1.1.1 - Financial Information Source Selection
What you'll learn
- Select evidence for a reported result, forecast, market price or transaction term.
- Determine which version of a figure was available on a specified date.
- Explain differences in period, units, business scope and financial definitions.
- Build a source record another banker can reproduce and recognize when a discrepancy remains open.
Estimated reading time: 15 minutes.
Why it matters
An earnings release, a financial database and an annual report can give three defensible answers to a question labeled simply 'sales.' A banker preparing a valuation exhibit, and a candidate choosing an answer on the Series 79, must establish whose sales, for which period, on what basis and as known on which date.
Key terms
- Primary source
- Evidence from the party that made the statement, measured the result or entered into the agreement.
- Point-in-time data
- A version of an observation that preserves what was available at a particular cutoff.
- As reported
- A value on the issuer's own presentation basis. For revised periods, specify the document version as well.
- Standardized data
- Values a provider maps into common fields so users can compare companies.
- Consensus estimate
- A provider's aggregation of contributing analysts' forecasts for a specified metric and period.
- Reporting perimeter
- The entities or operations included in a figure, such as a consolidated parent, a segment or a business being sold.
- Source trail
- The evidence and calculation details needed to reproduce a number as it appears in the deliverable.
Core content
1.1.1.1 Match the source to the claim
Start with a sentence someone could verify. 'The board needs an EBITDA number' leaves open whether the board wants last year's earnings, management's forecast or the measure defined in a credit agreement. 'The board needs the EBITDA definition used to test the borrower's covenant at year-end' points to the operative credit agreement, including applicable amendments. An audited income statement supplies some inputs. It cannot establish which contractual adjustments the lenders agreed to accept.
A primary source is authoritative for a particular claim. Management can state what it expects to earn. An analyst can state what that analyst expects the company to earn. Neither party alone establishes consensus. Likewise, a stock exchange or an appropriate market-data feed can supply evidence for a closing price even when the issuer's latest financial statements are months old. Table 1 pairs each assignment with a starting document and the detail that makes it usable.
| Assignment | Start here | Inspect before use |
|---|---|---|
| Historical annual revenue | Form 10-K, consolidated income statement | Fiscal year, revenue caption, notes and applicable revisions |
| Interim working capital | Form 10-Q, interim balance sheet | Measurement date, current classifications and accompanying notes |
| Latest publicly announced earnings | Dated issuer earnings release, often an exhibit to Form 8-K | Preliminary status, actuals column and reconciliation of adjustments |
| Management's outlook | Latest applicable public guidance or investor update | Forecast period, range, assumptions and subsequent withdrawal |
| Street earnings estimate | Dated consensus snapshot | Contributor set, aggregation method, estimate basis and timestamp |
| Historical market close | Exchange record or market-data provider | Share class, trading date, timestamp and adjustment convention |
| Agreed merger consideration | Executed merger agreement and effective amendments | Consideration per share, form of payment and adjustment terms |
| Completed acquisition | Closing disclosure or authorized closing records | Completion date and any disclosed change to signing terms |
A What an SEC filing establishes
EDGAR is the Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis, and Retrieval system of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). It provides the actual submission, its date and its exhibits. The issuer makes the disclosure. The SEC's receipt of it neither certifies accuracy nor gives an auditor's opinion. For an audit conclusion, locate the independent auditor's report and read which statements and periods it covers. Management discussion, outlook and operational statistics do not acquire an audit opinion merely by appearing in the same annual report.
For a domestic reporting company, Form 10-K is the annual report containing audited annual financial statements and notes. Form 10-Q supplies unaudited interim financial statements for the first three fiscal quarters. Fourth-quarter figures may appear in an earnings release or may be derived from annual and nine-month results. Form 8-K reports specified current events. An earnings announcement is commonly furnished under Item 2.02 with the release as an exhibit. The exhibit can contain the actual financial table even when the form's main text only identifies the announcement.
Use the statement, notes and exhibit for complementary tasks. The income statement supplies revenue; the revenue note may identify the portion attributable to a product or geography. A release may announce the newest quarterly result before the 10-Q appears. Describe it as preliminary if the issuer does. Once the 10-Q becomes available, compare the figures and definitions before updating the model. A company presentation can be the direct source for a management-defined operating metric even when that metric does not appear on a financial statement.
Match each research request to the source feature that resolves it.
- Auditor's report:
- Identifies the statements and periods covered by the independent opinion.
- Consensus snapshot:
- Captures contributing analysts' expectations at a specified time.
- Executed merger agreement:
- Sets out the consideration and conditions accepted by the signatories.
- Closing announcement:
- Confirms that the parties completed the transaction.
- Market trade record:
- Identifies an observed price for a particular security and trading time.
B Efficient discovery and defensible verification
A commercial database can screen hundreds of companies on common fields. A provider might aggregate several revenue captions, translate local currency or update historical periods after restatement. For a screening list, that consistency can be useful. For a number driving a valuation or client exhibit, inspect the field definition and trace the observation to its underlying evidence. When the requested observation is the provider's own consensus, retain the provider's snapshot itself. An individual research report cannot reproduce the aggregate.
A news story can identify a potential bidder or alert the team to a possible acquisition. Follow the story to its origin. Three outlets quoting the same unnamed report give one underlying account. A joint public announcement supports the fact that the parties announced an agreement. The agreement supplies its detailed terms. A later completion disclosure answers whether the deal actually closed. A transaction database may classify all three dates separately.
A private target may have no periodic public reports. For authorized diligence, request the target's audited statements if available, recent management accounts and supporting schedules for the relevant entity. A seller's confidential information memorandum can describe the business and its adjusted earnings, but the underlying statements and adjustment schedules establish what went into those earnings. For a carve-out, a parent audit may cover the consolidated group while the target figures come from separately prepared schedules. Label that difference in evidentiary support.
See Fig 1. The source changes with the exact statement the analyst wants to make about a proposed sale.
Key point: Each milestone requires evidence that the parties reached that milestone.
flowchart TD
A[Acquisition claim] --> B{Which milestone?}
B --> C[Bid under discussion]
B --> D[Binding terms signed]
B --> E[Purchase completed]
C --> F[Authorized bid correspondence]
D --> G[Executed purchase agreement]
E --> H[Closing disclosure]C Checkpoint
A buyer wants the public consensus for next fiscal year's earnings per share immediately before the target raised guidance. Which source best answers the request?
- The dated consensus snapshot immediately before the announcement
- The midpoint of the target's previous guidance range
- The first analyst report published after the announcement
- The next annual filing showing realized earnings per share
1.1.1.2 Fix the information date and the financial period
A balance sheet might measure cash on December 31, appear in a release on February 12 and be downloaded on April 6. December 31 answers when the cash was measured. February 12 answers when that public release became available. April 6 identifies when the analyst accessed it. For a January 31 historical valuation based on public information, the February release falls outside the information set even though the underlying cash balance predates the valuation.
Define the cutoff precisely when events occur on the same day. Guidance issued after the market closes is public by that evening. An analysis explicitly using information available at the closing bell must exclude it. Likewise, a vendor's last-refresh timestamp describes a database operation. The underlying observation may come from an earlier quarter. For a foreign security or cross-market comparison, record the trading venue and time zone when they affect which observation was available.
Table 2 gives the complete public release history for a hypothetical issuer. All amounts are consolidated GAAP revenue for the same fiscal quarter, in millions of U.S. dollars.
| Public date | Document | Quarter ended | Revenue | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| April 18 | Issuer earnings release | March 31 | 246 | Preliminary actual |
| May 7 | Form 10-Q | March 31 | 243 | Reported interim result |
| August 9 | Form 10-Q/A | March 31 | 239 | Amendment expressly revises revenue |
A current historical exhibit and a reconstruction of an earlier board presentation serve different purposes. In a current exhibit, use the revised amount for the affected line and period. In a historical reconstruction, recover the version publicly available at the original cutoff. Check the explanation of an amendment: an amended annual report might add governance disclosures while leaving all financial statements unchanged. A later filing can also present revised comparative figures; inspect the notes to identify exactly what was revised.
See Fig 2. Two assignments can select different versions from the same filing history.
Key point: The assignment determines whether a later correction belongs in the exhibit.
flowchart TD
A[Historical financial figure] --> B{Which assignment?}
B --> C[Reconstruct earlier information]
B --> D[Update historical series]
C --> E[Apply original public cutoff]
D --> F[Inspect revision scope]
F --> G[Select applicable statement version]A Read both ends of the period
Fiscal year labels can hide different economic periods. A retailer with a January year-end and a manufacturer with a December year-end can both describe a period as 'fiscal 2025.' Record the actual beginning and ending dates. A 52- or 53-week fiscal calendar can produce different lengths even when the quarter labels match. When collecting comparable-company financials, retain those dates so later calendar alignment is possible.
Balance-sheet captions are measured at a date. Cash at June 30 already includes the effects of operations through that date; adding March 31 cash would double-count a stock of resources. Revenue, earnings and operating cash flow cover intervals. An interim statement may present three-month and year-to-date columns side by side, while an interim cash flow statement commonly presents cumulative cash flows. Choose by the heading above the number.
Worked case
A domestic issuer with a December 31 year-end files its annual report in February. A pitch needs standalone fourth-quarter consolidated GAAP sales. Annual sales are $820 million. The nine-month filing shows $596 million. The release also highlights fourth-quarter bookings of $251 million. The annual notes confirm the nine-month revenue figure remains on the same accounting and consolidation basis.
The desired interval is October through December. Annual sales include January through September once, so remove that nine-month amount once. In millions of dollars, \(820-596=224\). Adding $224 million back to $596 million recovers the annual total. Use $224 million and identify it as derived. The $251 million figure is already quarterly, but bookings measure orders under the issuer's definition. The annual total divided by four would give an average quarter and erase the actual sales pattern. If the annual notes had revised the first nine months, obtain a compatible revised nine-month figure before subtracting.
B Checkpoint
Using Table 2, which amount belongs in a reconstruction of a May 31 presentation using the latest GAAP revenue then public for the March quarter?
- $246 million from the release
- $239 million from the amendment
- $243 million from the interim filing
- An average of the release and interim filing
1.1.1.3 Reconcile definitions before choosing a number
Two values can share a date and a label yet measure different things. Read the units above the table, the line caption beside the number and the footnote below it. A value of 640,000 in U.S. dollars in thousands equals $640 million. A value of 640 million Canadian dollars still requires a currency convention for comparison with U.S. dollars. Record the source currency, translation rate and relevant date or period when a conversion is necessary. Preserve the native observation alongside the translated result.
Table 3 shows the evidence needed to explain common discrepancies. Each comparison starts with two plausible inputs.
| Apparent conflict | Inspect | What can explain the gap |
|---|---|---|
| Parent sales exceed target sales | Entity name and consolidation note | Parent includes operations outside the proposed sale. |
| Segment totals exceed group revenue | Segment note and eliminations | Intersegment sales are removed on consolidation. |
| Adjusted operating income exceeds GAAP operating income | Issuer's reconciliation | Specified expenses were added back in the adjusted measure. |
| Actual revenue differs from pro forma revenue | Acquisition date and pro forma assumptions | Pro forma presentation may include pre-acquisition activity. |
| Two share counts differ | Share class, date and calculation basis | A dated outstanding balance differs from a period-weighted diluted denominator. |
| Historical share prices differ | Price field and corporate-action settings | A retrospectively split-adjusted series changes the scale of earlier prices. |
| Transaction values differ | Equity consideration and assumed obligations | A database may quote enterprise value while the announcement quotes equity purchase price. |
U.S. generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) supply the reporting basis for the GAAP figure in a U.S. issuer's reconciliation. To collect a company-defined adjusted result, locate its definition, its comparable GAAP measure and the individual adjustments. Read their signs: removing an expense can increase adjusted earnings, while removing a gain can decrease them. An adjustment schedule explains the issuer's calculation. It does not, by itself, establish that an expense will disappear after a transaction. Two issuers using 'adjusted EBITDA' can choose different exclusions.
For a share-count request, the noun after the number matters. A date-specific count of outstanding common shares can support an equity capitalization calculation when aligned with the price date and share classes. A periodic report's cover may give shares outstanding on a more recent date than the balance sheet. For diluted earnings per share, the relevant denominator is the weighted-average diluted share count over the earnings period. For a deal-specific fully diluted count, examine the transaction terms and relevant equity awards. A vendor's generic 'diluted shares' field could answer a different question.
Completeness is part of reconciliation. A dash may mean zero, immaterial, unavailable or inapplicable according to the table legend. A blank purchase-price field for a private acquisition means the field supplies no amount. Search the announcement, agreement and subsequent financial footnotes as appropriate. If the amount remains undisclosed, mark it accordingly and leave a price-dependent multiple unavailable. Assigning zero would create a fictitious observed price.
See Fig 3. A field-level comparison helps distinguish a documented difference from an unsupported adjustment.
Key point: A reconciling adjustment needs evidence for both its amount and its meaning.
flowchart TD
A[Conflicting operating figures] --> B{Comparable periods and units?}
B -->|No| C[Align dates and scale]
B -->|Yes| D{Matching metric definitions?}
D -->|No| E[Inspect adjustment schedule]
D -->|Yes| F[Check perimeter and revisions]
E --> G{Gap fully explained?}
G -->|Yes| H[Retain documented bridge]
G -->|No| I[Flag unresolved amount]Worked case
A sell-side exhibit calls for the target's reported GAAP operating income. Its annual income statement is headed 'U.S. dollars in thousands' and shows 72,400. A database displays normalized operating income of $80.4 million. The vendor identifies one adjustment, an $8.0 million restructuring expense, and cites the same fiscal year and consolidated entity. The seller also forecasts $11 million of future annual savings.
Express the historical results in millions first: \(72{,}400/1{,}000=72.4\). The $8.0 million expense reduced reported income. Adding it back gives \(72.4+8.0=80.4\), exactly the vendor figure. The exhibit calls for the reported measure, so enter $72.4 million and retain the bridge. The numbers agree on the underlying economics. The projected savings belong to a future period and cannot explain the difference between these historical observations. If the vendor had supplied only the label 'normalized,' the $8.0 million gap alone would not establish its cause.
1.1.1.4 Preserve evidence another banker can reproduce
A useful source note lets a second analyst retrieve the same observation after the issuer updates its website or the vendor refreshes its data. For an SEC filing, record the issuer, form, filing date, period end and precise locator, such as the accession number plus the statement caption, note or exhibit. For market or consensus data, record the provider, identifier, field, timestamp and relevant settings. Preserve the permitted snapshot or export in the deal record. A homepage address or the phrase 'per management' leaves the reviewer searching for the underlying observation.
Table 4 illustrates how a single number can be followed from origin to output. The example uses the historical operating-income case.
| Record element | Example entry | Reviewer can verify |
|---|---|---|
| Population and period | Target consolidated group, fiscal year ended December 31 | Entity and time span match the exhibit. |
| Primary locator | Archived annual filing, consolidated statements of operations, operating income row | The exact line used in the workbook. |
| Raw value and unit | 72,400, U.S. dollars in thousands | The original value before conversion. |
| Transformation | Divide by 1,000 to display millions | The model preserves scale and sign. |
| Difference resolved | Vendor adds back $8.0 million of restructuring expense | The normalized and reported values reconcile. |
| Final destination | Historical results exhibit, GAAP operating income, $72.4 million | The client-facing label matches the selected measure. |
When updating a model, preserve the old observation and the reason for the change. Distinguish correcting a transcription error from incorporating information published later. A corrected formula can apply to an old information set. A new filing changes that information set. If a material difference survives the date, scope, units and definition checks, retain both values, identify their sources and state what evidence is missing. Route the issue to the deal lead before distributing an exhibit that depends on the disputed number.
See Fig 4. A public valuation exhibit and an authorized private diligence analysis can require different handling of the same forecast.
Key point: A forecast's origin and permitted use travel with the number.
flowchart TD
A[Target forecast] --> B{Which source?}
B --> C[Public investor presentation]
B --> D[Restricted diligence forecast]
C --> E[Verify dated public guidance]
D --> F{Authorized for this use?}
F -->|Yes| G[Retain within approved assignment]
F -->|Unclear| H[Hold use pending direction]See also. Industry and Market Research covers sector data. Company Business Profile Research covers operating context. Comparable and Precedent Data Collection applies source selection to valuation samples. Periodic and Event Filing Research, Ownership and Insider Filing Sources, and Permitted Internal and Client Communications develop document selection and use restrictions further.
A Recall check
Answer each question from memory before revealing the response.
- Where can the numerical results behind a short earnings-related Form 8-K appear?
- In the earnings release attached as an exhibit.
- Which two dates establish the age and availability of a balance-sheet observation?
- The balance-sheet measurement date and the date the observation became available to the relevant audience.
- What must align before subtracting nine-month sales from annual sales?
- The periods must nest within the same fiscal year and use compatible units, accounting basis and business scope.
- Which share count belongs in a historical diluted earnings-per-share calculation?
- The weighted-average diluted shares for the earnings period.
- How should an undisclosed acquisition price appear in a precedents file?
- Mark the price undisclosed and any multiple requiring that price unavailable.
Common mistakes
Each tempting choice in Table 5 answers a plausible research question. Read the assignment closely enough to see which question it actually answers.
| Tempting choice | Why it attracts | Detail that settles the choice |
|---|---|---|
| Use an audited annual number for the latest interim result. | The audit provides independent assurance. | The requested interval ends after the audited year. |
| Use the last database refresh as the observation date. | The screen carries today's timestamp. | The field still cites last quarter's statement. |
| Read every 10-K/A as a financial restatement. | The suffix identifies an amendment. | The amendment's stated scope identifies the items changed. |
| Treat an acquisition announcement as evidence of closing. | The parties and purchase price are already public. | The announcement says completion remains subject to conditions. |
| Average two earnings figures to resolve uncertainty. | Both sources look credible. | The assignment specifies a defined measure that the midpoint need not represent. |
Approach
Use this sequence when two sources compete for a single model input.
Self-check quiz
Question 1. A buyer needs a target's sales from external customers. The segment note reports $315 million of sales for the target division, including $28 million to another division in the same group. The group reports $910 million of consolidated sales. Which amount and source best answer the request?
- $315 million from the segment total
- $287 million derived from the segment note
- $910 million from the consolidated income statement
- $882 million derived from the consolidated income statement
Question 2. A banker needs the actual closing price paid in the market for one common share on the day before a merger announcement. A two-for-one split occurred six months later. Which observation best fits?
- The retrospectively split-adjusted close for the pre-announcement day
- The unadjusted close on the announcement day
- The merger consideration for one pre-split common share
- The unadjusted close for that class on the pre-announcement day
Question 3. A target's data room contains an unpublished forecast more recent than its public guidance. A banker is updating a public-information-only peer comparison. Which input is appropriate?
- The applicable public guidance, with its date and management attribution
- The data-room forecast, identified only as a banking estimate
- The midpoint between the public and data-room forecasts
- The data-room forecast, with a confidential footer on the peer comparison
Question 4. A database lists a completed private acquisition with no price. A trade journal names a price and cites another publication's unnamed source. The buyer's announcement confirms completion and says terms were undisclosed. Which treatment best supports a precedent analysis?
- Enter zero as the consideration until the buyer issues another report.
- Use the reported price because two publications carried it.
- Record completion and leave the price-based multiple unavailable pending support.
- Estimate consideration using the peer median and classify the resulting multiple as observed.
Question 5. A team is updating a historical income statement using the latest available filings. A Form 10-K/A adds director information and explicitly leaves the financial statements unchanged. A database shows a different net income with no explanation. Which action is most appropriate?
- Replace filed net income with the database figure because an amendment exists.
- Retain the supported filed figure and investigate the database difference.
- Average the two amounts and mark the midpoint as revised net income.
- Reclassify the original audited statement as preliminary pending another annual report.
Answer key
Question 1 - Answer: B. The division's external sales are \(315-28=287\) million dollars. A includes intersegment sales, C captures all consolidated businesses, and D subtracts a division-level amount from a group total that already reflects consolidation eliminations.
Question 2 - Answer: D. The unadjusted close preserves the per-share price observed for the specified class on the specified trading day. A expresses the price on a later split basis, B uses a day when the announcement could affect trading, and C gives a contractual payment rather than a market observation.
Question 3 - Answer: A. Dated public guidance supplies management's publicly available forecast on its stated basis. B obscures the restricted source, C incorporates restricted information through averaging, and D changes the label on the output without satisfying the public-source condition.
Question 4 - Answer: C. Completion has direct support, while the purchase price lacks independent confirmation. A turns missing information into a price, B counts a single underlying report twice, and D converts a modeling assumption into a purported transaction observation.
Question 5 - Answer: B. The amendment's scope preserves the financial statements as filed. A assumes a financial revision the amendment expressly excludes, C creates an amount supported by neither source, and D changes the status of the statements without evidence.
Rapid review
- Audited annual actuals → read the Form 10-K statements, notes and auditor's coverage.
- Newest interim actual → identify the latest available release or Form 10-Q for the requested period.
- Management outlook → trace the forecast to dated issuer guidance.
- Street estimate → preserve the consensus snapshot at the required cutoff.
- Historical reconstruction → exclude disclosures first public after the chosen date.
- Quarterly flow → verify whether the source column covers three months or year to date.
- Vendor mismatch → compare units, perimeter, revisions and field definition.
- Deal status → distinguish a signed agreement from evidence of completion.
- Reproducible number → retain the observation, locator, version and calculation.
Keep going with the full Series 79 Investment Banking Representative Exam Prep Course
You just studied the way members do, in the same lesson interface. Full access unlocks every lesson, the question bank and flashcards for a full year.
One payment per program