Skip to content
Free previewYou are reading 1 of 189 lessons, in the same interface members use. Everything else unlocks with full access.Get full access · $150

1.1.1 - Federal Subject Matter Jurisdiction

What you'll learn

  • Identify a federal question from the plaintiff's claim rather than a defense.
  • Determine every party's citizenship and test complete diversity.
  • Calculate the jurisdictional amount using the proper aggregation rules.
  • Distinguish jurisdictional defects from objections that parties can waive.
  • Choose dismissal, remand, or correction of an allegation when jurisdiction is challenged.

Estimated reading time: 29 minutes.

WHY

Why it matters

Federal subject-matter jurisdiction determines whether a federal court has authority to adjudicate the kind of dispute presented. Bar questions often combine an ordinary state-law claim with federal defenses, complicated business ownership, or a misleading damages demand; each requires a separate jurisdictional analysis before reaching the merits.

KEY TERMS

Key terms

Original jurisdiction
A court's authority to hear an action at its outset, rather than on appellate review.
Well-pleaded complaint
The plaintiff's properly pleaded claim, considered without anticipated defenses or replies to them.
Complete diversity
No plaintiff shares state citizenship with any defendant.
Domicile
An individual's legally recognized home, established through physical presence and intent to remain indefinitely.
Nerve center
The actual location where a corporation's high-level officers direct, control, and coordinate its activities.
Amount in controversy
The monetary value genuinely placed at issue, assessed under the governing jurisdictional rules.
Minimal diversity
A statutory standard satisfied by the required citizenship difference between at least one qualifying pair of opposing parties or claimants.
Remand
Sending a removed action back to the state court from which it came.
CORE

Core content

1.1.1.1 Federal judicial power requires a jurisdictional basis

Article III of the United States Constitution establishes the outer boundaries of federal judicial power. A federal district court also needs a congressional grant authorizing it to hear the action. Constitutional power alone does not establish statutory jurisdiction. The two most common grants are federal-question jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1331 and diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332.

The party invoking federal jurisdiction bears the burden of establishing it. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8(a)(1) requires a short and plain statement of the jurisdictional grounds unless the court already has jurisdiction and the claim requires no additional support. In a diversity complaint, alleging that someone lives in Texas leaves a factual gap: residence does not necessarily establish Texas citizenship.

The following table separates questions that can arise in the same lawsuit but require different rules.

Table 1. Separate questions about the federal forum
InquiryWhat it determinesIllustration
Subject-matter jurisdictionAuthority over the category of disputeA federal claim or a qualifying diversity action
Personal jurisdictionAuthority over a defendantA defendant's forum contacts or valid consent
VenueThe proper geographic federal districtA district connected to defendants or substantial events
Governing lawThe substantive and procedural rules to applyState substantive law in an ordinary diversity action
Exclusive jurisdictionWhether state courts are excluded from hearing a claimPatent infringement under the applicable federal jurisdictional statute

A federal court sitting in Texas applies federal subject-matter jurisdiction rules. Texas residence, a Texas contract, or a contract clause selecting a Texas federal court does not independently supply jurisdiction. Conversely, a federal court can adjudicate a state-law claim through diversity jurisdiction. The governing substantive law and the source of judicial power answer different questions; see also Erie and Federal Governing Law.

Federal jurisdiction also does not invariably exclude state jurisdiction. State courts generally may hear federal claims unless Congress has made the particular jurisdiction exclusive. Section 1338, for example, addresses exclusive federal jurisdiction over specified patent and copyright claims; exclusivity is not an automatic consequence of Section 1331.

A Procedural permission does not establish federal judicial power

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 82 expressly provides that the Federal Rules do not extend or limit district court jurisdiction. A rule allowing joinder, counterclaims, intervention, or class treatment answers whether a procedural arrangement is permitted; it does not establish that the court can adjudicate every resulting claim. For example, satisfying Rule 23 does not itself create federal jurisdiction over a class action. Analyze the jurisdictional grant separately, including any available supplemental jurisdiction, before treating procedural permission as sufficient.

The Federal Rules retain this distinction expressly.

1.1.1.2 A federal question must belong to the plaintiff's claim

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1331, district courts have jurisdiction over civil actions arising under the Constitution, laws, or treaties of the United States. There is no general dollar minimum. A properly asserted federal statutory claim seeking $8,000 can satisfy Section 1331 even though the same amount would be insufficient for ordinary diversity jurisdiction.

A The well-pleaded complaint rule

Ordinarily, federal law must create the plaintiff's cause of action. A federal defense does not make a state-law claim arise under federal law, even when the plaintiff predicts the defense in the complaint and explains why it fails. An ordinary federal counterclaim likewise does not establish Section 1331 jurisdiction over the plaintiff's action. Specific statutory exceptions should be analyzed under their own terms.

A seller's state-law suit to collect an unpaid invoice remains a state-law suit when the buyer argues that federal law makes the contract unenforceable. The plaintiff can establish the elements of the collection claim without proving a federal right. The defense may be decisive on the merits while remaining insufficient to open the federal forum.

Fig 1 follows the federal-question inquiry from the pleaded claim to the narrow embedded-issue exception.

Fig 1. Federal-question jurisdiction
Key point: A federal issue must enter through the plaintiff's claim or a recognized exception.
flowchart TD
A["Plaintiff's well-pleaded claim"] --> B{"Federal law creates claim?"}
B -->|Yes| C["Section 1331 ordinarily satisfied"]
B -->|No| D{"Necessary disputed federal issue?"}
D -->|No| E["No ordinary federal question"]
D -->|Yes| F{"Systemic importance and balance?"}
F -->|Both satisfied| C
F -->|Either missing| E

B Federal issues embedded in state-law claims

A narrow category of state-law claims nevertheless arises under federal law. The federal issue must be necessarily raised, actually disputed, substantial to the federal system as a whole, and capable of resolution in federal court without disrupting the congressionally approved federal-state balance. All four requirements matter. The Supreme Court articulated this framework in Gunn v. Minton, a Texas legal-malpractice dispute involving an underlying patent issue. A hypothetical patent determination important to the parties did not establish the required systemic importance.

A necessary issue is one the plaintiff must resolve to establish the claim. If an independent state-law theory permits recovery without deciding federal law, the federal issue ordinarily is not necessary. A substantial issue must matter beyond the immediate litigants; a fact-bound disagreement about their past conduct is less likely to qualify than a controlling federal issue with broader consequences.

C Preemption, declaratory relief, and weak federal claims

Ordinary preemption means federal law defeats or displaces a state-law rule as a defense. Complete preemption is different: in a narrow field where Congress has provided an exclusive federal remedial scheme, a covered claim pleaded under state law is treated as federal. Complete preemption under Section 502(a) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act is a recognized example; not every ERISA-related dispute falls within it.

The Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. §§ 2201-2202, authorizes a remedy but does not independently confer jurisdiction. Ask whether the corresponding coercive action would arise under federal law. A potential defendant cannot convert an anticipated federal defense into jurisdiction by filing first for a declaration that the defense is valid.

Jurisdiction and merits. A genuinely asserted, nonfrivolous federal cause of action ordinarily supplies federal-question jurisdiction even if the plaintiff ultimately loses. A claim that is wholly insubstantial or frivolous, or asserted solely to manufacture jurisdiction, is different. An ordinary failure to prove a federal claim generally produces a merits ruling rather than a jurisdictional dismissal.

D Checkpoint

A Texas citizen sues another Texas citizen for $120,000 for breach of a Texas-law contract. The complaint anticipates a defense based on a federal regulation. No complete-preemption doctrine applies. What is the strongest conclusion?

  1. Federal jurisdiction exists because federal law will affect the result.
  2. Neither the anticipated federal defense nor the parties' citizenship establishes original federal jurisdiction.
  3. Federal jurisdiction exists because the demand exceeds $75,000.
  4. Federal jurisdiction exists if the defendant agrees to the forum.
Answer: B. The claim is state-created, and both parties are Texas citizens. A is tempting because federal law may control the outcome, but a federal defense does not satisfy the well-pleaded complaint rule.

Worked case

A Texas distributor sues a Texas manufacturer in federal court for $180,000 in unpaid rebates under a distribution agreement. The complaint explains that an expected federal regulatory defense is invalid. A separate paragraph asks for a declaration rejecting that defense. The agreement selects a federal court in Dallas, and the distributor attaches extensive correspondence about national sales.

The right being enforced is the contractual right to rebates. Resolving the manufacturer's anticipated federal defense is not an element of that claim. The declaratory request mirrors the same defense and does not supply an independent jurisdictional basis. Both parties are Texas citizens, so the size of the demand cannot establish diversity. Neither national sales nor the forum clause changes these conclusions. Without another statutory basis, the federal court lacks subject-matter jurisdiction.

1.1.1.3 Diversity requires a complete citizenship inventory

For ordinary diversity under 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a), the controversy must exceed $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs, and satisfy a statutory citizenship category. For citizens of different states, complete diversity means every plaintiff must be diverse from every defendant. Co-plaintiffs may share citizenship, and co-defendants may share citizenship; the disqualifying overlap is across opposing sides.

A Individuals and domicile

A natural person is a citizen of a state for diversity purposes only if the person is a United States citizen domiciled there. Domicile requires physical presence plus intent to remain indefinitely. A person need not promise to stay forever. Employment, home ownership, voter registration, tax filings, family location, and statements of intent provide evidence; no mailing address alone conclusively decides the issue.

A person retains an established domicile until acquiring another. A student temporarily renting an apartment in another state while planning to return home may retain the original domicile. Someone who actually moves to Texas for an open-ended job and makes Texas home can acquire Texas domicile immediately; there is no minimum residency period.

The citizenship rule changes with the kind of party, as Table 2 shows.

Table 2. Citizenship by party type
PartyCitizenship usedFact that does not control alone
United States citizenState of domicileResidence or temporary physical location
CorporationEvery place of incorporation and its principal place of businessLargest market or greatest sales volume
Limited liability companyEvery member's citizenship, traced through ownership layersFormation state or headquarters
PartnershipEvery partner's citizenship, including limited partnersPrincipal business office
Estate's legal representativeDecedent's citizenshipRepresentative's personal domicile
Infant's or incompetent person's legal representativeRepresented person's citizenshipGuardian's personal citizenship

B Corporations and unincorporated entities

Under Section 1332(c)(1), a corporation has citizenship in every state or foreign state where it is incorporated and in the state or foreign state of its principal place of business. The principal place of business is its nerve center: the actual place where high-level officers direct, control, and coordinate corporate activities. Headquarters usually supplies that location if it is genuine; a nominal office does not. A Delaware corporation directed from Texas is a citizen of both Delaware and Texas, even if California generates most revenue.

An LLC is not treated as a corporation for this purpose. Its citizenship follows all members. If a member is itself an LLC or partnership, continue through that entity until the citizenship of every relevant owner is identified. A limited partnership includes limited partners as well as general partners. A business's tax election does not substitute for this organizational analysis.

Section 1332(c)(2) supplies the representative rules in Table 2. Section 1332(c)(1) also contains a narrower insurance provision: in a qualifying direct action against a liability insurer, when the insured is not joined as a defendant, the insurer additionally takes the insured's citizenship. An insured suing its own insurer for coverage is not automatically the kind of direct action covered by that provision.

C Foreign parties and citizenship at filing

Section 1332(a)(2) generally permits a state citizen to sue a foreign citizen, or vice versa. It does not ordinarily support a foreign citizen suing another foreign citizen, even when they are citizens of different foreign countries. Under Section 1332(a)(3), foreign parties may appear on both sides as additional parties when completely diverse United States state citizens occupy opposing sides. A United States citizen domiciled abroad is neither a citizen of a state nor an alien for these categories, creating a diversity gap.

A lawful permanent resident remains a foreign citizen rather than automatically becoming a citizen of the state of domicile. Section 1332(a)(2) specifically excludes an action between a state citizen and a foreign citizen lawfully admitted for permanent residence who is domiciled in that same state.

Table 3 applies these distinctions; assume the amount requirement is satisfied and no special jurisdictional statute applies.

Table 3. Ordinary citizenship configurations
Plaintiff sideDefendant sideCitizenship result
Texas citizenOklahoma citizenDiverse state citizens
Texas citizen and French citizenOklahoma citizen and German citizenPermissible additional foreign parties under Section 1332(a)(3)
French citizenGerman citizenNo ordinary alienage jurisdiction
Texas citizenFrench permanent resident domiciled in TexasExcluded by Section 1332(a)(2)
United States citizen domiciled in FranceTexas citizenNo qualifying state or alien citizenship for plaintiff
Texas citizenDelaware corporation with Texas nerve centerShared Texas citizenship defeats complete diversity

For an action originally filed in federal court, citizenship generally is assessed at filing. A genuine later move ordinarily does not create diversity that was missing or eliminate diversity that existed. Separate rules can govern changes involving parties, removal, and special statutes; see Supplemental Jurisdiction and Removal.

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1359, improper or collusive assignments or joinder cannot manufacture jurisdiction. A sham transfer of a claim to a diverse nominal plaintiff is different from an actual, good-faith domicile change completed before filing. Courts also examine the parties' real interests and may realign them, so caption labels alone do not control opposing-side citizenship.

D Checkpoint

Using Table 2, determine whether complete diversity exists when a Texas citizen sues an Oklahoma-organized LLC for $160,000. Its office is in Oklahoma, but its two individual members are domiciled in Oklahoma and Texas.

  1. Yes, because the LLC was organized in Oklahoma.
  2. Yes, because the LLC's principal office is outside Texas.
  3. Yes, because only its managing member's citizenship matters.
  4. No, because the LLC has a Texas member.
Answer: D. The LLC has both members' citizenship, including Texas. B imports the corporate headquarters analysis into the wrong entity category.

E Government parties, territories, and class representatives

Complete the citizenship inventory by checking whether the party fits a statutory category at all. A governmental name does not automatically identify either a state citizen or a foreign citizen.

Table 4 distinguishes additional party categories that can change the diversity result.

Table 4. Additional diversity citizenship categories
Party or locationApplicable treatmentQuestion to resolve
District of Columbia, Territories, or Puerto RicoIncluded within States under Section 1332(e)Does the individual satisfy the applicable citizenship and domicile requirements?
A state itselfNot a citizen for ordinary diversityIs the state an actual party rather than background to the dispute?
State agency or instrumentalityNo state citizenship if it is an arm of the stateDoes its legal status make it an arm of the state?
Municipality or other political subdivisionOrdinarily a citizen of its state unless an arm of the stateIs it a separate local governmental entity?
Qualifying foreign state as plaintiffSection 1332(a)(4) provides a separate citizenship categoryAre defendants citizens of a state or different states?
Ordinary class action under Section 1332(a)Generally use named representatives' citizenship rather than unnamed members' citizenshipIs the action relying on ordinary diversity or CAFA?

A United States citizen domiciled in Puerto Rico can therefore have qualifying citizenship under Section 1332; living outside the fifty states does not necessarily create the same problem as domicile in Spain. Conversely, Texas itself cannot be treated as a Texas citizen merely because an opposing plaintiff is domiciled in Oklahoma. A city's status requires a different inquiry from the state's status.

Section 1332(a)(4) concerns a foreign state as plaintiff, not merely a private foreign national. It retains the ordinary requirement that the controversy exceed $75,000. A foreign government appearing as defendant raises separate statutory questions and should not be treated as the reverse of this provision.

For an ordinary class action, an unnamed class member's shared citizenship with the defendant generally does not defeat diversity when the named representatives satisfy the citizenship requirement. Do not transfer that rule to CAFA: its minimal-diversity inquiry expressly considers class members. The amount and aggregation requirements also depend on the jurisdictional route selected.

The statutory territorial and foreign-state categories appear in Section 1332(a)(4) and (e).

F Citizenship disclosure under Rule 7.1

Rule 7.1(a)(2) makes the citizenship inventory a disclosure obligation in actions relying on Section 1332(a). Unless the court orders otherwise, each party or intervenor must name and identify the citizenship of every individual or entity whose citizenship is attributed to it. An LLC cannot satisfy this requirement merely by listing its formation state: the relevant ownership chain must be disclosed.

The rule requires disclosure when the action is filed in or removed to federal court and when a later event could affect jurisdiction under Section 1332(a). Rule 7.1(b) additionally requires filing with the party's first appearance, pleading, petition, motion, response, or other request addressed to the court, and prompt supplementation when required information changes. No fixed number of days substitutes for these event-based requirements. Disclosure exposes jurisdictional facts; it does not create otherwise missing citizenship.

1.1.1.4 The amount must exceed the threshold under permitted valuation rules

Section 1332(a) requires more than $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs. Exactly $75,000 fails. The plaintiff's good-faith demand ordinarily controls unless it appears to a legal certainty that the plaintiff cannot recover more than $75,000. The test is not whether the plaintiff probably will win that amount. A legally available $100,000 claim does not fail because the defendant offers persuasive evidence of no liability.

A substantive damages cap can change the result. If controlling law limits all recoverable relief to $60,000 and no additional legally available recovery applies, a demand for $100,000 cannot establish the amount. By contrast, a later verdict of $40,000 ordinarily does not undo jurisdiction that existed when the action began.

Table 5 distinguishes recoverable relief from amounts ordinarily excluded from the calculation.

Table 5. Components of the jurisdictional amount
ComponentOrdinary treatmentCondition or qualification
Compensatory damagesCountMust be genuinely claimed and legally recoverable
Punitive damagesCount when availableGoverning law must permit them on the asserted claim
Attorney feesCount when recoverable as part of the claimA statute, contract, or other applicable law must authorize recovery
Interest for delayed paymentExclude when merely incidentalInterest forming part of the underlying substantive obligation may be treated differently
Litigation costsExcludeAdding filing or service costs cannot bridge the threshold
Equitable reliefValue the object of litigationThe permissible plaintiff or defendant viewpoint varies among courts

For injunctions or declarations, determine the value of the right to be protected or the object of the litigation. A plaintiff seeking removal of an obstruction might rely on the value of restored access; some courts also permit valuation from the defendant's cost of compliance. Because courts differ, use a valuation rule supplied in the question rather than assuming a universal viewpoint.

A Aggregation depends on whose claims and whose liability

A single plaintiff may add separate claims against a single defendant, even when the claims are unrelated. Two separate plaintiffs ordinarily cannot add independent injuries together. Nor may one plaintiff add separate claims against separate defendants simply because both defendants appear in one complaint. Joint liability permits treatment of the jointly owed obligation as a whole; it does not justify adding distinct liabilities.

Table 6 makes the ownership of each claim explicit.

Table 6. Aggregation outcomes
ConfigurationClaims assertedOrdinary amount result
One plaintiff against one defendant$45,000 contract claim plus unrelated $40,000 tort claim$85,000; aggregation permitted
Two plaintiffs with separate injuries$45,000 for one and $40,000 for the otherNo aggregation; neither independently exceeds $75,000
One plaintiff against separate defendants$45,000 owed by one and $40,000 separately owed by anotherNo aggregation of independent liabilities
One plaintiff against jointly liable defendantsOne $85,000 joint obligationThe $85,000 obligation satisfies the threshold
Multiple plaintiffs with a common undivided interestA genuinely collective right valued at $85,000Aggregation may be permitted because the right is jointly held

A common undivided interest is more than similar claims arising from the same accident. The plaintiffs must enforce a genuinely collective right rather than independent entitlements. Separate passengers injured in one collision retain separate damages claims; sharing evidence does not transform their claims into an undivided interest.

Worked case

When suit is filed, a Texas citizen sues a corporation incorporated in Delaware and directed from Colorado. The plaintiff asserts a $48,000 equipment-contract claim and an unrelated $32,000 property-damage claim against that corporation. Both amounts are legally recoverable and pleaded in good faith. The corporation earns most revenue in Texas. Three months later, the plaintiff moves permanently to Colorado.

The corporation's citizenship is Delaware and Colorado, rather than its largest sales market. The plaintiff was a Texas citizen at filing, so the opposing parties were completely diverse. Because one plaintiff asserts both claims against one defendant, the claims aggregate to $80,000. The later Colorado move ordinarily does not disturb jurisdiction. If the property-damage claim instead belonged to a second plaintiff, adding the two plaintiffs' independent demands would not establish the amount.

B Checkpoint

Using Table 6, which action satisfies the ordinary amount requirement, assuming complete diversity and no supplemental jurisdiction?

  1. One plaintiff asserts unrelated claims of $46,000 and $35,000 against the same defendant.
  2. Two plaintiffs assert separate $41,000 claims against the same defendant.
  3. One plaintiff seeks exactly $75,000 plus $2,000 in filing and service costs.
  4. One plaintiff asserts separate $41,000 claims against two independently liable defendants.
Answer: A. One plaintiff may aggregate both claims against one defendant to reach $81,000. B is tempting because the combined total exceeds the threshold, but independent plaintiffs cannot combine separate claims that way.

C Alternative relief, reductions, and offsets

Aggregation counts the relief legally placed in controversy, rather than every dollar appearing anywhere in the pleadings. Separate cumulative claims differ from mutually exclusive remedies for one injury.

Table 7 identifies three valuation adjustments that do not follow ordinary addition.

Table 7. Valuation without double counting or improper subtraction
SituationAmount treatmentIllustration
Mutually exclusive alternative remediesDo not add recoveries that cannot both be awardedAlternative $50,000 remedies do not create a $100,000 controversy
Demand reduced after valid federal filingOrdinarily retain jurisdiction established at filingA valid $100,000 demand later reduced to $60,000 ordinarily does not defeat jurisdiction
Defendant asserts a setoff or counterclaimDo not subtract it from the plaintiff's jurisdictional demandA $100,000 claim remains above the threshold despite a claimed $40,000 offset

Suppose a plaintiff pleads $50,000 for breach of contract or, alternatively, $50,000 in restitution for the same payment, and governing law permits only one recovery. These alternative theories do not place $100,000 in controversy. Compare two distinct losses recoverable cumulatively: those amounts may be added when the ordinary aggregation rules permit.

A later reduction must also be distinguished from evidence that the initial demand never could satisfy the threshold. A voluntary postfiling reduction ordinarily leaves valid jurisdiction intact. A controlling damages cap that already limited recovery when suit began instead shows that the original valuation was insufficient. The relevant distinction is between a later change in the amount sought and a legal limitation that existed at filing.

D A small recovery can affect costs without undoing jurisdiction

Section 1332(b) supplies a consequence separate from jurisdictional dismissal. Unless another federal statute expressly provides otherwise, when a plaintiff who originally filed in federal court is finally adjudged entitled to recover less than $75,000, the district court may deny costs to that plaintiff and may also impose costs on the plaintiff. The statute computes this recovery without regard to a setoff or counterclaim and excludes interest and costs. This authority is discretionary, applies to the original federal plaintiff described in the statute, and does not convert a low recovery into retroactive loss of jurisdiction.

1.1.1.5 Special statutes and exceptions require their own analysis

Original jurisdiction over one claim does not necessarily establish independent original jurisdiction over every additional claim. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1367, supplemental jurisdiction can reach additional claims forming part of the same constitutional case or controversy, generally through a common nucleus of operative fact. Statutory restrictions and discretionary grounds for declining jurisdiction remain important.

In a diversity action with completely diverse opposing parties, one plaintiff's qualifying claim may support supplemental jurisdiction over a related co-plaintiff claim below the amount threshold when Section 1367 otherwise permits it. This is different from adding two small claims when no plaintiff has a qualifying anchor claim. Supplemental jurisdiction also does not cure a lack of complete diversity among original opposing parties. The detailed joinder restrictions belong in Supplemental Jurisdiction and Removal.

The following table contrasts ordinary diversity with two commonly confused statutory alternatives.

Table 8. Distinct statutory jurisdictional thresholds
Jurisdictional routeCitizenship standardAmount and additional conditions
Ordinary diversity, Section 1332(a)Complete diversity for opposing state citizensMore than $75,000, with ordinary aggregation limits
CAFA class action, Section 1332(d)Minimal diversity under the statuteGenerally at least 100 proposed members and aggregate controversy exceeding $5 million; exclusions and exceptions apply
Statutory interpleader, Section 1335Minimal diversity between at least two adverse claimantsAt least $500 in disputed property; deposit or qualifying bond required
Rule interpleader, Rule 22Depends on the independent jurisdictional basisRule 22 itself supplies neither a special amount threshold nor federal subject-matter jurisdiction

The Class Action Fairness Act, or CAFA, permits aggregation of proposed class members' claims under its own rules. Local-controversy and home-state provisions can require declining jurisdiction, and other statutory exclusions apply. The special $5 million and minimal-diversity rules therefore should not be imported into an ordinary two-party negligence action.

Statutory interpleader allows a stakeholder facing competing demands to bring adverse claimants into one action. Its $500 threshold includes exactly $500, unlike ordinary diversity's requirement that the controversy exceed $75,000. For Section 1335, the relevant minimal diversity is between adverse claimants; it is not simply diversity between the stakeholder and one claimant. Rule 22 is a procedural device and requires a separate jurisdictional basis.

A Probate and domestic-relations boundaries

The probate exception reserves probate or annulment of a will and administration of a decedent's estate to state probate courts, and prevents federal courts from disposing of property in a state probate court's custody. It does not categorically exclude an otherwise proper personal damages claim merely because an inheritance dispute supplies the background.

The domestic-relations exception to diversity jurisdiction reserves issuance of divorce, alimony, and child-custody decrees. A former spouse's ordinary tort claim is not automatically excluded because the parties were married. Determine the relief requested: a federal damages judgment and a new custody decree are different judicial acts.

Match each jurisdictional source to the feature that distinguishes it.

Section 1331:
A claim arising under federal law without a general dollar minimum.
Section 1332(a):
Ordinary state-citizen diversity with a controversy greater than $75,000.
Section 1332(d):
A qualifying class using a $5 million aggregate threshold and minimal diversity.
Section 1335:
Competing claimants to property worth at least $500, secured by deposit or bond.
Section 1367:
Additional related claims attached to an action within original federal jurisdiction.

1.1.1.6 A jurisdictional objection survives ordinary forfeiture

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(1) authorizes a motion for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction. Rule 12(h)(3) requires the court to dismiss when it determines, at any time during a pending action, that subject-matter jurisdiction is absent. The court may raise the issue itself; the plaintiff, defendant, or appellate court can also identify the problem. Agreement and silence do not supply missing power.

Personal jurisdiction, venue, process, and service objections follow different preservation rules. Under Rule 12(h)(1), available defenses under Rule 12(b)(2)-(5) can be waived by omission from the required initial Rule 12 presentation. Failure to state a claim under Rule 12(b)(6) has its own preservation rules and is not automatically a defect in subject-matter jurisdiction.

Table 9 connects the defect to the appropriate procedural consequence.

Table 9. Defect, preservation, and response
ProblemPreservation or correctionOrdinary response
Original federal action lacks subject-matter jurisdictionCannot be supplied by party consentDismiss without prejudice if the defect remains uncured
Removed action lacks subject-matter jurisdictionMay be raised before final judgment under Section 1447(c)Remand to the originating state court
Removal defect other than subject-matter jurisdictionRemand motion ordinarily required within 30 days after notice of removal is filedTimely remand if the objection is valid
Available personal-jurisdiction or venue defense omittedCan be waived under Rule 12(h)(1)Proceed if waived and no other barrier applies
Actual jurisdiction exists but allegations are defectiveSection 1653 permits amendment of defective allegationsCorrect the allegations rather than invent missing facts

Dismissal without prejudice means the court has not adjudicated the merits; it does not guarantee that another forum will accept the claim or that a limitations period remains open. For an action removed from state court, 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c) generally requires remand when subject-matter jurisdiction is lacking before final judgment. The 30-day deadline for other removal objections is not a 30-day waiver rule for subject-matter jurisdiction.

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1653, a plaintiff can correct a defective allegation when the necessary jurisdictional facts actually existed. For example, an allegation of Texas residence may be amended to allege Texas citizenship if domicile and United States citizenship support that correction. Section 1653 cannot make a Texas plaintiff diverse from a defendant who actually was a Texas citizen at filing. Rule 21 may permit dismissal of a dispensable nondiverse party in appropriate circumstances; that possibility requires a separate party analysis rather than rewriting citizenship facts.

Pending action versus final judgment. Nonwaivability does not mean every final judgment can be attacked forever. Finality rules limit collateral attacks after judgment; the ordinary Rule 12(h)(3) question concerns a court discovering the defect while the litigation remains pending.

Answer these questions from memory before moving to the practice problems.

A Recall check

What facts establish a new domicile?
Physical presence in the new state plus intent to remain there indefinitely.
What establishes a corporation's principal place of business?
Its actual nerve center, where high-level officers direct, control, and coordinate corporate activities.
What four requirements govern an embedded federal issue?
The issue must be necessarily raised, actually disputed, substantial to the federal system, and resolvable without disrupting the federal-state balance.
Which citizenship applies to an estate's legal representative?
The decedent's citizenship under Section 1332(c)(2).
What distinguishes a defective allegation from missing jurisdiction?
An allegation can be corrected when jurisdictional facts existed; amendment cannot create facts that were absent.
COMMON MISTAKE

Common mistakes

These choices become attractive when a familiar fact is assigned to the wrong jurisdictional rule.

Table 10. Confusions that change the answer
Tempting choiceWhy it attractsFact that settles the issue
Any decisive federal issue establishes jurisdictionThe defense may determine who winsThe federal issue appears only in a defense
An LLC is a citizen wherever headquarteredThe corporation's nerve-center rule feels transferableThe party is unincorporated and has members
A combined demand over $75,000 always sufficesThe complaint presents one overall disputeSeparate plaintiffs own separate claims
A late jurisdictional objection is waivedOther Rule 12 objections can be forfeitedThe challenge concerns subject matter under Rule 12(h)(3)
A federal court applies only federal substantive lawThe court belongs to the federal systemThe claim enters through diversity rather than a federal cause of action
ALGO

Approach

Use this sequence to build a short jurisdictional analysis from the pleaded claims and the parties' actual facts.

Separate the claims. Identify each cause of action and the relief requested; distinguish claims from defenses and counterclaims.
Test federal-question jurisdiction. Apply Section 1331 to the well-pleaded claim; consider embedded issues or complete preemption only when supported.
Build the citizenship inventory. Use filing-date domicile, corporate citizenship, or every unincorporated owner's citizenship; compare opposing sides.
Value the controversy. Require more than $75,000 for ordinary diversity, count legally available relief, and aggregate only where permitted.
Check additional jurisdictional routes. Apply Section 1367 or a special statute separately, then consider narrow jurisdictional exceptions.
Select the procedural result. Distinguish dismissal of an original action, remand of a removed action, and correction of defective allegations.
QUIZ

Self-check quiz

Question 1

A Texas citizen brings a nonfrivolous federal statutory claim against another Texas citizen seeking $18,000. The statute creates a private cause of action and has no separate jurisdictional amount requirement. Which is correct?

  1. Jurisdiction fails because both parties are Texas citizens.
  2. Jurisdiction fails because less than $75,000 is disputed.
  3. Section 1331 supports jurisdiction despite shared citizenship and the amount.
  4. Jurisdiction exists only if the defendant consents.

Question 2

A United States citizen domiciled in Spain sues a Texas citizen in federal court on a state-law claim for $200,000. No other jurisdictional basis exists. What is the result?

  1. Alienage jurisdiction exists because the plaintiff lives abroad.
  2. Ordinary diversity jurisdiction is absent because the plaintiff is neither a state citizen nor a foreign citizen.
  3. Diversity exists because Spain and Texas are different places.
  4. Jurisdiction exists because the defendant has state citizenship.

Question 3

Using Table 5, a completely diverse plaintiff demands $68,000 in compensatory damages, $10,000 in attorney fees expressly recoverable under the contract, and $2,000 in litigation costs. All recovery demands are made in good faith and legally available. What amount counts?

  1. $68,000
  2. $70,000
  3. $80,000
  4. $78,000

Question 4

A Texas citizen sues a corporation for $140,000 under state law. The corporation is incorporated in Delaware, its officers actually direct it from Oklahoma, and most of its factories are in Texas. Assuming no other defect, which is correct?

  1. Diversity exists because the corporation is a citizen of Delaware and Oklahoma.
  2. Diversity fails because most factories are in Texas.
  3. Diversity exists because only incorporation matters.
  4. Diversity fails unless the corporation consents to jurisdiction.

Question 5

A defendant removes a state-law action. Sixty days after the notice of removal is filed, but before final judgment, the federal court determines that both parties were Texas citizens when the action began and at removal. No federal question or special statutory basis exists. What should the court do?

  1. Keep the action because more than 30 days have elapsed.
  2. Dismiss the claim with prejudice on the merits.
  3. Remand the action to state court.
  4. Keep the action if both parties now prefer federal court.
ANSWERS

Answer key

Question 1 - Answer: C. A nonfrivolous claim created by federal law falls within Section 1331 without a general dollar minimum. A imports the diversity citizenship requirement; B imports the diversity amount requirement; D incorrectly makes consent necessary to an existing statutory basis.

Question 2 - Answer: B. A United States citizen domiciled abroad is outside the ordinary state-citizen and foreign-citizen categories needed here. A treats residence as foreign nationality; C substitutes geography for statutory citizenship; D overlooks the need for qualifying citizenship on both sides.

Question 3 - Answer: D. The $68,000 damages demand and $10,000 contract-authorized fee demand total $78,000; litigation costs are excluded. A omits recoverable fees; B counts costs while omitting fees; C improperly includes all three components.

Question 4 - Answer: A. Incorporation supplies Delaware citizenship, and the actual nerve center supplies Oklahoma citizenship, leaving no shared citizenship with the Texas plaintiff. B substitutes factory concentration for direction and control; C omits the principal-place-of-business citizenship; D confuses subject-matter jurisdiction with a consent question.

Question 5 - Answer: C. A removed action lacking subject-matter jurisdiction must generally be remanded before final judgment under Section 1447(c). A applies the deadline for other removal defects; B incorrectly adjudicates the merits; D treats party preference as a jurisdictional grant.

RAPID

Rapid review

  • Federal defense → does not ordinarily create Section 1331 jurisdiction.
  • Federal cause of action → no general jurisdictional dollar floor.
  • Individual state citizenship → United States citizenship plus domicile.
  • Corporate party → incorporation citizenship plus one nerve center.
  • LLC or partnership → trace every member or partner.
  • Ordinary diversity amount → greater than $75,000, excluding interest and costs.
  • One plaintiff and one defendant → unrelated claims may be combined.
  • Separate plaintiffs' independent claims → no ordinary aggregation.
  • Missing subject-matter jurisdiction → consent and silence do not cure it.
  • Removed action without jurisdiction → remand rather than a merits judgment.
  • Procedural rule authorizes a claim arrangement → identify a separate jurisdictional grant.
  • Puerto Rico or District of Columbia domicile → Section 1332 includes these locations within States.
  • State itself versus municipality → state has no diversity citizenship; municipality ordinarily does.
  • Alternative remedies for one recovery → do not add mutually exclusive awards.
  • Valid demand reduced after filing → jurisdiction ordinarily remains.
  • Original federal plaintiff recovers less than $75,000 → discretionary cost consequences may follow under Section 1332(b).

See also: Supplemental Jurisdiction and Removal; Personal Jurisdiction and Service; Venue Transfer and Forum Dismissal; Erie and Federal Governing Law; Joinder and Class Actions.

References

  • Constitution of the United States, Article III. United States.
  • United States Code, Title 28, §§ 1331, 1332, 1335, 1338, 1359, 1367, 1447, 1653, and 2201-2202. United States House of Representatives, Office of the Law Revision Counsel, current text.
  • Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rules 8, 12, 21, and 22. United States Courts, 2025.
  • Gunn v. Minton. Supreme Court of the United States, 2013.
  • Employee Retirement Income Security Act, Section 502(a), codified at 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a). United States Congress.
  • MBE Subject Matter Outline, Civil Procedure. National Conference of Bar Examiners, current outline.
End of your free lesson

Keep going with the full Texas Bar Exam Prep Course

You just studied the way members do, in the same lesson interface. Full access unlocks every lesson, the question bank and flashcards for a full year.

Up next with full access1.1.2 - Supplemental Jurisdiction and Removal

One payment per program