Skip to content
Free previewYou are reading 1 of 24 lessons, in the same interface members use. Everything else unlocks with full access.Get full access · $150

What you'll learn

  • Translate a customer's price, timing and quantity instructions into an executable order.
  • Use quotes, trades and available size to determine which shares can fill and at what price.
  • Track an order through activation, partial execution, cancellation and replacement.
  • Distinguish best execution, customer priority and limit-order display in a trading-desk scenario.

Estimated reading time: 19 minutes.

WHY

Why it matters

A customer says, 'Sell if it falls to $40,' and later asks why the execution report says $38.50. Whether the desk followed instructions depends on what the customer authorized after the trigger. Series 57 questions often turn on a similarly small distinction between the event that activates an order, the prices it permits and the firm's duty while it holds the order.

KEY TERMS

Key terms

Inside market
The highest bid and lowest offer in the market being described. The national best bid and offer, or NBBO, identifies the national best quoted prices for an NMS stock.
Displayed size
The quantity advertised at a quoted price. A quote snapshot can change before an order arrives.
Marketable limit
A limit order priced to trade against an available opposite-side quote.
Elected
Activated by the event specified in a conditional order.
Leaves quantity
The unexecuted quantity still open after accounting for fills and cancellations.
Principal trade
A transaction for the broker-dealer's own account. In an agency transaction the firm acts for another party.
CORE

Core content

1.1.1.1 Price instructions determine which shares can trade

A market order seeks execution against available trading interest. A buyer takes offers, beginning with the lowest available price. A seller takes bids, beginning with the highest. The last sale tells you where two parties previously traded. It supplies neither today's available quantity nor a commitment to execute another order there. During a halt, even a market order can wait.

A limit gives the desk a boundary in dollars per share. A customer willing to pay up to $25.10 can receive $25.04. A seller asking at least $25.10 can receive $25.16. The difference matters when the limit crosses the spread: the order can trade immediately and still retain protection for shares that cannot fill at an acceptable price.

Table 1 gives an executable book for the examples. Sizes are shares, all quotes are accessible, and no other interest enters or leaves during each independent example.

Table 1. Available interest in stock JKL
Bid priceShares bidOffer priceShares offered
$24.98400$25.02200
$24.95600$25.05300
$24.90800$25.11500

Once a limit rests, queue position matters. At a venue using price-time priority, better-priced displayed orders rank first, and earlier displayed orders generally lead at the same price within the same priority class. A trade at your customer's price could exhaust only the shares ahead. A print on another venue also does not establish that the customer's venue received executable contra-side interest.

Worked case

A customer buys 500 JKL at market against Table 1. The last trade was $25.00. The first 200 shares cost $5,004 and the next 300 cost $7,515. The total is $12,519 before fees. Divide by 500 executed shares to obtain $25.038 per share. That answer lies between the two execution prices and closer to $25.05, where more shares traded. The historical print contributes zero shares to the calculation.

For fills indexed by \(i\), let \(q_i\) be shares filled, \(p_i\) be execution price in dollars per share and \(\bar p\) be the average in dollars per share. The formula is \[\bar p=\frac{\sum_i q_i p_i}{\sum_i q_i}.\] Use executed shares in the denominator even when the original ticket was larger.

Fig 1 shows how the average changes as more of this 500-share execution occurs at the higher price.

Fig 1. Average price across two fills
Key point: Moving shares to the higher price raises the average in proportion to their share of the execution.
{"x":{"label":"Shares at higher price","min":0,"max":500,"step":1},"y":{"label":"Average price ($/share)","min":25.01,"max":25.11},"curves":[{"label":"Average execution price","expr":"((500-x)*25.02+x*h)/500"}],"sliders":[{"name":"h","label":"Higher fill price ($/share)","min":25.03,"max":25.1,"step":0.01,"value":25.05}],"readouts":[{"label":"Average with 300 shares at higher price ($/share)","expr":"(200*25.02+300*h)/500","digits":3}],"try":"Predict how the average changes for the 300-share second fill, then raise its price from $25.05 to $25.08 to check.","say":"The average rises along a straight line as more shares fill at the higher price. Raising that price makes the line steeper.","prompt":"a live graph of average price ($/share) against shares at higher price. The curve shows average execution price. The average rises along a straight line as more shares fill at the higher price. Raising that price makes the line steeper. On the page, a slider changes the higher fill price ($/share), and the curve redraws as it moves. It also displays average with 300 shares at higher price ($/share). Try this: Predict how the average changes for the 300-share second fill, then raise its price from $25.05 to $25.08 to check."}

A Checkpoint

Using Table 1, a day limit order to buy 650 shares at $25.06 arrives. What is its status immediately after all eligible offers trade?

  1. 500 filled, 150 resting at $25.06
  2. 650 filled, including 150 at $25.11
  3. 200 filled, 450 resting at $25.02
  4. 500 filled, 150 automatically canceled
Answer: A. Both the 200-share and 300-share offers qualify. The remaining 150 retain the customer's limit. D would require an immediate-or-cancel instruction or another reason to cancel.

B Reserve orders: reconcile displayed size with total shares open

A customer offers 2,400 shares at $36 and instructs the venue to display 300 shares at a time. A reserve order, also called an iceberg order, lets the venue advertise 300 and hold 2,100 undisplayed. Another trader seeing 300 offered can establish how many shares are quoted. The quote alone cannot establish the seller's total available interest.

Suppose 300 shares execute and the venue replenishes the display to 300. Table 2 follows this customer's shares through both events, assuming no other fills or cancellations.

Table 2. Share counts before and after a reserve refresh
Order stateDisplayed sharesReserve sharesTotal shares open
Accepted3002,1002,400
First slice executed, before refresh02,1002,100
Display replenished3001,8002,100

Read the Total shares open column to answer a cancellation question. Canceling the remaining order after refresh withdraws all 2,100 shares, including the 1,800 still hidden. Read the venue's priority rule separately before assigning a refreshed slice its place among other sellers at $36.

C Pegged orders: identify which quotation moves the order

A peg gives the venue a reference for repricing an active order. Start with the side of the order and the named quotation. Then apply any offset in the direction specified. Table 3 uses a national best bid of $24.90 and a national best offer of $25.10, with no offset, before applying any limit or venue-specific pricing restriction.

Table 3. Reference prices for three peg instructions
InstructionReferenceBuy reference priceSell reference price
Primary pegSame-side best quote$24.90 bid$25.10 offer
Market pegOpposite-side best quote$25.10 offer$24.90 bid
Midpoint pegHalfway between bid and offer$25.00$25.00

Primary peg. A buyer wants to join the best bid as it changes. If the bid rises to $24.94 while the offer stays at $25.10, the primary buy reference rises four cents. The primary sell reference stays at $25.10. An instruction to buy one cent above the primary reference would now indicate $24.95, subject to the ticket's ceiling and venue rules.

Market peg. A buyer instead specifies two cents below the best offer. With the offer at $25.10, the indicated buy price is $25.08. A move in the bid alone leaves that calculation unchanged. If the offer falls to $25.04, the indicated price becomes $25.02. The word market in the peg's name identifies a quotation relationship; the offset can leave the order resting inside the spread.

Midpoint peg with a limit. A customer authorizes a midpoint-only buy up to $25.02. At $24.90 bid and $25.10 offered, the midpoint is $25.00 and satisfies the ceiling. If the bid rises to $24.98 with the offer unchanged, the midpoint becomes $25.04. The order cannot execute at that midpoint. Nor can the desk simply buy at $25.02 under a midpoint-only instruction. Execution can become possible again if the midpoint returns to an authorized price while the order remains live.

1.1.1.2 A trigger determines when the execution instruction starts

Under FINRA Rule 5350, a conventional buy stop is elected by a transaction at or above its stop price, and a conventional sell stop by a transaction at or below its stop price. For an ordinary stop, the activated instruction is a market order. A qualifying trade can jump over the trigger: a decline from $41 to $38 crosses a $40 sell stop. The sale that elected it may already have consumed the bid on which it traded.

A stop-limit has two fields. The stop price controls activation, and the limit price constrains every subsequent fill. A sell stop at $40 with a $39.50 limit may sell at $39.50 or higher after election. If the best available bid is $38, the activated order can remain open. If the bid later recovers to $39.75 while the order is live, the order is eligible without another stop event.

Fig 2 follows the same sell instruction through both possible order types.

Fig 2. Sell order after a price gap
Key point: A transaction through the trigger activates both orders, but only the stop-limit retains a price floor.
flowchart TD
A[Trade at or below stop] --> B{Activated order type}
B -->|Stop| C[Seek available bids]
B -->|Stop-limit| D{Bid meets floor}
D -->|Yes| E[Execute eligible shares]
D -->|No| F[Await qualifying bid]

A firm may offer a conditional order triggered by a quote or another event. FINRA Rule 5350 requires a distinguishable name and advance disclosure of the triggering event for such alternatives. A falling bid alone therefore has different consequences depending on the actual instruction. Table 4 distinguishes common conditional choices by the move the customer wants to capture.

Table 4. Conditional instructions with stock trading at $50
Customer objectiveInstructionEffect of the specified move
Reduce exposure on a long position during a declineSell stop at $47A trade at $47 or lower activates a market sale.
Cover a short position during a riseBuy stop at $53A trade at $53 or above activates a market purchase.
Enter on a breakout with a price ceilingBuy stop $53, limit $53.25After activation, purchases are eligible through $53.25.
Buy on a dip, accepting the price available after activationBuy market-if-touched at $47, where offeredA decline to the specified trigger releases a market buy.
Sell on a rally, accepting the price available after activationSell market-if-touched at $53, where offeredA rise to the specified trigger releases a market sell.

A trailing stop moves the activation level with favorable changes. Consider a sell stop trailing a stated reference price by $2. From $50 the initial trigger is $48. When the reference rises to $55, the trigger rises to $53. A retreat to $54 leaves the trigger at $53. A trailing buy stop works in the opposite direction: a new low can lower its trigger. Verify the reference price, dollar or percentage trail, activation convention and eligible session for the specific instruction.

A Checkpoint

A short seller enters a conventional buy stop at $53. The offer rises to $53.10 while the latest transaction remains $52.95. The next transaction is $53.20. Which event activates the order?

  1. The first offer above $53
  2. The transaction at $53.20
  3. A subsequent trade at exactly $53
  4. A subsequent offer at or below $53
Answer: B. The $53.20 transaction meets the at-or-above test. The $53.10 offer might trigger a separately defined quote-based order, but the customer entered a conventional stop.

1.1.1.3 Duration and quantity qualify the price instruction

Read a ticket as a set of conditions that must hold together. A price can be acceptable even though the available size is too small, the eligible auction has passed or the order has expired. Table 5 applies different instructions to the same order to buy 1,000 shares at a $30 limit when only 600 shares are available at an acceptable price.

Table 5. Quantity and duration with a 600-share opportunity
InstructionImmediate resultWhat can happen later
DayBuy 600 if available.Remaining 400 may fill until the applicable session ends.
Good-till-canceled (GTC)Buy 600 if available.Balance can carry forward until filled, canceled or expired under firm policy.
Immediate-or-cancel (IOC)Buy 600 and cancel 400.No balance carries forward.
Fill-or-kill (FOK)Cancel all 1,000 because full immediate execution is unavailable.No balance carries forward.
All-or-none (AON), dayKeep all 1,000 open.Fill the entire quantity when available or expire at session end.

Regular-session eligibility does not automatically extend into after-hours trading. A customer entering a day order late in the afternoon may have only minutes of eligibility. For GTC orders, the firm's stated maximum life matters. Do not infer a universal 30-, 60- or 90-day expiration from the letters GTC.

An auction instruction adds a different restriction. Market-on-open and market-on-close orders seek execution in the designated opening or closing auction. Limit-on-open and limit-on-close orders also require an acceptable auction price. A buy limit-on-close at $30 is price-eligible if the closing auction clears at $29.98. At $30.02 it cannot participate. An auction-only balance expires or is canceled under the venue's rules. Entry, modification and cancellation cutoffs depend on the exchange and auction.

Match each customer's instruction to the handling of an otherwise acceptable partial fill.

Immediate-or-cancel:
Take the available portion now and discard the balance.
Fill-or-kill:
Discard the whole ticket if any shares would have to wait.
All-or-none, day:
Wait within the session for enough shares to complete the ticket together.
Unrestricted day limit:
Accept available shares and work the balance until the session expires.

A Read the expiration and the eligible session separately

Good-till-date (GTD). A customer wants a $28 buy limit to remain available across several sessions and expire on Friday. A GTD instruction, where offered, specifies that endpoint at entry. If 400 of 1,000 shares have executed by the stated expiration, the remaining 600 expire. The completed 400-share purchase stands. The ticket's session terms determine when the order can trade before Friday's cutoff.

Extended-hours protection. Normal market hours under Rule 5320 are generally 9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Eastern time. If the firm and customer agree to process the order outside those hours, protection follows the order whenever the firm can execute it. At 4:15 p.m., a proprietary purchase can therefore trigger a customer entitlement on an eligible extended-hours buy. A regular-hours-only GTC order awaiting the next session has a different status at the same moment.

1.1.1.4 The ticket preserves authority as order status changes

A held order calls for prompt handling consistent with its conditions. A not-held instruction lets the trader exercise judgment over time and price while working the specified order. The customer can still impose an outside limit. Permission to work a purchase of 2,000 XYZ at or below $31 gives the trader latitude over when and how much of that order to execute at a time. It confers no authority to substitute another security, change the side or exceed the authorized amount.

Discretionary authority. Under FINRA Rule 3260, time and price discretion for a definite amount of a specified security ordinarily lasts only through the business day on which it was granted. A specific signed and dated written customer instruction can provide otherwise. A separate exception covers qualifying institutional-account orders given on a not-held basis under valid GTC instructions. Broader discretionary trading requires prior written customer authorization and written firm acceptance by the designated person.

Under Exchange Act Rule 17a-3(a)(6), a brokerage order memorandum captures the account, terms and conditions, modifications or cancellations, receipt and entry times, execution price and applicable execution or cancellation times, with the required personnel identifiers. An unexecuted order still has a history. Reliable timestamps distinguish a request received before a trade from a cancellation that actually became effective before the trade.

Fig 3 follows a cancel-and-replace request when an execution report arrives while cancellation is pending.

Fig 3. Reconciling a replacement quantity
Key point: Shares executed before effective cancellation count toward the customer's intended total.
Read the original instruction. The customer wants 1,000 shares in total. An initial report confirms 300 bought.
Request the change. The customer raises the limit on the remaining shares. The original order shows 700 open while cancellation is pending.
Account for an intervening fill. Another 200 shares execute before cancellation takes effect. Cumulative executions reach 500.
Reconcile the acknowledgment. Once the outstanding balance is confirmed canceled, a replacement for 500 shares completes the intended total if filled.

A replacement can affect queue position. Under ordinary price-time matching, changing the price or increasing displayed size generally receives a new priority time. A size reduction alone can preserve priority under venue rules. A customer moving a buy limit from $31 to $31.05 may improve price rank while joining behind older eligible orders already bid at $31.05.

An open order may also change without a fresh trading decision. FINRA Rule 5330 governs adjustments to covered open orders for distributions. Table 6 applies an ordinary $0.40 cash dividend to open orders in the rule's scope on the ex-dividend date. Assume no contrary instruction or other exception.

Table 6. Cash-dividend treatment of open orders
Original orderPrice after adjustmentReason
Buy limit at $36.00$35.60The open buy is subject to reduction.
Sell stop at $34.00$33.60Reduction accounts for the distribution-related price change.
Sell limit at $40.00$40.00An open sell limit is outside this cash-reduction category.
Buy stop at $41.00$41.00Open stop orders to buy are excepted.

A do-not-reduce instruction preserves the price where permitted. A stock split raises a separate issue because shares per position change. In a two-for-one split, a covered open buy for 100 shares at $60 ordinarily adjusts to 200 at $30. Do-not-increase concerns the size adjustment. Reverse splits require cancellation of covered open orders under Rule 5330. Orders governed by exchange rules must be handled under the applicable venue provision.

A Cash distributions at the one-cent threshold

Apply the threshold to the distribution per share before using the tick size. A $0.009 cash distribution leaves a covered $20 buy limit unchanged under Rule 5330, even on a 10,000-share ticket. A distribution of exactly $0.01 reaches the threshold. With one-cent quotation increments and no contrary instruction, that same limit becomes $19.99.

For a distribution above the threshold, subtract the full distribution before rounding. Suppose the open buy limit is $20, the cash dividend is $0.025, and the applicable minimum quotation variation is $0.01. Subtraction gives $19.975. Round the resulting order price down to $19.97. Rounding to the nearest cent would produce $19.98 and authorize a purchase above the prescribed adjusted price.

1.1.1.5 Best execution depends on the order and the accessible markets

FINRA Rule 5310 requires reasonable diligence to ascertain the best market for the security and to buy or sell so that the resulting price to the customer is as favorable as possible under prevailing market conditions. The duty applies when acting as agent or principal, including transactions for a customer of another broker-dealer. The assessment uses information reasonably available when handling the order. A later price change alone cannot establish whether the original routing decision was sound.

Table 7 translates the five express factors into evidence a trader can use when comparing destinations.

Table 7. Best-market inquiry under FINRA Rule 5310
FactorQuestion for this orderIllustrative consequence
Character of the marketHow volatile, liquid and price-transparent is this security?Thin trading makes a stale last sale a weak indication of available price.
Size and type of transactionCan the destination execute the requested quantity and conditions?A 100-share quote may cover little of a 5,000-share order.
Number of markets checkedWhat competing sources of liquidity were considered?A single habitual destination may overlook recurring price improvement.
Accessibility of quotationsCan the firm actually access the quoted interest?A nominal price with no accessible size cannot supply the assumed fill.
Customer's terms and conditionsWhat limits, auction, size or routing conditions did the customer impose?A continuous-market fill cannot satisfy an auction-only instruction.

For covered routing arrangements, a firm that does not conduct an order-by-order review must perform a regular and rigorous execution-quality review at least quarterly, and more often when warranted. Compare current destinations with competing markets by security and order type. Price improvement, price disimprovement, likelihood of execution, speed, size, transaction costs and customer needs can reveal different strengths for marketable and resting orders. Material differences call for a routing change or a documented justification for continuing the arrangement.

A fill at the NBBO can still deserve scrutiny when a competing venue regularly supplies accessible price improvement. A routing rebate benefits the firm and cannot justify inferior customer execution. Likewise, compliance with Regulation NMS Rule 611 on protected quotations addresses a distinct trade-through issue. It does not settle the broader best-execution inquiry.

Customer-directed routing. When the customer gives an unsolicited instruction naming a particular market, Rule 5310 does not require the originating member to determine the best market beyond that direction. The firm still processes the order promptly and according to its terms. A broker-dealer receiving the directed order for handling has its own applicable best-execution duties. A customer's price limit alone does not designate a market.

A Justify an intermediary and document a thin-market search

Interpositioning. An introducing desk can reach a seller directly at $15.20. An affiliate proposes to buy those shares and resell them to the desk at $15.24, with the same size, speed and likelihood of execution. The extra four cents per share buys the customer no execution benefit. Rule 5310 prohibits inserting an intermediary on those facts. If a third party provides access to liquidity the desk otherwise cannot reach, assess the price and execution actually available through that route.

Limited quotation information. When pricing is unclear or quotations are limited, apply the firm's written procedures for identifying available price information and document the inquiry. For example, consider relevant recent trades, seek current indications from dealers that handle the security, and assess the size each can actually deliver. A record identifying the dealer, time, price and executable quantity explains why the desk selected a particular bid for the customer's sale.

1.1.1.6 Customer priority and public display answer different questions

FINRA Rule 5320 addresses a firm that accepts and holds a customer equity order and trades for its own account on the same side at a price that would satisfy the order. Both accounts buying is the same side. Both selling is also the same side. If a proprietary buy at $19.98 would satisfy a customer's $20 buy limit, the firm generally must immediately execute the customer order up to the proprietary quantity at $19.98 or better, unless an applicable exception permits different handling.

A dealer selling shares from inventory directly to a customer who wants to buy is on the opposite side. That capacity raises execution-quality and fair-pricing questions. The fact that the firm used inventory alone does not establish a same-side trade ahead. Conversely, a stock bought for inventory while the desk holds an executable customer buy is precisely the pattern that warrants the priority analysis.

Worked case

A retail customer has 800 shares left on a held buy limit at $40.10. The desk knows of the order and buys 300 shares of the same stock for inventory at $40.04. The last public sale was $40.12. No exception applies. Both instructions are buys, and $40.04 falls inside the customer's ceiling. The firm must immediately execute 300 customer shares at $40.04 or lower. That leaves 500 shares open. A fill at $40.10 would respect the limit while withholding the better proprietary price. Filling all 800 immediately is unnecessary on these facts because the proprietary trade covered only 300.

Rule 5320 has specific exceptions. For example, the large-order provision can apply to a qualifying institutional account or to an order of at least 10,000 shares unless that order is worth less than $100,000. The firm must satisfy the applicable disclosure and customer-choice conditions. A customer can elect protection. A separate no-knowledge exception depends on an effective system of internal controls, including appropriate information barriers, and satisfaction of applicable disclosure requirements. Different desk names alone establish neither independence nor lack of knowledge.

Display concerns the quote shown to the market. FINRA Rule 6460 applies to OTC market makers in OTC equity securities. An eligible customer limit that improves the market maker's own quote generally must be displayed immediately. At the market maker's existing price, a qualifying size increase can also require display when the market maker is at the best interdealer price. For NMS stocks, the corresponding exchange-specialist and OTC-market-maker display framework is Regulation NMS Rule 604. Determine the security and the firm's role before choosing the rule.

Table 8 separates the decisions a single incoming order can require.

Table 8. Three decisions for a held customer buy limit
EventApplicable inquiryConsequence on the stated facts
OTC market maker receives an eligible $12.05 bid above its $12.00 bid.Customer limit-order displayReflect the improved bid immediately unless an exception applies.
Customer expressly requests that the eligible order remain undisplayed.Exception to public displayHonor the display instruction while continuing to protect and handle the order.
Firm knowingly buys for inventory at $12.03 while holding that $12.05 bid.Trading aheadAbsent an exception, immediately provide the prescribed customer execution.
Two accessible venues offer different execution opportunities.Best executionAssess the routes in light of the customer order and prevailing conditions.

Orders executed immediately upon receipt, odd-lot orders and all-or-none orders are among the Rule 6460 display exceptions. An immediately executed order leaves no resting interest for the market maker to advertise. A customer request for nondisplay concerns publication only. Treat confidentiality, authority to trade ahead and discretion over routing as distinct instructions.

See also. Trading Ahead and Customer Order Protection develops the Rule 5320 exceptions. Market Making and Quotation Obligations and Regulation NMS and Exchange Rules develop display and protected quotations. Manipulative and Prohibited Trading Conduct addresses orders entered to create a misleading appearance of interest. Trading During Offerings and Short Sales and Regulation SHO add restrictions that depend on the transaction. Markups, Markdowns and Fair Prices addresses dealer compensation. Options, ETFs and Other Products on the Desk applies handling decisions to other products.

A Crossing a marketable order already on hand

A firm still holds a marketable buy for 700 shares when it receives a compatible customer sell for 300. Rule 5320.07 requires every effort to cross the available quantity. Use the best bid and offer when the later order arrives and respect both customers' limits. If the market then stands at $19.98 bid and $20.02 offered, the buyer permits up to $20.02, and the seller requires at least $20, a 300-share cross at $20.01 qualifies. The buyer has 400 shares left. The same-price cross can also be effected by contemporaneously buying from the seller and selling to the buyer.

B Large-order consent and block-size display

A desk invoking the large-order trading-ahead exception must establish how it obtained authority. Under the written route, disclose the trading practice at account opening and annually thereafter, and give the customer a meaningful opportunity to elect protection for all or part of an order. Under the order-by-order route, clearly explain the handling orally, obtain consent for that order and document who consented in a way that shows the customer's understanding. A ticket marked 'institutional' establishes neither disclosure nor consent.

Table 9 separates three thresholds that answer different questions about the same incoming limit order.

Table 9. Size tests for priority and public display
QuestionSize testHandling consequence
Does a noninstitutional order qualify by size for Rule 5320's large-order provision?At least 10,000 shares and at least $100,000 in value.Check disclosure and customer choice before proprietary trading.
Does an OTC order qualify for the block-size display exception?At least 10,000 shares or at least $100,000 in aggregate market value.The exception permits nondisplay unless the customer requests display.
Is an OTC size increase de minimis at the existing best interdealer price?The increase is 10% or less of the market maker's displayed size.A de minimis size change alone does not require a quote update.

Consider an OTC retail order for 12,000 shares worth $72,000. Its share count meets the block-size display test. Its value falls short of the separate trading-ahead test. For a size-only question, use shares already displayed as the denominator: an additional 200 shares on a displayed bid of 2,000 are exactly 10%. An additional 300 are 15% and exceed the de minimis allowance, assuming the price and other display conditions are met.

C Recall check

Give the specific handling consequence for each instruction or event.

What price boundary survives election of a sell stop-limit?
The sell limit remains the minimum acceptable price per share.
What ordinarily ends an unextended retail grant of time and price discretion?
The end of the business day on which the discretion was granted.
Which quantity belongs in the denominator of an average fill price?
The total shares actually executed in the fills being averaged.
What is the minimum review frequency when a regular and rigorous routing review is permitted in place of order-by-order review?
At least quarterly, with more frequent review when warranted.
What does a customer's express nondisplay instruction change?
It can exempt the order from public display. Customer priority and best execution still require separate assessment.
COMMON MISTAKE

Common mistakes

Table 10 pairs each attractive answer with the detail that changes the result.

Table 10. Closely competing answers
Tempting answerWhy it sounds plausibleDeciding detail
Guarantee the stop price.The customer named a dollar figure.The activated instruction is a market sale.
Cancel an AON immediately.The available size is insufficient.Only an immediate-execution condition ends its opportunity now.
Replace the entire original ticket.The customer changed only its price.Cumulative fills already satisfy part of the intended total.
Use the customer's limit for a required priority fill.That price is acceptable on the ticket.A better proprietary execution establishes the customer entitlement.
Infer a directed order from use of a preferred venue.The ticket identifies a destination.Who selected it determines whether the unsolicited customer-direction provision applies.
ALGO

Approach

Fig 4 gives the order in which to resolve a ticket that combines a trigger, price protection and an immediate-execution instruction.

Fig 4. Reading a conditional ticket from entry to disposition
Key point: Apply the trigger before testing executable price and apply the quantity instruction before assigning a final status.
Establish eligibility. Identify the active session, remaining quantity and qualifying trigger event. A dormant stop has no executable balance in the book.
Read the activated terms. For a limit buy, select offers at or below the ceiling. For a limit sell, select bids at or above the floor.
Apply the quantity instruction. For IOC, take immediately available eligible shares. For FOK, verify immediate availability of the full amount.
Assign the disposition. Record executions at actual fill prices and cancel any IOC remainder. An eligible day balance without an immediate condition may continue working.
QUIZ

Self-check quiz

1. Using Table 1, a customer sells 700 JKL with a $24.95 IOC limit. What execution report follows?

  1. 400 at $24.98, with 300 canceled
  2. 700 at $24.95
  3. 400 at $24.98 and 300 at $24.95
  4. 700 canceled because no single bid takes the entire order

2. A day sell stop-limit has a $42 stop and a $41.75 limit. The first qualifying trade is $41.20, and the best available bid is $41.15. What should the desk do?

  1. Sell against the $41.15 bid.
  2. Wait for a trade back at $42 before activating the order.
  3. Cancel the ticket because the trade skipped the limit.
  4. Maintain an activated sell limit at $41.75.

3. A customer raises the limit on a purchase intended to total 900 shares. The first report shows 250 bought. Another 150 execute before the outstanding balance is confirmed canceled. How many shares belong on the replacement?

  1. 500 shares
  2. 650 shares
  3. 750 shares
  4. 900 shares

4. A firm routinely routes retail orders to a venue that pays it for order flow. Its permitted quarterly review finds that an accessible competitor consistently delivers better prices with comparable speed, size and fill rates. Customers gave no routing directions. What is the most appropriate response?

  1. Retain the route solely because the current venue executes at the NBBO.
  2. Change the route or document a customer-execution justification for retaining it.
  3. Treat customer acknowledgment of payment disclosure as venue direction.
  4. Retain the route solely because its payments offset the firm's operating costs.

5. A desk holds a retail customer's sell limit for 700 shares at $18.30. The desk knowingly sells 200 shares of the same stock for inventory at $18.36. No exception applies. Which action satisfies the immediate Rule 5320 obligation?

  1. Sell 200 customer shares at $18.30.
  2. Sell all 700 customer shares at $18.30.
  3. Sell 200 customer shares at $18.36 or higher.
  4. Wait until the desk next buys shares for inventory.
ANSWERS

Answer key

Question 1 - Answer: C. Both bids meet the seller's floor. The first supplies 400 shares and the second supplies the remaining 300. A overlooks the eligible second bid, B discards the better bid, and D imposes a single-bid requirement absent from the ticket.

Question 2 - Answer: D. The downside trade elects the order, and the $41.75 floor remains in force. A breaches the floor, B requires an exact-price print, and C assumes a gap cancels a day order.

Question 3 - Answer: A. Confirmed purchases total 400 shares, leaving 500 of the intended 900. B counts only the first fill, C counts only the second, and D disregards both.

Question 4 - Answer: B. Material execution-quality differences require action or a documented basis for continuing the arrangement consistent with best execution. A treats the NBBO as conclusive, C substitutes disclosure for a customer instruction, and D gives the firm's revenue priority over customer execution.

Question 5 - Answer: C. The same-side proprietary sale satisfies the customer's limit and establishes a 200-share entitlement at the proprietary price or better. A gives the seller an inferior price, B also uses the wrong price and overstates the required quantity, and D waits for an opposite-side event.

RAPID

Rapid review

  • Market buy → read available offers and their sizes.
  • Marketable limit → trade eligible shares while preserving the customer's boundary.
  • Conventional stop → a qualifying transaction releases the next instruction.
  • IOC versus FOK → only IOC accepts an immediate partial fill.
  • AON → full quantity required, with waiting permitted during the order's life.
  • Pending cancellation → count intervening executions before replacing shares.
  • Best-market inquiry → assess accessible execution opportunities in light of customer terms.
  • Same-side proprietary fill → test customer entitlement using the firm's price and quantity.
  • Express nondisplay → evaluate priority and routing separately.
  • Reserve refresh → move shares from hidden to displayed and preserve the outstanding total.
  • Primary, market, midpoint → follow the same side, the opposite side, or halfway between.
  • Cash distribution below one cent per share → leave the covered open-order price unchanged.
  • Later compatible order → use the inside market at its arrival to test a cross.
  • OTC block display versus large-order priority → distinguish an either-threshold test from a both-thresholds test.

References

  • Securities Trader Representative Qualification Examination (Series 57) Content Outline. FINRA.
  • FINRA Rulebook, Rules 3260, 5310, 5320, 5330, 5350 and 6460. FINRA.
  • Regulation NMS, Rules 604 and 611. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
  • Exchange Act Rule 17a-3, Records to Be Made by Certain Exchange Members, Brokers and Dealers. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
End of your free lesson

Keep going with the full Series 57 Securities Trader Representative Exam Prep Course

You just studied the way members do, in the same lesson interface. Full access unlocks every lesson, the question bank and flashcards for a full year.

Up next with full access1.1.2 - Manipulative and Prohibited Trading Conduct

One payment per program