Skip to content
Free previewYou are reading 1 of 27 lessons, in the same interface members use. Everything else unlocks with full access.Get full access · $150

1.1.1 - Broker-Dealer Registration and Membership

What you'll learn

  • Recognize business activities that require broker-dealer registration.
  • Distinguish the approvals a firm needs before its representatives solicit customers.
  • Select the filing and deadline for a disclosure change, acquisition, expansion or withdrawal.
  • Determine what a member may do while FINRA considers a proposed change.

Estimated reading time: 17 minutes.

WHY

Why it matters

A registered representative moves to a start-up and wants to call former customers before the new firm's membership decision arrives. The same question arises when an established firm buys a competitor or adds a trading desk: what activity may this legal entity conduct today? Series 24 scenarios turn on the difference between disclosing a fact, requesting permission and having authority to act.

KEY TERMS

Key terms

Effecting a transaction
Participating in bringing about a securities purchase or sale. Soliciting investors, negotiating terms or taking orders can be evidence of this activity.
Central Registration Depository (CRD)
The registration system that holds firm and personnel records and makes filings available to participating regulators.
Membership agreement
The written terms governing a FINRA member's authorized business, including any restrictions imposed at admission or later.
Continuing membership application (CMA)
An existing member's application for FINRA review of a covered change in ownership, control or operations.
Materiality consultation
A request for FINRA to determine whether a proposed change requires a CMA. Specified situations require a written request even when an ordinary numerical threshold is unmet.
Safe harbor
A defined range of expansion that an eligible member may presume is nonmaterial when the applicable conditions are satisfied.
CORE

Core content

1.1.1.1 Recognize when the business requires registration

The Securities Exchange Act of 1934 defines a broker in Section 3(a)(4) by whose account the firm serves. A company that routinely finds buyers for another person's securities, negotiates purchases and receives a commission acts for others. Section 3(a)(5) defines a dealer by both account and activity: the firm buys and sells for its own account as a business. A market maker that stands ready to buy from and sell to customers is a familiar example. A manufacturer investing surplus cash for its own account ordinarily falls within the trader exception. Ownership of the securities answers only half the dealer question.

Under Section 15(a), the federal registration obligation generally reaches use of interstate means to effect transactions or induce or attempt to induce purchases or sales. An email soliciting investors can therefore matter before anyone places an order. Transaction-based compensation is particularly significant because the intermediary earns money when a deal closes. Examine the actual services as well as the fee. Calling someone a consultant supplies little information about either.

Table 1 separates facts about the intermediary from facts about the securities being sold.

Table 1. Activities at the registration boundary
ActivityControlling detailLikely treatment
Outside consultant repeatedly solicits private-placement buyersReceives a percentage of each completed sale for an issuerBroker activity; examine registration before solicitation
Firm quotes both sides and supplies securities from inventoryRegular business serving counterparties as principalDealer activity
Operating company invests excess cashTrades for its own portfolio outside a securities dealing businessOrdinary own-account investing
Issuer sells newly issued shares directlyRaises its own capitalIssuance alone generally does not make the issuer a broker

An issuer's offering exemption and an intermediary's registration exemption answer different statutory questions. A private placement may qualify for an exemption from Securities Act registration while its sales agent still needs broker registration. An issuer employee who helps sell the issuer's securities requires a separate analysis. Exchange Act Rule 3a4-1 provides a conditional safe harbor that includes restrictions on transaction-based pay and broker-dealer association, a statutory-disqualification condition and limits on sales activity. An employee title alone does not establish eligibility.

A When an issuer employee participates in selling

Apply Rule 3a4-1 to the individual at the time of participation. The person must be free of statutory disqualification, receive no direct or indirect transaction-based compensation for participating, and have no current association with a broker-dealer. Then match the person's work to one of the three routes in Table 2.

Table 2. Permitted activity routes for issuer personnel
RouteQualifying activityDetail that changes the answer
Specified transactionsLimit participation to designated institutional sales, statutory exemptions, security-holder transactions or employee plans.An individual's accredited-investor status alone does not qualify a sale.
Substantial other dutiesPrimarily perform substantial nonsecurities duties for the issuer or expect to do so after the offering.Check both prior broker-dealer activity and frequency of offerings.
Limited selling assistanceDistribute approved written material without oral solicitation, answer qualifying incoming inquiries, or perform ministerial or clerical work.A purchaser must initiate an inquiry, and the answer must stay within the filed registration statement or other offering document.

The first route includes sales to registered broker-dealers, registered investment companies or separate accounts, insurers, banks, savings and loans, supervised trust companies or similar institutions, and qualifying trusts with specified trustees or written investment authority. It also includes Securities Act exemptions under Sections 3(a)(7), (9) and (10), specified reorganizations submitted for security-holder approval, and qualifying employee benefit or investment plans.

For the substantial-duties route, look back 12 months for service as a broker, dealer or associated person of either. Selling participation ordinarily may occur only once every 12 months across issuers, apart from participation under the other two routes. For a Rule 415 offering, measure from the last sale under that registration. A salaried treasurer who left a brokerage sales job eight months ago fails the lookback even if this is her first offering. For the written-material route, an issuer partner, officer or director must approve the content. Failure to qualify for the safe harbor calls for analysis of actual broker activity.

B When all the firm's business stays in one state

Section 15(a)(1) provides an exception when the broker-dealer's business is exclusively intrastate and it uses no facility of a national securities exchange. Test the entire business. An office and every employee can be in one state while the firm solicits customers across the state line. Conversely, exchange use defeats this exception even if all customers reside locally. State registration remains a separate question.

1.1.1.2 Identify the authority needed before solicitation

Form BD identifies the applicant legal entity, its business, owners, control persons, jurisdictions and disciplinary disclosures. Schedule A identifies direct owners and executive officers; Schedule B addresses indirect owners. A holding company between the applicant and its ultimate owner makes the indirect ownership schedule especially important. The firm files through CRD. A system receipt establishes that a filing arrived. The status of the application tells the principal whether the relevant regulator has acted.

Under Exchange Act Section 15(b)(1), the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) generally must grant registration or begin proceedings to determine whether to deny it within 45 days after filing, unless the applicant agrees to a longer period. Commencing proceedings satisfies that statutory decision point. A calendar entry 45 days after submission is therefore insufficient evidence that a sales desk may open.

Table 3 shows what a principal should establish for a firm proposing ordinary off-exchange retail brokerage.

Table 3. Evidence supporting a proposed solicitation
AuthorityEvidence to inspectQuestion it answers
Federal registrationSEC broker-dealer registration statusIs this legal entity federally registered?
Self-regulatory membershipEffective FINRA membership and agreementMay the member conduct this business on these terms?
State registration or exemptionFirm status or applicable exemption in the relevant jurisdictionMay this firm conduct the proposed activity there?
Individual registrationRepresentative's association, registration categories and applicable state statusMay this individual perform the proposed function for this firm?

Exchange Act Section 15(b)(8) generally requires membership in a registered national securities association unless the broker-dealer effects transactions solely on a national securities exchange of which it is a member or qualifies for an applicable exemption. Exchange membership alone is inadequate support for an off-exchange brokerage business. State law adds a jurisdiction-specific inquiry. A firm without a branch in a customer's state may still have a registration obligation there.

Authority to act. The representative checks the firm's authorization before inviting orders. The principal verifies the regulator's decision, the activity permitted and the individual's status. An internal approval cannot confer registration or expand a membership agreement.

A Checkpoint

A representative has passed the Series 7 exam. Her new employer has effective SEC registration, but its initial FINRA application for off-exchange retail brokerage is pending. What may the principal authorize?

  1. Calls inviting orders if the firm postpones execution
  2. Internal training while customer solicitation remains on hold
  3. Solicitation limited to accredited investors
  4. Order entry through a FINRA-member clearing firm
Answer: B. Internal preparation can proceed. Delaying execution under A leaves the invitation to transact in place. The firm's authority must cover the solicitation itself.

B After the SEC starts denial proceedings

Section 15(b)(1) starts a second clock when the SEC gives notice that it has instituted proceedings. The applicant receives notice of the grounds and an opportunity for a hearing. The SEC generally must conclude the proceedings within 120 days after that notice. It may extend the period by up to 90 days for good cause and publish its reasons, or proceed for a longer period to which the applicant consents. If a question gives both the Form BD filing date and the date of notice, use the notice date for the 120-day calculation.

1.1.1.3 Connect the membership decision to the business plan

Under FINRA Rule 1013, a prospective member submits a new member application (Form NMA) and the supporting materials for the business it intends to conduct. Form BD supplies registration disclosures. The NMA supplies evidence that the applicant can operate the business it describes. For example, an introducing broker that sends accounts to a carrying firm must explain the clearing arrangement, the division of responsibilities and how its own principals will supervise the work it retains.

Rule 1014 directs FINRA's Membership Application Program staff to evaluate whether the applicant meets the admission standards. The review connects each product, office and customer activity to qualified people, financial resources and operating controls. Table 4 shows what would resolve common gaps in an application.

Table 4. Evidence for admission
Issue raised by the planEvidence that addresses itReason it matters
Owners supply start-up fundsOwnership chain, funding sources and evidence of available capitalIdentifies who controls the firm and whether its funding is credible
Sales begin before projected revenue covers expensesCapital computation, expense projections and available fundingTests continuing capacity to remain above the applicable minimum
A principal will supervise an unfamiliar businessRelevant experience, registration, assigned activities and supervisory proceduresTests whether the principal can recognize and address violations
Customer records will reside with a service providerService arrangements, record access, staffing and continuity proceduresTests whether the firm can preserve and produce records through a disruption
An applicant or associated person has an adverse regulatory historyDisclosure records, eligibility analysis and any proposed heightened supervisionSupports evaluation of public-interest and investor-protection concerns

For each proposed supervisor, Rule 1014 looks for at least one year of direct experience or two years of related experience in the area to be supervised. A principal qualification exam establishes tested knowledge. The application also has to support the person's ability to supervise the particular activity, including from the proposed location and with the proposed workload. Written supervisory procedures should assign responsibility for each business line and office. Training, financial controls, facilities, communications systems, recordkeeping and business continuity should fit the same plan.

Minimum net capital under SEC Rule 15c3-1 depends on the firm's activities. A projected opening balance exactly at the minimum leaves no cushion for operating losses. In assessing opening capital, FINRA may consider projected expenses net of revenue for at least 12 months, inventory risk and underwriting commitments. A signed clearing contract addresses one operational dependency; it does not establish capital sufficiency.

The following sequence traces a new application from submission to the decision the firm can rely on.

Submit the application. File Form NMA, the fee and supporting materials under Rule 1013. Reconcile the business plan with Form BD.
Complete the evidentiary record. Supply requested information and participate in the membership interview. Resolve discrepancies such as a proposed activity with no assigned supervisor.
Read the written decision. Under Rule 1014, FINRA may grant, restrict or deny membership. The ordinary decision period is 30 days after the interview or the latest required additional information, whichever is later.
Resolve the terms. Execute the membership agreement following approval. An applicant challenging the decision generally has 25 days after service to request review by the National Adjudicatory Council under Rule 1015.

Rule 1014 also addresses prolonged review. Once 180 days have elapsed after filing without a decision, the applicant can seek an order directing a decision, subject to the rule's provisions for an extension. Passage of 180 days does not admit the firm. A grant limited to introducing accounts authorizes the narrower business, even if the submitted plan also proposed carrying accounts.

Worked case

A start-up has funded 12 months of projected overhead. Its founder wants to solicit customers on day 46 after filing Form BD. The SEC instituted denial proceedings on day 42. FINRA separately granted membership subject to a restriction against holding customer funds. The founder proposes sending every check directly to a clearing broker.

The immediate question is whether solicitation may begin. The SEC acted within its 45-day period by instituting proceedings, so there is no federal grant on these facts. Sending checks to a clearing broker might address the custody restriction, and a year of funding bears on financial capacity. Neither supplies effective SEC registration. The principal holds solicitation and verifies federal status before considering whether the proposed check-handling arrangement satisfies the agreement.

A Which application clock is running?

Identify who must act before counting days. FINRA's deadline to request information differs from the applicant's deadline to supply it. Table 5 gives the ordinary periods under Rules 1013, 1014 and 1017.

Table 5. New and continuing membership application deadlines
EventNew member applicationContinuing membership application
FINRA requests initial additional informationWithin 30 days after filing.Within 30 days after filing.
Applicant answers a request60 days after service of the first request, then 30 days after service of each later request.30 days after each request.
InterviewGenerally by the later of 90 days after filing or 60 days after all requested materials are filed.Discretionary, ordinarily within 30 days after filing the application or requested additional materials.
Written interview noticeOrdinarily at least seven days before interview.Ordinarily at least seven days before interview.
Decision without interview or information requestThe ordinary admission process includes an interview.Within 45 days after filing.
Board action on a proper delay petitionWithin seven days. A good-cause extension may reach 90 days.Within seven days. A good-cause extension may reach 30 days.

Suppose FINRA serves its first information request 20 days after an NMA is filed. The applicant ordinarily has 60 days from service to respond. If the same request concerns a CMA, the applicant ordinarily has 30 days. The parties may agree to a different response period. For a CMA with an interview or additional submissions, the ordinary decision period is 30 days after the interview concludes or additional materials are filed, whichever occurs later.

For a delayed decision, direct the written petition to the FINRA Board of Governors. The Board directs the Department to decide immediately or show good cause for an extension. An applicant that agreed in writing to a later decision date must account for that date before petitioning.

B Financial evidence and acceptance of terms

Check the date on the balance sheet, supporting schedules and net capital computation. For the NMA filing, the figures must be prepared as of a date within the preceding 30 days. For the interview, the ordinary freshness limit is 45 days before the interview unless the parties agree to a longer period. Figures dated 25 days before filing can therefore satisfy the filing test and be stale by the interview.

Under Rule 1014(d), admission is contingent on filing an executed agreement satisfactory to FINRA. A founder can sign the agreement and still request review of a restriction within the review period. The restriction binds successors as well as the applicant. During review it remains effective unless the National Adjudicatory Council, FINRA Board or SEC grants a stay. A buyer evaluating the firm should therefore obtain the agreement and check for an actual stay or final modification.

1.1.1.4 Keep the public record accurate through withdrawal

SEC Rule 15b3-1 requires prompt amendment when information on a registration application becomes inaccurate. FINRA By-Laws, Article IV, Section 1(c), generally sets an outside limit of 30 days after learning the facts or circumstances requiring amendment. The FINRA period shortens to 10 days when the amendment involves statutory disqualification as defined in Exchange Act Section 3(a)(39). Prompt action still matters when a numerical outside limit applies.

Suppose a member learns that a disclosed executive officer has departed. It checks the firm's Form BD schedules and the individual's record separately. One event can require both firm and individual filings. If a replacement investor also acquires control, correcting Form BD addresses disclosure while the acquisition requires a separate Rule 1017 analysis. Annual renewal does not provide an extension for intervening changes.

Match each filing to the record or decision it addresses.

Form BD:
Establishes or updates the firm's registration disclosures.
Form NMA:
Requests initial admission to FINRA.
Form CMA:
Requests review of a covered change at an existing member.
Form BR:
Registers or updates a branch office.
Form U4:
Requests or updates an individual's registration.
Form U5:
Reports termination of an individual's registration.
Form BDW:
Requests withdrawal of the firm's registration in designated jurisdictions.

For withdrawal, distinguish a branch closing, departure of one representative, exit from one state and termination of the entire broker-dealer business. Form BDW accommodates a full or partial withdrawal. Under SEC Rule 15b6-1, federal withdrawal ordinarily takes effect on the 60th day after filing unless the SEC permits earlier effectiveness. Pending proceedings can change that result. A partial withdrawal from one state does not surrender the firm's federal registration. The withdrawing firm must address outstanding customer property and obligations and identify who will maintain required records. Ceasing sales does not erase record-preservation duties.

A Initial inspections and events during an application

SEC Rule 15b2-2 starts the initial inspection periods at SEC registration. The responsible examining self-regulatory organization ordinarily inspects for financial responsibility compliance within six months and for the remaining applicable Exchange Act requirements within 12 months. If it determines the firm has not begun actual operations within six months, it delays inspection until the second six-month period following registration. Opening the first customer account late does not start a new 12-month period.

While an NMA or CMA remains pending, promptly notify FINRA's Department of Member Regulation in writing when an arbitration claim involving the applicant or an associated person is filed, results in an award or becomes unpaid. This duty continues until service of the decision constituting FINRA's final action. A newly filed claim can require notice even when its amount falls below the threshold used to evaluate a proposed sales hire.

1.1.1.5 Classify a transaction before setting the closing date

For an existing member, FINRA Rule 1017 asks what changes hands and what the surviving firm will do. Read the proposed transaction from the perspective of the member, its ultimate owners and the customers whose business will move. A small purchase price does not establish a small regulatory change. A purchaser can acquire a controlling stake for a modest sum or acquire a valuable stream of brokerage business with few tangible assets.

Table 6 distinguishes the transaction tests. Each row can apply independently.

Table 6. Continuing membership application triggers
EventRule 1017 testQualification
Merger with another memberMember merges with memberException if both are NYSE members or the survivor continues as an NYSE member
Acquisition of another memberMember acquires another member directly or indirectlyException if the acquiring member is an NYSE member
Asset transactionAggregate assets acquired or transferred reach 25% of the member's assetsException if seller and acquirer are both NYSE members
Revenue-producing operationTransferred or acquired operation generates at least 25% of member earnings in aggregate over a rolling 36 monthsSame two-party NYSE exception as the asset test
Equity ownership or partnership capitalOne person or entity comes to own or control at least 25%, directly or indirectlyMeasure resulting interest and trace intermediate entities
Material operational changeProposed activity meets Rule 1011's material-change definitionAssess the business itself and any express membership restriction

A holding company's purchase can change indirect ownership of the broker-dealer even if the immediate parent shown on its stock certificate stays the same. The CMA identifies the proposed owners, their percentages and their funding sources for purchase and recapitalization. For an asset transaction, examine transfers in aggregate. Dividing a sale into several agreements does not turn each installment into an unrelated asset base.

FINRA Rule 1011 includes first-time market making, underwriting or acting as a dealer; adding activity that requires a higher minimum net capital level under Rule 15c3-1; and removing or modifying an existing membership restriction. The definition is inclusive. A substantial change in risks or supervision can merit review even outside the named examples. For a restriction, the member presents the circumstances that have changed and explains why they resolve the reason FINRA originally imposed it.

Fig 1 shows how the kind of application governs implementation while FINRA considers it.

Fig 1. Implementation during continuing membership review
Key point: A pending application has different consequences for an ownership closing, an operating change and an existing restriction.
flowchart TD
A[Classify proposed change] --> B[Ownership or control]
A --> C[Existing agreement restriction]
A --> D[Other material operating change]
B --> E[File 30 days ahead]
E --> F[Check interim restrictions]
C --> G[Keep restriction in force]
D --> H[Await decision or agreement]

Under Rule 1017(c), the member files an ownership or control application at least 30 days before the change. It may generally close before final disposition after satisfying the advance filing requirement, subject to applicable conditions and any FINRA interim restrictions. A material operating change generally awaits conclusion of proceedings unless FINRA and the member agree otherwise. An existing restriction continues during review. A transaction with both ownership and operating components needs a separate implementation decision for each.

Worked case

A buyer owns 18% of a member and proposes to buy seven additional percentage points in 20 days. The firm's membership agreement limits it to an introducing business. The buyer wants to begin underwriting as soon as the purchase closes. The same president and clearing firm will remain in place.

The resulting interest is exactly 25%. Rule 1017 measures the resulting stake, so the seven-point size of the purchase does not keep it below the threshold. A filing today leaves only 20 days before closing, ten days short of the required advance period. The firm files a CMA and moves the closing far enough out to meet the 30-day requirement. It then checks for interim conditions and other impediments.

The underwriting launch has its own answer. This is first-time underwriting and conflicts with the existing agreement. The firm presents its supervisory, capital and operating support and requests the needed modification. Even if the ownership transfer can close while review continues, the principal keeps underwriting on hold while the restriction remains effective. Retaining the president does not change the buyer's percentage or the agreement.

A Checkpoint

A member will transfer an operating unit representing 8% of assets. Over the rolling 36-month period, the unit generated 27% of the member's earnings. Neither party belongs to the NYSE. Which conclusion follows?

  1. The transfer qualifies because less than 25% of assets will move.
  2. The firm may use the expansion safe harbor if headcount stays level.
  3. The firm need only update its registration disclosures after closing.
  4. The earnings contribution independently triggers a CMA.
Answer: D. The unit crosses the earnings threshold for the specified period. A uses the correct percentage for assets but stops after testing only one of two independent grounds.

B If an ownership application fails after closing

Rule 1017(m) gives the member three choices if its ownership application lapses or FINRA denies it and all appeals are exhausted or waived. Within 60 days after the applicable event, the member must file a new application and fee, unwind the transaction, or file Form BDW. In a denial case, identify when appeal rights ended before calculating the deadline.

FINRA may shorten the period to protect investors or lengthen it for good cause shown by the member. It gives written notice of the revised period and reasons. Interim restrictions may continue throughout this interval. A buyer that closed while review was pending therefore needs a plan for an adverse final decision.

1.1.1.6 Test ordinary growth against the safe harbor and its exceptions

FINRA IM-1011-1 gives eligible members a presumption for expansion within three measured categories. Read the membership agreement first. An express restriction on the expansion remains binding, and a specified disciplinary finding against the firm or a principal within the preceding five years can remove safe-harbor eligibility. The interpretation defines the relevant violations. An allegation and a finding are different facts.

Table 7 gives the permitted increases for otherwise eligible firms. Apply each category to its own starting count over a rolling 12-month period.

Table 7. Expansion within the FINRA safe harbor
CategoryStarting countPermitted increase
Associated persons involved in sales1 to 1010 people
Associated persons involved in sales11 or moreGreater of 10 people or 30%
Offices, registered or unregistered1 to 53 offices
Offices, registered or unregistered6 or moreGreater of 3 offices or 30%
Markets already made1 to 1010 markets
Markets already made11 or moreGreater of 10 markets or 30%

Count people by function. A sales assistant or cold caller involved in public customer sales belongs in the personnel count even if unregistered. A back-office clerk with no sales involvement falls outside it. Count unregistered offices for this expansion test even though Form BR has a different purpose. The markets category starts at one because becoming a market maker for the first time raises a separate material-change issue. Track increases throughout the period. A January calendar reset can hide growth that occurred the previous November.

Outside the safe harbor, the firm contacts FINRA before implementation to determine whether the expansion requires a CMA. Losing the presumption does not itself establish that every expansion is material. Conversely, staying within the arithmetic limit does not resolve a required risk consultation.

Table 8 identifies facts that can change the answer even for a small deal or a single hire under Rule 1017(a)(6) and (7).

Table 8. Required consultation when an ordinary CMA is otherwise unnecessary
Proposed actionAdditional factRequired response
Acquire or transfer assets or a business lineTransferor or its associated person has a covered pending arbitration claim, unpaid award or unpaid arbitration settlementSeek written materiality consultation before the transaction
Add an associated person involved in salesIncoming person has a covered pending claim, unpaid award or unpaid arbitration settlementSeek written consultation; ordinary growth allowance is unavailable
Add an owner, control person, principal or registered personNatural person has one final criminal matter or two specified risk events within the prior five yearsSeek written consultation unless Rule 9522 relief is required for the same association

Use the defined categories in Rule 1011 to determine whether a pending arbitration claim is covered. The definition distinguishes personnel additions from asset transfers. An informal customer complaint alone does not establish a covered pending arbitration claim. In a required consultation, FINRA can allow the proposal to proceed without a CMA or require an application and approval first. An existing CMA also carries a payment safeguard: if the member or an associated person has an unpaid arbitration award or unpaid arbitration-related settlement at filing, Rule 1017(c)(4) requires the member to demonstrate its ability to satisfy the obligation before effecting the change.

Related subjects include Registration of Personnel, Continuing Education Requirements, and Investigations and Disciplinary Proceedings. The operating evidence behind a membership application connects to Written Supervisory Procedures, Supervisory Controls and Certification, Books and Records and Communications Supervision, AML, Privacy and Cybersecurity, and Outside Activities and Private Securities Transactions.

A Calculate a covered pending arbitration claim

Begin with unresolved, investment-related, consumer-initiated claims filed in any arbitration forum. Under Rule 1011(c), aggregate the maximum compensatory loss claimed for which the relevant party could be liable. Exclude requests for punitive damages, pain and suffering, and attorney fees. Use the full potential liability even if another respondent shares the claim or an insurer is expected to indemnify the respondent.

For a sales hire, compare claims against the person being hired with the hiring member's excess net capital. For an asset or business transfer, compare claims against the transferring member or its associated persons with the transferring member's excess net capital. In either case the claims must exceed the applicable capital figure. Equality falls below the trigger.

A recruit faces two unresolved customer arbitrations seeking $55,000 and $45,000 in compensatory losses, plus $30,000 in punitive damages. The hiring firm has $100,000 of excess net capital. The qualifying total equals $100,000, so these claims alone do not trigger consultation. If the second compensatory demand increases to $46,000, the total reaches $101,000 and clears the threshold. The size of the punitive demand changes neither result.

B Read the disposition on the person's record

A final criminal matter under Rule 1011 includes a conviction, guilty plea or no-contest plea disclosed or required to be disclosed on the applicable uniform registration form. A pending charge alone lacks that disposition. One qualifying criminal matter within five years can trigger consultation. For the separate two-event test, classify each disclosed or reportable event using Table 9.

Table 9. Specified risk events under Rule 1011(p)
Final eventMonetary testOther qualifying sanction
Investment-related, consumer-initiated arbitration award or civil judgment against the named personAt least $15,000.None under this category.
Investment-related, consumer-initiated arbitration or civil settlement naming the personAt least $15,000.None under this category.
Investment-related civil actionAt least $15,000 in total monetary sanctions.Bar, expulsion, revocation or suspension.
Regulatory actionAt least $15,000 in total monetary sanctions.Temporary or permanent bar, expulsion, rescission, revocation or suspension.

Apply the dollar test to each event separately. Two $8,000 customer settlements remain below the threshold even though their sum exceeds $15,000. By contrast, a qualifying $15,000 customer judgment and a separate final regulatory suspension within five years can supply two events even when the suspension carries no fine. For a civil or regulatory action, total the fines, penalties, disgorgement and restitution ordered in that action.

C When an expansion agreement or disciplinary finding controls

An agreement may expressly authorize a larger staged expansion than the published safe harbor. Follow the approved schedule, including its dates and conditions. For example, permission to add ten representatives in the first six months and another ten the following year gives the firm authority for those stages. It cannot accelerate the second group by combining the allowance with an ordinary safe-harbor increase.

For the disciplinary screen, IM-1011-1 recognizes findings by the SEC, a self-regulatory organization or a foreign financial regulatory authority. Table 10 identifies the provisions that can disqualify a member based on its own or a principal's five-year history.

Table 10. Findings that remove the expansion presumption
AuthorityCovered provisions or conduct
Federal securities lawExchange Act Sections 15(b)(4)(E) and 15(c), Securities Act Section 17(a), and applicable implementing rules, including Rules 10b-5 and 15g-1 through 15g-9.
FINRA Rule 2010Unauthorized trading, churning, conversion, material customer misrepresentations or omissions, frontrunning, trading ahead of research reports, or excessive markups.
FINRA Rule 3110Failure to supervise.
Other FINRA provisionsRules 2020, 2111, 2121, 2150, 4330, 5210 and 5230. Corresponding predecessor NASD rules also count.
Municipal Securities Rulemaking BoardRules G-19, G-30 and G-37(b) and (c).
Foreign regulatorA finding under a comparable foreign provision qualifies.

Read the conduct described in a Rule 2010 finding. A principal's finding for churning four years ago removes the presumption. A question stating only that the principal violated Rule 2010 leaves out the detail needed to reach that conclusion.

D Recall check

Answer each question before revealing the filing, period or condition.

Which Form BD schedules distinguish direct ownership from indirect ownership?
Schedule A identifies direct owners and executive officers. Schedule B identifies indirect owners.
What experience does Rule 1014 look for in the subject area assigned to a proposed supervisor?
At least one year of direct experience or two years of related experience.
How long does an applicant generally have to request review of a FINRA membership decision?
25 days after service of the decision.
What change shortens FINRA's ordinary Form BD amendment deadline to 10 days?
An amendment involving statutory disqualification.
What is the ordinary federal effective date for withdrawal?
The 60th day after Form BDW is filed, subject to SEC action or pending proceedings.
COMMON MISTAKE

Common mistakes

Table 11 pairs each plausible answer with the detail that decides the question.

Table 11. Similar facts with different consequences
Tempting choiceWhy it attractsDeciding detail
Allow private-placement solicitationThe offering has a valid exemptionThe outside intermediary receives commission for finding buyers
Use a Form BD amendment aloneThe proposed buyer belongs on an ownership scheduleThe buyer's resulting stake independently triggers membership review
Launch a new desk 30 days after filingThirty days is a familiar CMA intervalThe desk conflicts with an express operating restriction
Use a growth allowance for the first marketThe proposed increase is only one marketThe firm has never made a market before
Close a small asset sale immediatelyThe asset and earnings percentages are both lowThe transferring member owes an unpaid arbitration award
ALGO

Approach

For a proposed launch or transaction, build the principal's decision in this order.

Identify the entity. Establish whether a new firm seeks admission, a member changes its business or only an individual changes firms.
Read the existing authority. Check SEC and state status, FINRA membership terms and any restriction covering the proposed activity.
Measure the actual change. Trace ultimate ownership, aggregate asset transfers, examine the 36-month earnings contribution or measure ordinary expansion over 12 months.
Check exceptions and risk conditions. Apply the transaction-specific NYSE exception, safe-harbor eligibility and any mandatory consultation as relevant.
Separate the filing date from the start date. Identify the required application and amendments, then determine independently when ownership may transfer and operations may begin.
QUIZ

Self-check quiz

Question 1

A consulting company repeatedly negotiates subscriptions for unrelated issuers and receives 4% of each completed sale. All offerings qualify for a private-placement exemption. Which action is most appropriate before its next solicitation?

  1. Determine whether the company's brokerage activity requires registration or qualifies for a separate exemption.
  2. Rely on the issuers' offering exemptions for the company's solicitation.
  3. Classify the company as a dealer because its fee depends on sales.
  4. Apply the issuer-employee safe harbor to the company's outside salesforce solely because the issuers retain it.

Question 2

Using Table 7, an eligible firm began its rolling period with 40 sales personnel and 20 offices. It has added eight sales personnel and five offices. With no departures or closures, which further expansion stays within both allowances?

  1. Five sales personnel and one office
  2. Four sales personnel and two offices
  3. Four sales personnel and one office
  4. Six sales personnel and no offices

Question 3

A member filed its ownership CMA 35 days before a planned purchase that gives the buyer 30% ownership. Review is pending. There is no unpaid award, unpaid settlement, interim restriction or other impediment. Its agreement prohibits underwriting. Which action is permissible?

  1. Begin underwriting while postponing the purchase.
  2. Close the purchase while continuing to observe the underwriting restriction.
  3. Close the purchase and begin underwriting under the new owner.
  4. Replace the pending CMA with an amended Form BD before closing.

Question 4

A member proposes to transfer 6% of its assets. The transferred unit accounts for 9% of the member's earnings over 36 months. The transferor has an unpaid arbitration award. No other ordinary CMA trigger applies. What must occur first?

  1. Approval of a new member application for the transferor
  2. Expiration of the ordinary 30-day ownership filing interval
  3. Closing followed by disclosure of the award in the next annual renewal
  4. A written request to FINRA for a materiality consultation

Question 5

A member discontinues all brokerage business and submits a full Form BDW. No proceedings are pending, and the SEC grants no accelerated effective date. Which instruction should the principal give?

  1. Plan for ordinary federal withdrawal on the 60th day and preserve required records.
  2. Treat the receipt as immediate federal withdrawal and release all records.
  3. Apply the 45-day initial registration period to withdrawal.
  4. Substitute individual Forms U5 for the firm's withdrawal filing.
ANSWERS

Answer key

Question 1 - Answer: A. Repeated solicitation and negotiation for others, paid on completed sales, support broker status. B addresses registration of the offering, C confuses a contingent fee with trading as principal, and D treats an outside firm as issuer personnel.

Question 2 - Answer: C. The allowances are 12 people and six offices. Prior additions leave room for four people and one office. A exceeds the personnel limit by one, B exceeds the office limit by one, and D exceeds the personnel limit by two even though it adds no offices.

Question 3 - Answer: B. The ownership filing preceded closing by more than 30 days, and the facts remove the stated impediments. A violates the operating restriction, C assumes the purchase removes that restriction, and D substitutes disclosure for the required approval process.

Question 4 - Answer: D. The transferor's unpaid award triggers written consultation despite the small transfer. A concerns initial admission, B applies an ownership deadline to an asset transfer, and C would implement the transaction before FINRA determines whether approval is required.

Question 5 - Answer: A. SEC Rule 15b6-1 supplies the ordinary 60-day period, and record-preservation duties continue. B mistakes receipt for effectiveness, C imports the SEC's initial application decision period, and D addresses departing individuals rather than the legal entity.

RAPID

Rapid review

  • Paid to bring buyers to another issuer → analyze broker status even in a private offering.
  • Initial federal filing → 45 days for an SEC grant or institution of proceedings, absent an agreed extension.
  • New member versus existing member → Form NMA for admission; Form CMA for a covered change.
  • Form BD becomes inaccurate → amend promptly; FINRA generally allows at most 30 days, or 10 for statutory disqualification.
  • Resulting direct or indirect ownership reaches 25% → file the ownership CMA at least 30 days before the change.
  • Business line has few assets → test its earnings contribution over a rolling 36 months.
  • Existing restriction under review → continue observing it.
  • Growth in people, offices or markets → use separate rolling 12-month allowances and check eligibility.
  • Unpaid arbitration award in a small transfer → assess mandatory consultation before implementation.
  • Full federal withdrawal → ordinary effectiveness on day 60; retain required records.
  • First information request → ordinarily allow 60 days to answer an NMA request and 30 days to answer a CMA request.
  • CMA with no interview or additional information request → written decision within 45 days after filing.
  • Sales hire with pending arbitrations → compare aggregate compensatory exposure with the hiring firm's excess net capital.
  • Two customer settlements → test each separately against $15,000 before counting risk events.
  • Ownership application lapses or denial becomes final → ordinarily reapply, unwind or file Form BDW within 60 days.

References

  • General Securities Principal Qualification Examination (Series 24) Content Outline. Financial Industry Regulatory Authority.
  • Securities Exchange Act of 1934. United States Congress, 1934, as amended.
  • General Rules and Regulations, Securities Exchange Act of 1934, 17 CFR Part 240. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
  • FINRA Rulebook, Membership Application and Associated Person Registration Rules, including the Rule 1000 Series and IM-1011-1. Financial Industry Regulatory Authority.
  • By-Laws of the Corporation, Article IV, Membership. Financial Industry Regulatory Authority.
End of your free lesson

Keep going with the full Series 24 General Securities Principal Exam Prep Course

You just studied the way members do, in the same lesson interface. Full access unlocks every lesson, the question bank and flashcards for a full year.

Up next with full access1.1.2 - Registration of Personnel

One payment per program