the embedded-federal-issue requirements already described rather than treating the subject matter of the contract as sufficient.

1.1.1.2 The plaintiff's claim must arise under federal law

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1331, federal district courts have jurisdiction over civil actions arising under the Constitution, federal laws, or treaties. Section 1331 has no minimum dollar requirement. A federal statutory claim seeking $500 may qualify even though a state contract claim seeking $500 ordinarily does not.

The well-pleaded complaint rule asks whether federal law supplies an essential part of the plaintiff's properly pleaded claim. Federal law usually creates the cause of action. A defendant's anticipated federal defense does not suffice, even when the complaint discusses that defense. A federal counterclaim also does not establish ordinary § 1331 jurisdiction over an otherwise state-law complaint.

A claim created by state law can fall within the narrow embedded-federal-issue category. Under the Supreme Court's Grable and Gunn framework, the state claim must necessarily raise a federal issue that is actually disputed, substantial to the federal system as a whole, and capable of resolution in federal court without disrupting the congressionally approved federal-state balance. All four requirements matter; importance to the litigants alone is insufficient.

The following examples distinguish a federal claim from federal material appearing elsewhere in the dispute.

Table 2. Where the federal issue appears
Claim or issueOrdinary § 1331 resultControlling distinction
Claim created by federal civil-rights lawFederal questionFederal law supplies the cause of action.
State contract claim facing a federal preemption defenseNo federal question from the defenseThe complaint's affirmative claim controls.
State claim necessarily presenting a disputed federal issuePossible narrow federal jurisdictionSubstantiality and federal-state balance must also be satisfied.
Federal counterclaim to a state complaintNo ordinary federal-question jurisdiction over the complaintThe counterclaim does not replace the plaintiff's claim.

Ordinary preemption means federal law defeats or displaces a state rule as a defense. Complete preemption is different: in a limited category where Congress has displaced the state cause of action with an exclusive federal one, the purported state claim is treated as federal from inception. Section 301 of the Labor Management Relations Act and certain claims within ERISA § 502(a) supply familiar examples. A statement that federal law regulates an industry does not establish complete preemption.

The Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. § 2201, supplies a remedy rather than an independent jurisdictional grant. Look to the anticipated coercive lawsuit. If that lawsuit would be a state contract action and federal law would appear only as a defense, reversing the parties through a declaratory action does not create § 1331 jurisdiction.

Jurisdiction and a viable claim are separate. A nonfrivolous federal claim generally invokes § 1331 even if it ultimately fails under Rule 12(b)(6). A purported federal claim that is wholly insubstantial or frivolous does not supply the same jurisdictional anchor.

A Checkpoint

A New York resident sues another New York resident for $120,000 under state contract law. The complaint anticipates that the defendant will invoke a federal statute as a defense. No complete preemption applies. Is there federal subject matter jurisdiction?

  1. No, because neither a federal defense nor the amount alone supplies a jurisdictional basis.
  2. Yes, because the complaint mentions federal law.
  3. Yes, because the amount exceeds $75,000.
  4. Yes, if both parties consent to federal adjudication.
Answer: A. The federal issue is a defense, and the parties are not diverse. B is tempting because the complaint discusses federal law, but the source of the affirmative claim controls.

1.1.1.3 Citizenship must be established for every party

Ordinary diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a) requires complete diversity and an amount in controversy exceeding $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs. Every plaintiff must be diverse from every defendant. Two plaintiffs may share citizenship with each other, as may two defendants; the prohibited overlap is across opposing sides.

For an individual, state citizenship ordinarily requires United States citizenship and domicile in a state. Domicile requires physical presence plus an intent to remain indefinitely. A person need not intend never to leave. An existing domicile continues until a new one is acquired, and an individual has only one domicile at a time. Residence, employment, voting registration, property ownership, and family location provide evidence but are not independently conclusive.

Citizenship ordinarily is assessed when the complaint is filed. A later genuine move does not destroy jurisdiction already established. A prefiling move can establish new citizenship if physical presence and the required intent actually exist. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1359, improper or collusive assignments or joinder cannot manufacture federal jurisdiction.

The next table identifies whose citizenship matters for common party types.

Table 3. Citizenship by party type
PartyCitizenship ruleFact that does not control alone
IndividualUnited States citizenship plus state domicileCurrent residence
CorporationEvery place of incorporation plus principal place of businessLargest sales market
LLCEvery member's citizenship, through all layersFormation state or headquarters
Partnership, including limited partnershipEvery general and limited partner's citizenshipPrincipal office
Legal representative of decedent, infant, or incompetentRepresented person's citizenship under § 1332(c)(2)Representative's personal domicile
United States citizen domiciled abroadNo state citizenship for ordinary diversityUnited States nationality alone

Under § 1332(c)(1), a corporation can hold multiple citizenships. Its principal place of business is its nerve center: the place where high-level officers actually direct, control, and coordinate corporate activities. Hertz Corp. v. Friend rejects treating the state with the most sales or operational activity as automatically controlling. A nominal headquarters or mail drop does not override the actual center of direction.

An LLC is not treated as a corporation merely because it offers limited liability. If an LLC's member is a partnership and one partner is another LLC, trace the citizenship of that entity's members as well. One nondiverse owner at any layer can defeat complete diversity. Ordinary class actions, by contrast, generally use the citizenship of named representatives rather than every absent class member.

A Alienage and unusual citizenship

Section 1332(a)(2) generally allows a citizen of a United States state to sue a citizen or subject of a foreign state. It does not generally support litigation between aliens alone. Section 1332(a)(3) allows citizens of different United States states on opposing sides with foreign citizens as additional parties; that configuration must be distinguished from an alien plaintiff suing an alien defendant alone.

A United States citizen domiciled abroad is neither a citizen of a state nor a foreign citizen for these purposes. Such a party can defeat ordinary diversity. A lawful permanent resident remains a foreign citizen for this analysis; § 1332(a)(2) excludes an action between a state citizen and a foreign citizen lawfully admitted for permanent residence who is domiciled in that same state. Do not apply the obsolete rule automatically deeming every permanent resident a state citizen.

Worked case

Elena, a United States citizen, moves from New York to Virginia for an indefinite position, leases a home, and plans to remain. She retains a New York bank account. She then sues Harbor LLC for $180,000. Harbor was formed in Delaware and has its headquarters in Pennsylvania. Its two members are a Maryland citizen and a corporation incorporated in Delaware with its actual nerve center in Virginia.

Elena has acquired Virginia domicile through presence and intent; the old bank account does not preserve New York citizenship. Harbor's citizenship follows its members. The corporate member contributes both Delaware and Virginia citizenship, while the individual member contributes Maryland citizenship. Because Elena and Harbor share Virginia citizenship, complete diversity is absent. The amount is sufficient, but no amount cures that citizenship overlap. A federal claim or another independent grant would be needed to proceed in federal court.

B Checkpoint

Using Table 3, determine the citizenship of an LLC formed in Delaware, headquartered in New York, and owned entirely by individuals domiciled in Ohio and Texas who are United States citizens.

  1. Delaware only
  2. Delaware and New York
  3. Ohio and Texas
  4. New York, Ohio, and Texas
Answer: C. The LLC row assigns citizenship through every member. B incorrectly applies the corporation rule to an LLC.

C Identify the real opposing parties before comparing citizenship

A caption does not conclusively establish which parties oppose each other. Courts align parties according to their actual interests in the principal dispute and disregard merely nominal parties without a real interest in the controversy. A genuinely interested defendant cannot be ignored simply because its presence defeats diversity. For example, naming a purely formal stakeholder does not necessarily add a relevant citizenship, while naming a party against whom substantive relief is actually sought ordinarily does.

These additional statutory classifications can change the citizenship comparison.

Table 4. Additional citizenship classifications
Party or locationRuleApplication
District of Columbia, territories, and Puerto RicoIncluded as States under section 1332(e).Do not classify their citizens as foreign citizens merely because the jurisdiction is not one of the fifty states.
State itselfNot a citizen for ordinary diversity jurisdiction.An action involving a state cannot rely on treating that state as a section 1332 citizen.
City or countyGenerally a citizen of its state unless it is an arm of the state.Separate local governmental status can permit diversity that would be unavailable for the state itself.
Foreign state as plaintiffSection 1332(a)(4) covers suits against citizens of a state or different states.The amount must still exceed $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs.
Liability insurer in a qualifying direct actionAdd the absent insured's citizenship to the insurer's own citizenship under section 1332(c)(1).The added citizenship may eliminate complete diversity.

The insurer rule concerns a direct action seeking to impose an insured's liability on the insurer when the insured is not joined as a defendant. It does not mean that every coverage dispute between an insured and its insurer acquires additional citizenship. Suppose a New York accident victim directly sues a Delaware-incorporated insurer with its nerve center in Connecticut for the liability of an absent New York insured. In a qualifying direct action, the insurer also has New York citizenship, defeating diversity despite its otherwise diverse corporate citizenship.

D Citizenship disclosure is separate from a pleading allegation

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 7.1(a)(2) ordinarily requires a party or intervenor in an action based on section 1332(a) to file a disclosure naming and identifying the citizenship of every individual or entity whose citizenship is attributed to it. The requirement applies when the action is filed in or removed to federal court and when a later event could affect diversity, unless the court orders otherwise. An LLC therefore cannot satisfy the substantive inquiry merely by disclosing its formation state. The disclosure must reveal the citizenship attributable through its ownership structure.

1.1.1.4 Value the controversy under the applicable jurisdictional grant

Section 1332(a) requires an amount exceeding $75,000. Exactly $75,000 is insufficient. The plaintiff's good-faith allegation ordinarily controls unless it appears to a legal certainty that the plaintiff cannot recover more than the threshold. A controlling damages cap can establish that certainty. An eventual verdict below the threshold does not retrospectively eliminate jurisdiction properly established at filing.

Include compensatory damages, punitive damages if legally recoverable, and attorney fees when substantive law or a contract makes them recoverable as part of the claim. Exclude ordinary litigation costs and interest merely incidental to the underlying obligation. Interest that itself forms part of the substantive claim requires a different analysis from interest added only because payment was delayed.

For an injunction or other nonmonetary remedy, determine the monetary value of the object of the litigation under the governing valuation approach. Courts differ over whether the plaintiff's benefit, the defendant's compliance cost, or either perspective controls. A question supplying a valuation rule must be answered using that rule rather than an assumed nationwide formula.

Aggregation turns on the legal ownership and structure of the claims, as shown below.

Table 5. Combining amounts in controversy
ConfigurationAggregation treatmentApplication
One plaintiff against one defendantAll claims may be added, even if unrelated.$45,000 contract claim plus $40,000 tort claim totals $85,000.
Separate plaintiffs with separate claimsClaims generally cannot be added together.Two $40,000 injuries do not independently satisfy § 1332(a).
One plaintiff against separately liable defendantsSeparate obligations generally cannot be added across defendants.Two distinct $40,000 debts do not create an $80,000 claim against either debtor.
One jointly enforceable obligationUse the value of the joint obligation.A $90,000 joint liability is valued at $90,000, not divided by defendant count.
Plaintiffs holding a common undivided interestThe shared interest may be valued together.A jointly owned right differs from separate personal injury claims.

A Exceptions and specialized grants

The domestic-relations exception to diversity jurisdiction covers issuing divorce, alimony, and child-custody decrees. It does not automatically exclude every tort or contract dispute between relatives. The probate exception reserves probate or annulment of a will, estate administration, and interference with property in a state probate court's custody. An otherwise qualifying damages claim against an individual may proceed if it does not require the federal court to perform those reserved functions.

Special statutes may change the ordinary thresholds. Under the Class Action Fairness Act, 28 U.S.C. § 1332(d), qualifying class actions generally require at least 100 proposed members, an aggregate amount exceeding $5 million, and minimal diversity: any class member differs in citizenship from any defendant. Local-controversy, home-state, and other statutory exceptions can require or permit declining jurisdiction. These special rules do not replace complete diversity in an ordinary two-party lawsuit.

Statutory interpleader under 28 U.S.C. § 1335 generally requires property or an obligation worth at least $500, minimal diversity between two adverse claimants, and the required deposit or bond. The stakeholder's citizenship is not the minimal-diversity comparison. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 22 supplies procedural interpleader but no jurisdictional grant; Rule 22 litigation needs an independent basis, such as ordinary diversity with its ordinary amount requirement.

Match each jurisdictional category to its distinctive threshold.

Federal question under § 1331:
No statutory minimum dollar amount.
Ordinary diversity under § 1332(a):
Complete separation across opposing sides and more than $75,000.
Qualifying CAFA class action:
At least 100 proposed members, minimal diversity, and more than $5 million aggregated.
Statutory interpleader under § 1335:
At least $500 and differently domiciled adverse claimants.

B Reducing the demand after jurisdiction attaches

A later amendment reducing a properly alleged diversity demand below the jurisdictional threshold ordinarily does not defeat jurisdiction. The same distinction applies after proper removal: a later damages reduction ordinarily does not compel remand. Separate that later change from evidence showing that the original claim never could legally exceed $75,000. A binding prefiling limitation may prevent the threshold from being met, while a postfiling concession ordinarily cannot erase jurisdiction that already attached.

C CAFA exceptions require more than a local setting

CAFA uses the citizenship of proposed class members, not merely the citizenship of named representatives, for its local-citizenship exceptions. The following rules distinguish mandatory and discretionary treatment under section 1332(d).

Table 6. CAFA local-citizenship exceptions
ProvisionCitizenship requirementAdditional conditions or consequence
Mandatory home-state exception: section 1332(d)(4)(B)At least two-thirds of class members and the primary defendants are citizens of the filing state.The district court must decline CAFA jurisdiction.
Mandatory local-controversy exception: section 1332(d)(4)(A)More than two-thirds of class members are filing-state citizens; a qualifying significant defendant is also a filing-state citizen.Local principal injuries and the three-year prior-class-action condition must also be satisfied.
Discretionary exception: section 1332(d)(3)More than one-third but less than two-thirds of class members, and the primary defendants, are filing-state citizens.The court weighs the statutory factors in the interests of justice and totality of circumstances.

For the mandatory local-controversy exception, at least one forum-state defendant must be a defendant from whom significant relief is sought and whose alleged conduct forms a significant basis for the class claims. The principal injuries from each defendant's alleged conduct must have occurred in the filing state. During the preceding three years, no other class action asserting the same or similar factual allegations may have been filed against any defendant on behalf of the same or other persons. A local mailing address or a local named plaintiff alone does not establish these requirements.

The discretionary exception requires consideration of all six statutory factors.

  • National or interstate interest: A broader interest weighs toward federal adjudication.
  • Governing law: Predominantly forum-state law favors declining jurisdiction.
  • Jurisdiction-avoidance pleading: Pleading designed to avoid federal jurisdiction weighs against declining it.
  • Forum connection: A distinct connection to the class, alleged harm, or defendants favors declining jurisdiction.
  • Citizenship distribution: A substantially larger forum-state share and dispersed citizenship elsewhere favor declining jurisdiction.
  • Other class actions: Similar class actions filed during the preceding three years may favor coordinated federal treatment rather than a purely local characterization.

1.1.1.5 Additional claims need a connection and a statutory check

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1367(a), a federal court with original jurisdiction over an anchor claim generally may hear additional claims forming part of the same Article III case or controversy. The usual formulation is a common nucleus of operative fact: the claims are sufficiently connected that one would ordinarily expect them to be tried together. Sharing only a broad legal topic is insufficient.

In a federal-question action, a related state claim may qualify despite nondiverse parties or an amount below $75,000. For example, a federal employment-discrimination claim and a state retaliation claim arising from the same termination may belong to the same case or controversy. An unrelated state debt claim against that employer needs its own jurisdictional basis.

When original jurisdiction rests solely on diversity, § 1367(b) adds restrictions. It bars specified claims by plaintiffs against persons made parties under Rules 14, 19, 20, or 24 when jurisdiction would be inconsistent with § 1332. It also restricts claims by persons proposed to join as plaintiffs under Rule 19 or to intervene as plaintiffs under Rule 24. The statute prevents plaintiffs from circumventing diversity limits through specified joinder devices.

The following comparison shows why the identity of the claimant matters.

Table 7. Supplemental claims in a diversity-only action
Additional claimTypical result if factually relatedReason
Defendant's indemnity claim against a nondiverse Rule 14 third-party defendantSupplemental jurisdiction generally availableThe restriction targets specified plaintiff claims.
Original plaintiff's claim against that nondiverse third-party defendantSupplemental jurisdiction barredSection 1367(b) expressly reaches plaintiff claims against Rule 14 parties.
Rule 20 coplaintiff's related $20,000 claim against a diverse defendantMay qualify when another plaintiff meets the amountAn amount defect can be supplemented while complete diversity remains intact.
Rule 20 coplaintiff sharing citizenship with a defendantNo cure through supplemental jurisdictionThe nondiverse party defeats complete diversity.

A compulsory counterclaim commonly shares the operative facts and may qualify under § 1367(a). A permissive counterclaim needs an independent basis unless it nevertheless satisfies the statutory case-or-controversy connection. The procedural label alone does not establish or foreclose supplemental jurisdiction. See also Joinder and Class Actions.

Section 1367(c) permits a court to decline supplemental jurisdiction when the state claim presents a novel or complex state-law issue, substantially predominates, remains after all original-jurisdiction claims have been dismissed, or presents exceptional circumstances with other compelling reasons. Dismissal of the federal anchor therefore authorizes a discretionary decision; it does not automatically erase jurisdiction that attached to related claims.

Limitations protection: Under § 1367(d), the limitations period for covered supplemental claims is generally suspended while the claim is pending and for 30 days after dismissal, unless state law provides a longer period. The clock is stopped, rather than merely replaced with a universal 30-day refiling limit.

Worked case

A New York citizen sues a New Jersey manufacturer in federal court for $200,000 after a machine accident. The manufacturer impleads a New York maintenance contractor for contractual indemnity arising from the same accident. The plaintiff then asserts a $100,000 negligence claim directly against the contractor. A separate warranty document identifies a Pennsylvania warehouse.

The original claim has complete diversity and a sufficient amount. The manufacturer's indemnity claim is factually related and is brought by a defendant, so § 1367(b)'s plaintiff restriction does not ordinarily bar it. The plaintiff's direct claim against the Rule 14 contractor is different: plaintiff and contractor share New York citizenship, and § 1367(b) expressly blocks that attempted use of supplemental jurisdiction. The warehouse address establishes neither a party's citizenship nor an alternative jurisdictional grant. The court can retain the original suit and the proper indemnity claim while rejecting the plaintiff's unsupported direct claim.

A Amendment deleting federal claims differs from their judicial dismissal

Do not extend the discretionary-retention rule to every event that removes federal claims from a case. In Royal Canin U.S.A., Inc. v. Wullschleger (2025), the Supreme Court held that a plaintiff's post-removal amendment eliminating the federal claims that enabled removal also eliminated supplemental jurisdiction over the remaining state claims. Without another original-jurisdiction basis, remand was required. This differs from a court dismissing the federal claims on the merits, after which section 1367(c)(3) permits discretionary treatment of the related state claims.

For example, a complaint containing federal and related state consumer claims is properly removed. The plaintiff then amends the complaint to leave only state claims, and the parties are nondiverse. The court must remand. Change the event to a judicial merits dismissal of the federal claims, with the related state claims still pleaded, and the court instead considers whether to exercise its remaining supplemental authority.

1.1.1.6 Removal adds restrictions to original jurisdiction

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1441(a), an original defendant generally may remove a state action that falls within federal original jurisdiction. Removal goes to the federal district and division embracing the state court where the action is pending. It is not a device for choosing any convenient federal district; transfer is a separate question.

The original plaintiff cannot remove after receiving a counterclaim. An ordinary counterclaim defendant or third-party defendant also cannot remove under § 1441 merely because a claim against it invokes federal law. Specialized removal statutes, including federal-officer and civil-rights removal, have their own requirements and must be analyzed under their own grants.

For removal based solely on ordinary diversity, § 1441(b)(2) adds the forum-defendant rule: removal is barred if any properly joined and served defendant is a citizen of the forum state. Thus, a New York plaintiff's $100,000 action against a New Jersey defendant in New Jersey state court can satisfy original diversity jurisdiction but still be nonremovable once the New Jersey defendant is properly joined and served. This restriction does not bar a removal independently supported by a federal question.

Figure 1 separates original jurisdiction from the additional removal restrictions.

Fig 1. Ordinary removal decision
Key point: A removable action needs an original jurisdictional basis and compliance with additional removal rules.
flowchart TD
A[Original defendant seeks removal] --> B{Original federal jurisdiction?}
B -->|No| C[Remain in state court]
B -->|Yes| D{Diversity is sole basis?}
D -->|Yes| E{Served forum defendant?}
E -->|Yes| C
E -->|No| F[Check timing and consent]
D -->|No| F
F --> G{Procedural requirements satisfied?}
G -->|Yes| H[File in embracing district]
G -->|No| I[Procedural remand risk]

A Timing and procedure

Section 1446(b) generally gives a defendant 30 days from the applicable formal-service trigger to remove an initially removable case. Mere informal receipt of a courtesy complaint before formal service does not start the ordinary removal clock. Where the jurisdiction's procedure separates summons and complaint, apply § 1446(b)(1)'s specified service and receipt rules to the facts.

If the initial case is not removable, § 1446(b)(3) generally supplies 30 days after receipt of an amended pleading, motion, order, or other paper first making removability ascertainable. Under § 1446(c)(1), this later-removal route based on diversity generally closes one year after commencement unless the court finds plaintiff bad faith prevented removal. Deliberately withholding the true amount to prevent removal can support the statutory bad-faith finding.

The deadlines below have different triggering events.

Table 8. Removal and remand clocks
EventOrdinary periodTrigger or qualification
Initially removable action30 daysApplicable formal-service trigger under § 1446(b)(1)
Action becomes removable later30 daysReceipt of qualifying paper first establishing removability
Later diversity removalOne-year outer limitMeasured from commencement; plaintiff bad faith can create an exception
Motion alleging procedural removal defect30 daysFiling of the federal notice of removal
Remand for missing subject matter jurisdictionWhenever identified before final judgmentNo procedural-defect forfeiture after 30 days

Under § 1446(b)(2), all properly joined and served defendants generally must join in or consent to ordinary § 1441 removal. Each defendant receives its own 30-day removal period. An earlier-served defendant may consent to timely removal by a later-served defendant even if the earlier defendant's own period has expired.

The removing defendant files a notice in federal court containing a short and plain statement of removal grounds and the required copies of process, pleadings, and orders. Under § 1446(d), the defendant must promptly notify adverse parties in writing and file a copy of the notice with the state court. That state-court filing effects removal and prevents further state proceedings unless the case is remanded.

B Correcting an improper removal

Section 1447(c) distinguishes procedural defects from missing subject matter jurisdiction. A plaintiff must move within 30 days after filing of the removal notice to raise a procedural defect such as untimeliness, lack of required consent, or violation of the forum-defendant rule. A federal court discovering missing subject matter jurisdiction before final judgment must remand even if everyone remained silent for more than 30 days.

Under § 1447(e), if the plaintiff seeks to join a new defendant whose citizenship would destroy diversity, the court may deny joinder or permit joinder and remand. It may not permit diversity-destroying joinder and simply ignore the resulting jurisdictional defect.

Under § 1441(c), a removable federal-question claim can coexist initially with a claim outside both original and supplemental jurisdiction, or one made nonremovable by statute. The court must sever and remand the claims specified by that provision. Only defendants against whom the federal-question claim is asserted must consent under this specialized subsection. Related state claims within § 1367 are not automatically severed merely because they arise under state law.

Review of remand orders: Section 1447(d) generally bars review of remand orders covered by its jurisdictional and procedural framework. Statutory exceptions include removals under §§ 1442 and 1443; do not assume every remand order is appealable.

C Proving the amount when the state complaint does not resolve it

Section 1446(c)(2) generally treats a good-faith amount demanded in the initial state pleading as controlling. A defendant may assert the jurisdictional amount in the removal notice when the pleading seeks nonmonetary relief or when state practice prohibits a specific demand or permits recovery beyond the amount demanded. If the amount is contested, removal on that basis requires a finding by a preponderance of the evidence that the amount exceeds $75,000. This removal inquiry differs from the legal-certainty standard applied to an original federal plaintiff's good-faith amount allegation.

D CAFA removal changes the ordinary checklist

Section 1453(b) permits a qualifying CAFA class action to be removed by any defendant without obtaining the other defendants' consent. Forum-state citizenship does not bar that removal, and section 1446(c)(1)'s one-year limit does not apply. Applicable 30-day removal periods still matter; eliminating the one-year ceiling does not create an unlimited removal period. These exceptions concern qualifying CAFA actions and do not change the ordinary rules for an individual diversity lawsuit.

CAFA also supplies a distinct review route: under section 1453(c)(1), a court of appeals may accept an appeal from an order granting or denying remand if an application is made within 10 days after entry. Acceptance is discretionary. The deadline is therefore different from both the 30-day procedural-remand deadline and the ordinary restrictions on review under section 1447(d).

Answer these prompts from memory before proceeding to the mixed questions.

E Recall check

What is the exact ordinary diversity amount threshold?
The amount must exceed $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs.
What two elements establish a new domicile?
Physical presence in the new state and an intent to remain there indefinitely.
What are the four embedded-federal-issue requirements?
The federal issue must be necessarily raised, actually disputed, substantial to the federal system, and resolvable without disturbing the federal-state balance.
Which supplemental-jurisdiction provision restricts specified plaintiff claims in diversity-only cases?
Section 1367(b).
What happens when an originally filed federal action lacks subject matter jurisdiction, compared with a removed action?
The original action is ordinarily dismissed without prejudice; the removed action is ordinarily remanded.
COMMON MISTAKE

Common mistakes

These errors arise from applying a correct rule to the wrong procedural category.

Table 9. Closely related rules with different consequences
Tempting choiceWhy it attracts attentionFact that resolves the issue
Use corporate citizenship for an LLCBoth entities provide limited liability.The party is an LLC; its members supply citizenship.
Remove because a federal defense is decisiveThe defense may determine the entire case.The plaintiff's claim arises only under state law, without complete preemption.
Treat every removal defect as jurisdictionalEach defect can produce remand.A served forum defendant creates a procedural removal defect, not missing original diversity jurisdiction.
Supplement every claim arising from one accidentThe common facts satisfy § 1367(a).A diversity-only plaintiff claim against a nondiverse Rule 14 party triggers § 1367(b).
Add separate plaintiffs' damagesThe combined losses exceed $75,000.Separate ownership of claims prevents aggregation; a qualifying anchor must exist before supplemental analysis.
ALGO

Approach

Analyze a jurisdiction problem in this order, keeping claims and parties separate.

Locate an original grant. Test the complaint under § 1331, § 1332, or an identified specialized statute.
Resolve citizenship and valuation. For ordinary diversity, compare every plaintiff with every defendant and apply the amount and aggregation rules.
Classify additional claims. Apply § 1367(a), then § 1367(b) if the anchor rests solely on diversity, then § 1367(c).
Audit removal separately. Check the removing party, embracing district, forum citizenship, consent, 30-day period, and any one-year limit.
Select the disposition. Distinguish dismissal of an original action, remand of a removed action, and discretionary treatment of supplemental claims.

See also Pleadings and Responsive Motions for Rule 12 sequencing, and Erie and Choice of Law for the substantive law a federal court applies after jurisdiction is established.

QUIZ

Self-check quiz

Question 1

A New York citizen sues a Delaware corporation whose actual nerve center is New Jersey. The plaintiff asserts an unrelated $45,000 contract claim and $40,000 property-damage claim against the corporation. Both amounts are legally recoverable and alleged in good faith. Does ordinary diversity jurisdiction exist?

  1. No, because unrelated claims cannot be combined.
  2. Yes, because the parties are completely diverse and the plaintiff may aggregate both claims.
  3. No, because each claim must exceed $75,000 independently.
  4. Yes, because incorporation in Delaware eliminates the need to consider the principal place of business.

Question 2

A California citizen sues a Nevada citizen in federal court for $160,000 after a collision. The defendant impleads a California mechanic for indemnity arising from the same collision. The plaintiff then asserts a related negligence claim against the mechanic. Which statement is most accurate?

  1. Both additional claims fail because the mechanic is a California citizen.
  2. Both additional claims qualify because they arise from the same collision.
  3. The plaintiff's claim qualifies, but the defendant's indemnity claim does not.
  4. The indemnity claim may qualify, but § 1367(b) bars the plaintiff's nondiverse claim against the mechanic.

Question 3

A New York citizen sues a New Jersey citizen for $100,000 in New Jersey state court. After proper service, the defendant timely removes solely on diversity grounds. Forty days after the removal notice is filed, the plaintiff first moves to remand solely because the defendant is a forum citizen. How should the court address that ground?

  1. Reject it as untimely because the forum-defendant objection is a procedural removal defect.
  2. Grant remand because forum citizenship eliminates original diversity jurisdiction.
  3. Grant remand because every removal defect remains available until final judgment.
  4. Dismiss the action without prejudice because the defendant lives in the forum.

Question 4

A plaintiff files a nonfrivolous federal employment claim and a related state wage claim against the same employer. The court later dismisses the federal claim on the merits before trial. What is the court's authority over the state claim?

  1. The court must dismiss it because federal jurisdiction disappears retroactively.
  2. The court must retain it because supplemental jurisdiction is mandatory after attachment.
  3. The court may decline supplemental jurisdiction under § 1367(c), considering the relevant circumstances.
  4. The court may retain it only if the parties are diverse and the wage claim exceeds $75,000.

Question 5

Two completely diverse plaintiffs join related claims against one defendant arising from the same accident. One plaintiff seeks $120,000; the other seeks $25,000. Joinder is proper under Rule 20. What is the strongest basis for hearing both claims?

  1. Aggregate the separate plaintiffs' claims to create the jurisdictional amount.
  2. Use original diversity jurisdiction for the larger claim and supplemental jurisdiction for the smaller related claim.
  3. Treat the smaller claim as arising under federal law because Rule 20 permits joinder.
  4. Use supplemental jurisdiction to dispense with the need for any claim to meet the jurisdictional amount.
ANSWERS

Answer key

Question 1 - Answer: B. One plaintiff may aggregate unrelated claims against one defendant, producing $85,000; neither corporate citizenship overlaps New York. A incorrectly requires relatedness for aggregation; C incorrectly imposes a separate threshold on each claim; D incorrectly ignores the corporation's additional New Jersey citizenship.

Question 2 - Answer: D. The defendant's related indemnity claim ordinarily falls within § 1367(a), while § 1367(b) bars the original plaintiff's claim against a nondiverse Rule 14 party. A applies the plaintiff restriction to defendants; B stops after factual relatedness; C reverses the statutory treatment of the two claimants.

Question 3 - Answer: A. The forum-defendant restriction concerns removability, and § 1447(c) requires a motion asserting that procedural defect within 30 days after the removal notice. B confuses original diversity with removal restrictions; C incorrectly extends the jurisdictional rule to procedural defects; D selects dismissal despite an otherwise competent federal forum and a removed action.

Question 4 - Answer: C. Dismissal of all original-jurisdiction claims permits the court to decline supplemental jurisdiction under § 1367(c), rather than automatically requiring either retention or dismissal. A incorrectly treats a merits dismissal as retroactively jurisdictional; B disregards statutory discretion; D demands an independent grant where supplemental authority may remain.

Question 5 - Answer: B. The $120,000 claim supplies an original diversity anchor, and the related Rule 20 coplaintiff claim may use § 1367 while complete diversity remains intact. A improperly aggregates separately owned claims; C mistakes a procedural rule for a jurisdictional grant; D incorrectly removes the need for a qualifying anchor.

RAPID

Rapid review

  • Federal defense → ordinarily no § 1331 gateway.
  • Ordinary diversity → complete diversity plus more than $75,000.
  • Individual citizenship → nationality plus domicile, not address alone.
  • Corporation → incorporation and actual nerve center.
  • LLC or partnership → trace every member or partner.
  • One plaintiff against one defendant → unrelated claims may aggregate.
  • Related additional claim → apply § 1367(a), then any diversity-only restriction.
  • Served forum defendant → blocks diversity-only removal, subject to timely objection.
  • Procedural remand motion → 30 days after filing the removal notice.
  • Missing jurisdiction → dismiss an original action; remand a removed action.
  • Qualifying insurer direct action → count the absent insured's citizenship too.
  • Postfiling damages reduction → ordinarily leaves properly attached diversity jurisdiction intact.
  • Amendment deleting every federal basis after removal → remand if no independent original jurisdiction remains.
  • CAFA home-state exception → at least two-thirds local class citizenship plus local primary defendants.
  • CAFA removal → no ordinary unanimity, forum-defendant bar, or one-year ceiling.
  • CAFA remand review application → within 10 days after entry of the order.

References

  • Constitution of the United States, Article III. United States.
  • United States Code, Title 28, §§ 1331-1335, 1338, 1359, 1367, 1441-1447, and 2201. United States Congress, current codification.
  • Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rules 8, 12, 14, 19, 20, 22, and 24. United States Courts, current rules.
  • Grable & Sons Metal Products, Inc. v. Darue Engineering & Manufacturing. Supreme Court of the United States, 2005; Gunn v. Minton. Supreme Court of the United States, 2013; Hertz Corp. v. Friend. Supreme Court of the United States, 2010.
  • Labor Management Relations Act, § 301, and Employee Retirement Income Security Act, § 502(a). United States Congress.
  • MBE Subject Matter Outline, Civil Procedure. National Conference of Bar Examiners, 2020.
  • Royal Canin U.S.A., Inc. v. Wullschleger. Supreme Court of the United States, 2025.
  • United States Code, Title 28, § 1453. United States Congress, 2026.
End of your free lesson

Keep going with the full New York Bar Exam and NYLE Prep Course

You just studied the way members do, in the same lesson interface. Full access unlocks every lesson, the question bank and flashcards for a full year.

Up next with full access1.1.2 - Personal Jurisdiction and Service

One payment per program